NZ POLITICS DAILY: Blog wars over race, rape & freedom of expression
Bryce Edwards | Friday November 22, 2013
A vicious blog war is raging over the successful campaign against Radiolive broadcasters Willie Jackson and John Tamihere. After blogger Giovanni Tiso, succeeded in getting Jackson and Tamihere taken off the air via a campaign focused on the radio station’s advertisers, bloggers have been vigorously debating whether this amounts to some kind of economic censorship that threatens free expression and media freedom. The debate has also encompassed highly-contested arguments about racism, feminism and identity politics in general.
Ex-Act MP Donna Awatere Huata has blogged to accuse Giovanni Tiso of ‘racism’ because he targeted the Maori broadcasters and not the equivalent pakeha talkback hosts – see: Celebrate, We're White, Tonight! Its a Celebration! Awatere Huata’s highly provocative post asks the question: ‘How did an issue involving mainly white girls, white boys, white police, white politicians, and white RadioLive officials end up with only two scalps, both of them Maori?’ Tiso responds to the racial allegations against him in the comments section.
This particular blog post epitomises how the debate about the ‘Roast Busters’, rape, and the Radiolive controversy has descended into an ‘identity politics’ scrap. Identity politics is, of course, the prioritisation of a person’s identity – ethnicity, gender, sexuality, etc – over issues of ideology, and especially economics and class. Awatere Huata is one of the original ‘identity politics’ activists, having led the Maori nationalist movement in the 1980s, before taking her radicalism to what some might say is its logical conclusion in becoming a neoliberal politician in the 1990s, before falling from grace in the 2000s. She’s back now to push Maori nationalism, and it seems to be galling for other identity politics activists to be on the receiving end of her racial allegations.
But is Awatere Huata simply an aberration amongst Maori activists? It’s telling that the president of the Mana Party, Annette Sykes went online to endorse Awatere Huata’s analysis as a ‘Great deconstruction of how the real issue got deflected’ in the Radiolive/Roast Busters scandal. Sykes has proclaimed that Awatere Huata’s blog post is the ‘First piece that deals with the race dimension and scapegoating while the real sideshow the police inaction remains unaddressed’.
In defence of a political sphere full of expression
In contrast to much of the vicious and nasty identity politics debates at the moment, the latest installment in the debate about Radiolive taking Jackson and Tamihere off the air is possibly the most rational and level-headed. Civil liberties lawyer Graeme Edgeler has blogged his views about Giovanni Tiso’s campaign, and indeed against all such advertising consumer boycotts – see his in-depth and thought-provoking post, Think it possible that you may be mistaken. Edgeler essentially argues that such campaigns are dangerous because they ultimately reduce debate in the public sphere. It’s a powerful argument and a must-read blog post.
Edgeler isn’t the first to raise concerns about the impact of the campaign against the broadcasters. One of the first was Prof Andrew Geddis of the University of Otago law school – see: Of speech and its consequences. He was followed by others such as Chris Trotter, who wrote a highly controversial column, Disturbing Precedent). Since then, Radio New Zealand’s Mediawatch programme investigated whether the successful campaign against the talkback hosts amounted to ‘a real threat to media freedom?’ – you can listen to the 36-minute document here: Mediawatch for 17 November 2013.
The original boycott organiser, Giovanni Tiso, has blogged a very interesting defence of his position – see: The business of free speech. This follows on from his previous statements on the issue (This is what rape culture looks like and A surge in the tide). And Tiso and his campaign was also profiled in the Hearld – see Phil Taylor’s Roast Busters: When people power works.
Danyl Mclauchlan has also blogged in favour of the campaign – see: Advertising boycotts and freedom of speech. He believes that ‘freedom of speech’ is essentially limited to not being imprisoned for your views, and he approves of boycotts because it’s ‘just good ‘ol capitalism working as designed’. In a somewhat more inflammatory blog post, Mclauchlan also essentially blames rape apologies on people like Chris Trotter – or ‘Trotterism’ – see: Baby it’s creepy outside. Mclauchlan and Tiso both declare that they’re not worried about the homogenising impact of increased boycotts of media voices, because they believe that New Zealand doesn’t have any decent leftwing political commentators anyhow. In agreement, it seems, is Scott Yorke – see his post, Killing kittens.
Leftwing infighting and identity politics
The heightened tensions over the various personal accusations being thrown around, especially on the left of the politics, has led Martyn Bradbury to make a plea for it all to stop – see: Why I think John Key might win 2014 election. But Bradbury’s post only raised the temperature in the debate, especially with his accusations about Green Party activists (‘Emerald Stormtroopers’) being the worst offenders. He also blogged, however, to disagree with Trotter’s stance on the silencing of Jackson and Tamihere – see: To my dear learned colleague, Chris Trotter – you are terribly wrong and I disagree strongly. He declared that ‘what is required now is for the male commentators to step back, shut up and listen to the women and whanau’.
Another identity politics activist – who has resigned from Bradbury’s Daily Blog has responded with two dissenting blog posts – Just one tiny thing and Ladies, step up to the platform – just not to the mic – the last of which, is a critique of the lack of diversity on Bradbury’s Daily Blog.
Trotter has responded to Bradbury with the blog post, The Finer Points of Freedom, which calls for more debate, not less. He’s also blogged today about the identity politics part of the debate, arguing in favour of universalism and against the ‘perversion of identity’ – see: The Equations Of Progressive Algebra. Trotter declares: ‘I am at a loss to explain the New Zealand Left’s extraordinary ability to demonize (and attempt to silence) not only its enemies, but also its own. The accusations and recriminations that have marred the Left’s discussion and debate of the Roastbusters Scandal have left many people of a progressive persuasion feeling disturbed, disgusted and depressed’. See also, Alan Alach’s With ‘friends’ like these.
There are plenty of other issues and debates at the moment concerning ethnicity and allegations of racism. Labour’s Sua William Sio has started a campaign on Facebook entitled Stop the Racism TVNZ, with the demand for ‘More ethnically diverse personel in mainstream media’.
The Labour MP’s campaign follows on from an allegedly racist joke made by TVNZ commissioning editor Andrew Shaw – which is reported in Steve Deane’s TVNZ defends executive after cracks at Auckland hit a nerve. For more on this, see Morgan Godfery’s blog posts, Taking the piss at TVNZ: why Andrew Shaw makes combating racism harder and Living in an age of racism without racists: Andrew Shaw and TVNZ part II.
John Drinnan’s column today about media matters deals with the media’s vulnerability to critiques on social media – in particular the TVNZ and RadioLive controversies. He reports Canterbury University’s senior Donald Matheson analysis of the role of Twitter in influencing media and advertising. On a similar issue, see Liam Dann’s Why I love my Twitter addiction.
There are some major issues in the justice system relating to ethnicity, which are explained in Martin van Beynen’s article, How much should courts discount for being Maori? For other very interesting comments on the issue, see TV3’s Justice system 'biased against Maori', Stuff’s Race-based sentence won't wash, says Peters, and Caleb Morgan’s Fabian Mika’s lawyer is (mostly) right.
We might also soon be debating ownership of another resource – see TV3’s Sharples: 4G spectrum is 'taonga'.
Biculturalism amounts to a false promise for Maori according to Elizabeth Rata in Democracy and Tribalism. She says that economic inequality for Maori has worsened alongside the rise of biculturalism, and that the benefits of colonisation are being undone by retribalisation in which only an elite is empowered. Also, on the changing nature of Maoridom, see Acushla Deanne O’Carroll’s Virtual marae? No thanks.
Finally, for a very interesting view on the role of Maori culture from yet another politician who grappled with issues of identity politics, see Tau Henare’s blog post, Culture – all the good stuff.
Peter Wilson (Newswire):
Matthew Hooton (NBR): National must gift East Coast Bays to Colin Craig (paywalled)
The Standard: Coat-tail of Many Colours
Tim Watkin (Pundit): New boundaries = new strategies for major parties
Audrey Young (Herald): Bennett asset to Nats
Audrey Young (Herald): Boundary changes spark Nats' rethink
Vernon Small (Stuff): Bennett won't make way for Craig
Glenn Conway (Stuff): Two MPs may lose Christchurch seats
Daily Blog: From Westie to Shore Girl – the urbanization of Paula Bennett: How the Left should use MMP tactically
RadioLive: No Upper Harbour deal for Colin Craig
Grant Duncan (Policy Matters): Upper Harbour: crooked as a dog's hind-leg
Cameron Slater (Whaleoil): Are the Bugger’s Muddle Stitching Up Upper Harbour?
Cameron Slater (Whaleoil): National Selection 101 – Don’t run “for the experience”
Felix Marwick (Newstalk): Flavell rules out merger, and Harawira isn't happy
Blog wars over race, rape and freedom of expression
Graeme Edgeler (Public Address): Think it possible that you may be mistaken
Donna Awatere Huata (Desperately seeking Amy): Celebrate, We're White, Tonight! Its a Celebration!
Elizabeth Rata (NZCPR): Democracy and Tribalism
Acushla Deanne O’Carroll: Virtual marae? No thanks
Muriel Newman (NZCPR): Constitutional Rights & Tribal Ambition
John Drinnan: Metro magazine's heading into city
Scott Yorke (Imperator Fish): But what about my rights?
MP pay rise
Hamish Rutherford (Stuff): Politicians' pay rises and more on way
Isaac Davison (Herald): MPs to get 'restrained' 2.2% pay rise
No Right Turn: "Restrained"
David Farrar (Kiwiblog): 2013 Salaries Determination for MPs
Isaac Davison (Herald): MP pay rises revealed
Stuff: PM gets $9200 pay rise
Tim Watkin (Pundit): Deal or no deal? New Zealand's oil & gas choice offers great risk & reward
Newswire: 'Secret' oil report was available online
David Farrar (Kiwiblog): The secret report that has been online for two years
Gordon Campbell (Scoop): In the latest failure of regulatory oversight of Anadarko
Thomas Mead (TV3): Oil drilling comes with serious risk – Labour
Isaac Davison and Kurt Bayer (Herald): Anadarko Oil spill risk kept secret – Labour
Glen Conway (Stuff): Risks of deep sea drilling kept secret: Labour
No Right Turn: National lied to us about drilling
Martyn Bradbury (Daily Blog): Gov caught censoring report on deep sea oil dangers: Why friends don’t let friends vote National
Isaac Davison (Herald): NZ rivers face increasing pollution – watchdog
Olivia Wannan (Stuff): Waterways will get worse – Commissioner
Listener: Editorial: something in the water
Amanda Gillies (TV3): WikiLeaks: US may have spied on ordinary Kiwis
Newswire: Greens question Key on NSA spying in NZ
Bryan Gould (Herald): If TPP signed, don't say I didn't warn you
Jordan Carter (Herald): Hands off our right to share digital information
Hamish Rutherford (Stuff): PM: Asset sales referendum won't go Government's way
Grant Duncan (Policy matters): Why the asset-sales referendum is not a waste of time and money
Jane Clifton (Listener): Flights of fancy (paywalled)
Rob Hosking (NBR): Air New Zealand - the politics of a non-fire sale (paywalled)
Matthew Theunissen (Herald): Voting begins in asset sale referendum
Tracy Watkins (Stuff): State-owned firm's ultimatum raises concern
Media Training NZ: Asset sales issue highlights important media training lesson
Viv Logie (Greymouth Star): Families appeal to TVNZ to withhold mine body photo
Matthew Dallas (Manawatu Standard): Compensation when it's due
Stacey Kirk (Stuff): Roast Busters petition handed to MPs
Cut Your Hair: Fabian Mika’s lawyer is (mostly) right
Jo Moir (Stuff): More charter schools to come
Brian Fallow (Herald): Why NZ's return to investment in tertiary education is so low
Liam Hyslop (Stuff): Party distances itself from Titford
Stacey Kirk (Stuff): Convicted rapist's mayoral campaign to be examined
Rebecca Quilliam (Herald): Jones: Titford a 'destructive' influence
Andrew Geddis (Pundit): Now in the second year of Nebuchadnezzar's reign, Nebuchadnezzar had dreams
David Cunliffe (The Ruminator): Them’s fighting words
Duncan Garner (RadioLive): Tone down the tosser, Cunliffe
TV3: Sharples: 4G spectrum is 'taonga'
Claire Trevett (Herald): PM's softly softly on Sri Lanka may just work
Chris Trotter (Daily Blog): The Equations Of Progressive Algebra
Mark Blackham (Political Business): Liberals aren’t as unique as they think
Sue Kedgley (Herald): Let's turn up the heat on trans fats
Heather McCracken (Herald): Internet study: Kiwis left on wrong side of 'digital divide'
Cameron Slater (Whaleoil): TVNZ’s resident racist hey hey Andy fails to amuse
Michael Fox (Stuff): Warning over troop drawdown
Andrew Dean (The Aotearoa Project): Close Your Eyes and Begin to Walk Forward: A Path Away from Inequality in Aotearoa
Matt Nolan (Idealog): Some ‘inequality’ is good (and other unpopular statements
David Kennedy (Local Bodies): The Greens, A Credible Alternative
Toby Manhire (Herald): Selfies more about sharing than self-love
Karl du Fresne: Regime change at Radio New Zealand
Wayne Hope (Daily Blog): The 150 years the New Zealand Herald didn’t want you to see
Hamish Rutherford and Stacey Kirk (Stuff): Air NZ share haul dismissed
Mike Hosking (Newstalk ZB): Anadarko protestors just looking for a fight
Barry Soper (Newstalk ZB): Key, a legend in his own lunchtime
Rachel Smalley (Newstalk ZB): Time to take care of our unborn children
Barry Soper (Newstalk ZB): A group grapple with John Key
Mike Hosking (Newstalk ZB): Cunliffe is preaching to the converted
Olivia Carville (Stuff): Waiting list 'double-speak'
Anna Powles: A seat at the top table
Christine Stephens: Our greying population