AIG blames Hanover's broker for policy mishap

Insurance giant – and All Blacks jersey sponsor – AIG is blaming an insurance broker's misinterpretation for Hanover's "misconceived" court case.

Hanover Group has taken High Court action against AIG, known as Chartis Insurance New Zealand, over its $20 million policy for directors and officers (D&O).

Hanover claims it was misled by AIG into thinking it had full prospectus liability cover, which is crucial for the directors of three Hanover finance companies – Hanover Finance, United Finance and Hanover Capital – now facing civil claims from the Financial Markets Authority.

However, AIG lawyer Andrea Challis will tell the High Court today Hanover should be suing its broker, Apex Insurance Brokers, not AIG.

Its case is "misconcieved", she says.

In October 2007, she says AIG offered to include the latest Hanover Finance prospectus as an exception to a $400 million upper limit exclusion for prospectus capital raisings.

"Unfortunately, Hanover finds itself in the position it is in as a result of its broker and agent misinterpreting AIG's 25 October email," Ms Challis's submissions say.

"It was not AIG who misrepresented anything to Apex or Hanover. In this instance, Hanover's remedy is against the broker, not AIG."

She says there was no common intention between AIG and Hanover to provide unlimited prospectus cover in the 2007-08 year.

"Two commercially sophisticated parties were involved in arms-length negotiations which addressed the question of the extent of prospectus liability cover and cover generally.

"In the circumstances, it is difficult to see where or how any deception by AIG arises."

AIG plans to call four witnesses: Vince Barker, the underwriter at the time; Mr Barker's assistant, George Springhall; underwriter Ella Langdon; and Judith Schwarz, an expert underwriter/broker.

About 36,500 investors were affected when Hanover Finance froze $550 million of assets in July 2008.

Got a question about this story? Leave it in Comments & Questions below.

This article is tagged with the following keywords. Find out more about MyNBR Tags

NZ Market Snapshot


Sym Price Change
USD 0.6664 0.0018 0.27%
AUD 0.9233 0.0030 0.33%
EUR 0.5856 0.0016 0.27%
GBP 0.4365 0.0005 0.11%
HKD 5.1656 0.0142 0.28%
JPY 79.7030 0.1240 0.16%


Commodity Price Change Time
Gold Index 1165.3 0.900 2015-10-13T00:
Oil Brent 49.7 -0.560 2015-10-13T00:
Oil Nymex 46.7 -0.910 2015-10-13T00:
Silver Index 15.9 0.040 2015-10-13T00:


Symbol Open High Last %
NZX 50 5702.8 5728.5 5702.8 0.26%
NASDAQ 4809.2 4858.3 4838.6 -0.87%
DAX 10106.7 10107.9 10119.8 -0.86%
DJI 17113.5 17172.8 17131.9 -0.29%
FTSE 6371.2 6371.2 6371.2 -0.45%
HKSE 22398.8 22508.8 22600.5 -0.70%
NI225 18106.7 18126.4 18234.7 -1.77%