Chief Justice Dame Sian Elias has floated the prospect of the Supreme Court restraining the government to selling no more than 25 percent of state-owned power companies while it sorts out a long-term solution to Maori claims to freshwater rights under the Treaty of Waitangi.
Her comments came at the end of the first morning of two days' scheduled hearings on the Maori Council's challenge to the government's partial assets sales policy.
It followed lengthy questioning of the council's lawyer, Colin Carruthers QC, about the responsibility for finding a means of redress for Maori grievances lies with the government rather than Maori claimants.
"A protective mechanism could be that the Crown will only divest 25 percent until there's some resolution," Chief Justice Elias says.
While comments in the course of a hearing cannot be claimed as evidence of the court's eventual decision, such an outcome would put a serious dent in the government's plans to raise as much as $4.85 billion from the sale of up to 49 percent of MightyRiverPower and Meridian Energy, valued at $3.3 billion and $6.5 billion, respectively, before the end of this year.
For a sale of just 25 percent of the two, the government might reap only around $2.4 billion. It intends committing capital raised by the sales to public infrastructure and facilities instead of increasing government borrowing.
Mr Carruthers had argued earlier that even with majority control of 51 percent, the government would be weakened in its ability to force Treaty settlement terms on partially privatised companies, leaving Maori capacity to seek redress "significantly impaired".
The Maori Council is appealing a High Court decision not to allow the Cabinet's decision to proceed with asset sales to be judicially reviewed.
Mr Carruthers expects to complete his submissions early this afternoon, with David Goddard QC to open the Crown's submissions before the end of the day. The hearing is set down for two days.
This article is tagged with the following keywords. Find out more about MyNBR Tags
- New Hampshire primaries: Trump, Sanders win by wide margins
- PayPal ‘on shaky ground’ as it pulls service from second Netflix unblocker popular with Kiwis
- Chief Justice Elias and hubby Fletcher hit with wet bus ticket over stock in lake
- Housing NZ directors get 63% pay hike
- Showdown at the ETS corral - part one
Most listened to
- Green party co-leader James Shaw and Business NZ's John Carnegie go head-to-head on the ETS review
- Cream Trading CEO Kevin O'Sullivan on why dairy companies might want to sign up to the new trading platform
- Paul Brislen on the merits of "cutting off the money" versus Netflix' technical attempts to shut-out unblockers
- Westpac's Dominick Stephens says dairy prices are still a major concern, despite El Niño fears fading
- London School of Economics Professor John Kay discusses financial regulatory shortcomings