Company to run Auckland prison "linked to violence"
Overseas prisons run by the company that has been chosen to manage Mt Eden Auckland Central Remand Prison have been linked to violence and overcrowding, the Green Party says.
Serco, a British company with operations in Europe, the Middle East, Asia-Pacific and North America, was today named as the winner of a contract to manage the Auckland prison.
The prison is the first to be privatised since the Government passed the Corrections Amendment Act late last year, allowing private sector organisations to tender for contracts to manage prisons.
Ms Collins said Serco was selected over two other overseas companies, G4S and Geo. There were no bids from New Zealand companies.
She said the Corrections Department felt Serco would provide the best opportunity to make save money but also to give effective rehabilitation for prisoners.
"There's a very innovative contract, they've looked at Serco's operations overseas, and they're very happy with it. It's also going to be substantially cheaper than what Corrections can actually provide."
However, Green Party MP David Clendon said international media reports had linked Serco-run detention centres with violence, lack of adequate health care and overcrowding.
"Do we really want Serco running our prisons? Just last month there was a violent brawl at one of their Australian detention centres which has been reported as being linked to overcrowding."
Serco operates six adult prisons and two youth offender centres in the United Kingdom and Australia and 22 immigration detention facilities in Australia.
They include Sydney's Villawood detention centre, where last month 10 detainees sewed their lips shut after an asylum seeker committed suicide.
Mr Clendon said research from New South Wales suggested the focus on profit in privately run prisons meant prisoner safety was compromised.
"The international evidence shows that the Government needs to seriously reconsider its policy of getting private corporations to run our prisons," he said.
"Private prisons have to make a profit, which means either cut backs on staffing levels and rehabilitation, or charging more per prisoner, as we saw with the Auckland remand prison last time it was privately run."
New Zealand Public Service Association (NZPSA) national secretary Richard Wagstaff said that while the union strongly opposed privately run prisons, it would work to build a constructive relationship with the new employer.
"That will involve guarding against any reduction in the conditions and health and safety provisions of our prison guard members. Where possible we will aim to enhance these."
Mr Wagstaff said studies had show that when savings were made from privately run prisons it was because the private operators were paying staff poorer wages.
"We will be doing everything possible to ensure this does not happen. That would be a very bad outcome for the prison system and the wider community as well as for our members," he said.
Ms Collins said Serco had a number ideas for saving money, including new technology and changes to staff rostering.
The prison would operate within the current Corrections framework, and all prisoners would remain the responsibility of the Department of Corrections, she said.
Serco would have to comply with all relevant New Zealand legislation and international obligations.
A six-year contract with Serco was to be signed by January 31, and the site fully handed over by August 2, Ms Collins said.
Signup to free NBR email alerts here
Share
Delicious
Digg
StumbleUpon
Reddit
Google
Yahoo
Technorati
Scoopit















Comments and questions13
Serco's web of influence includes air traffic control, nuclear arsenals, and time itself. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QwUHifop67M
Good, private company will save the Government heap of monies...
How can the company be cheaper than the government in this? They need to be at least cost +15%. That margin has got to come from somewhere. Voodoo accounting.
Its easy Profit, they under-staff the prisons, then the state picks up the bill as the Police gets called out more often to deal with riot situations.
Typically the state does is try and penalise the company if riots happen again- so the company responds by hushing up any problems.
PPP in prisons has been tried & failed overseas. There doesn't seem to any real world acknowledgement that this is the case, there is no talk of any controls from Ministers about how they will prevent what has happened in the US happening here.
Imagine what even a portion of the millions, now going offshore with a foreign corporate, could achieve if invested in our communities to provide preventative, rehabilitative and reintegration services.
I would support the privatization of our prisons if contracts were instead awarded to collaborative community and iwi based operators. We have the people and resources to address our world class imprisonment rate (3rd highest on the planet) ourselves.
Social Impact Performance Bonds | http://www.changemakers.com/en-us/node/84886
Well done, Serco. Let's get NZ prisons back to leaders in the world where we used to be. The currrent mob can't do it
Serco has a long history in NZ, and has failed to retain key contracts due to lack of service and a profit before people philosophy.
How will the government (or anyone) monitor the performance of a private company?
All the important data (especially financial) will be kept secret as "commercially sensitive", there will be no Ombudsman oversight, no Official Information requests allowed, no Government Minister will be able to hold them to account.
They can build in programmes of "training" to provide cheap labour for commercial companies while genuine companies hiring non-prisoner staff will pay the bare minimum wage and still struggle to compete.
Where does the GST go, Ms Profit at 08:38 pm on December 14, 2010?
Why be kind to those who have already committed multiple offences against society and experience shows are very unlikely to rehabilitate.
The only consistent achievement of prisons is keeping miscreants out of society for the period of their incarceration.
Bring on Serco and make prisons less of an all expenses paid holiday!
Para 5: 'make or save' money?
Doomed to Failure - the conditions in Serco prisons are so bad that no one will commit crime, therefore no prisoners - no money for Serco - they will go bust - total failure.
As the great Tui said...
when they get out they WONT want to go back in!! that'll save the govenment some money.
Post new comment or question
To share this article, click on a service below