Member log in

Copyright abusers get three warnings before termination

Internet New Zealand has welcomed a new bill changing copyright laws but says the penalty of suspending a user's account for breaches won't work.

On Tuesday, Commerce Minister Simon Power introduced a bill repealing Section 92A of the Copyright Act.

The Copyright (Infringing File Sharing) Amendment Bill replaced the section with a three strikes regime intended to to deter illegal file sharing.

The previous government's attempt to police copyright infringement was withdrawn after many internet user groups complained it was too draconian and would result in people being unfairly cut off by their internet service providers (ISPs).

Now there will be the three warning system after which offenders will face tough penalties or suspension.

Announcing the bill, Mr Power said the three notices would educate users about illegal file sharing and it provided effective methods for copyright owners to enforce their copyright.

"It ensures that file sharers are given adequate warnings that unauthorised sharing of copyright works is illegal."

The bill extended the jurisdiction of the Copyright Tribunal, enabling it to hear complaints and award penalties of up to $15,000 based on the amount of damage sustained by the copyright owner.

Mr Power said the bill would enable copyright owners to seek the suspension of internet accounts through the District Court for up to six months.

"It's important that account holders are given a reasonable time to stop infringing before enforcement takes place. The bill prescribes timeframes so account holders have the opportunity to address illegal file sharing activity occurring on their internet connection before enforcement action is taken."

Users would have the chance to challenge notices and may request hearings at the Copyright Tribunal to contest infringement claims.

Regulations outlining awards the tribunal may make would be drafted after the bill passed.

"Online copyright infringement is a problem for everyone, but especially for the creative industry, which has experienced significant declines in revenue as file sharing has become more prevalent," Mr Power said.

Internet NZ said the bill was good but said suspending people's internet accounts would not work.

"Internet users would simply start a new account at another ISP. While suspension would require an order of the District Court, it is still unworkable and unnecessary. InternetNZ will argue strongly that suspension be deleted by the Select Committee," the organisation's policy director Jordan Carter said.

He said definitions in the bill needed to be clear and workable.

"Overall, the draft Bill puts the mistakes of the original Section 92A behind us, and allows for a workable regime that will reduce copyright infringement in New Zealand," Mr Carter said.

More by NZPA

More on:

Comments and questions
2

"Online copyright infringement is a problem for everyone, but especially for the creative industry, which has experienced significant declines in revenue as file sharing has become more prevalent," Mr Power said.

Is that right?

If this is true, can Mr. Power show us the source for this claim of declining revenue?

I would be most interested to see it, given that revenues in the US and worldwide, as reported by the IFPI and the MPAA, have shown record profits.

This "decline" seems to be as real as the claim that file-sharing is a problem for "everyone". I guess if "everyone" is defined as the special interests buying their laws, that works.

Its simple as this when you sign up for an ISP you are entitled to
download/upload whatever the content maybe and as a ISP they
obey that or they might get a little fee and if this comes to law
just think what they have to change to make it the Privacy Act for
knowing who the subscriber is (Similar to your doctor cant tell the other person about another person.
ISP Customer Usage Contract with the ISP for could cost
the ISP alot of money and knowing the Goverment it will
come out of our tax payer funds so i Simon Power uses his brain
for once in his political life and relizes how much will this effect us as New Zealands. and another fact we are following the U.S in this and they are not going to do this law now so least they have the brains

Post new comment or question

Login to use your NBR member name
Full HTML is not supported but you can use the following tags in your comments:
Link: <url>link</url>
Quote: <quote>text</quote>