Cosgrove calls $17K property developer donation story a 'Brownlee smear'
Labour MP Clayton Cosgrove says he is a long-standing friend of a property developer who donated $17,500 to his campaign at the last election.
The donation came after Mr Cosgrove drafted a private members’ bill which would have allowed developer Mike Dormer to go ahead with a project stopped by the Christchurch District Plan.
Speaking on TV3’s The Nation programme at the weekend, Mr Cosgrove said he was a longstanding friend of Mr Dormer.
“We go back about 12 years,” he said. “He's a friend of my family, I know his family well.
“He's a respected person, I'm proud to say I'm a mate of his.”
Mr Cosgrove claimed the report on The Nation had been “shopped around” by Earthquake Recovery Minister Gerry Brownlee in an attempt to smear him.
But the programme presenter, Rachel Smalley, said that no one from Front Page, the production company which produces The Nation, had spoken to Mr Brownlee or anyone from his office.
Mr Dormer’s company, Independent Fisheries, is one a number of parties who have a legal action against Mr Brownlee on this issue now before the High Court in Christchurch.
In 2008, Independent Fisheries bought 22ha of land at Styx Mill, north of Christchurch Airport, and in Mr Cosgrove’s then electorate of Waimakiriri with the intention of developing it for houses.
But the company became frustrated at restrictions on the development imposed at the behest of Christchurch Airport.
Other landowners in the same area were also concerned at the tight noise boundaries around the airport which prohibited residential development.
In June 2009 Mr Cosgrove convened a public meeting about the boundaries and announced that he was preparing a private members’ bill to counter them.
His bill would have required landowners within the noise boundaries to forfeit any right to object to airport noise. In return, residential development would get a go ahead.
Mr Dormer described the bill as “win win” and “outstanding”.
And five months later, in November 2009, Independent Fisheries donated $2500 to Mr Cosgrove's campaign.
"I had discussion with all landowners. We set up a group of landowners across the board who had legal support, some who didn’t. I was leading negotiations on behalf of over a 100 constituents with the International Airport and others, for years on this," Mr Cosgrove said.
After the Christchurch earthquake in September 2010, Mr Cosgrove withdrew his bill from the private members’ list of bills in Parliament.
In June 2011, he got another donation from Independent Fisheries. This time it was for $15,000, making a total of $17,500, one of the highest sums given to any individual MP at the last election.
And in August 2011, Mr Cosgrove issued a press release advocating passage of his bill as a way of freeing up land for desperately needed sections in Christchurch.
But he vigorously denied that there was any connection between the bill and its obvious benefits for Independent Fisheries and the donations.
“I've never accepted a donation with any preconditions and I have never been offered a donation with any preconditions,” he said.
He rejected the suggestion that it could appear that he had a conflict of interest.
There would have been a conflict of interest from any person, and I have people donate money to me in support from all political persuasions,” he said.
“There would be a conflict of interest if it came with preconditions, and by the way every MP receives donations.
“There would be a very bad look and a lack of judgement if those donations were hidden and not declared.
“There is transparency here, and the reason you can question me is because I declared them.”























Comments and questions15
Smoke…. Fire…
Walks like a duck… sounds like a duck….
Birds of a feather… Aussie unions and corrupt politicians…
Sure these “donations” didn’t have any Preconditions to them – just like they didn’t with Liu’s “donations for passports” fiasco – it was all a big mistake right?
Shearer needs to stand Cosgrove down whilst he calls for full transparency and for the sake of Cosgrove’s, Shearer’s, the Labour Party’s credibility and the integrity of the NZ political scene – Shearer should ask the AG to investigate yet another Labour Party and Labour MP cash/bribes for elections/legislation.
Bright sunlight will help with the disinfectant… and with the help of the AG and Shearer’s constant call for transparency – the AG should be able to clear up any misunderstandings or confusion – thereby clearing Cosgrove to possibly be a credible and honest politician after a full enquiry.
Until then though, he might be needing Peter’s “No” sign for whenever asked if he took election bribes in return for favourable legislation… and then blatantly proposed the favourable legislation…
Something stinks just below the surface here… and any half decent investigative journalist will probably be able to find the fetid corruption before the AG.
Shearer – without the AG investigating yet another whiffy “situation” by your MP’s this entire issue will become a burning tyre around your neck – placed and set alight by your people.
Sunlight disinfects like no other….
Come on Mr Shearer, be consistent or be damned by the public.
I swear to God, that Cosgrove has always struck me as being a bit of a drooling drongo; his condition has deteriorated even further.
Good on you he is a crook. He is worse than any Real Estate Agent
$17,500 makes Dormer look like a cheapskate. He will make millions from this. He coukd have at least donated $100,000. But what do folk expect? You give politicians all this power. Of course they are going to do favours for those they favour.
And why would you mae a political donation? Of course it is expecting something in return. Did Dormer make this donation wanting Cosgrove to promote labour policies like higher corporate taxes? Or capital gains tax? I'm afraid not folks.
seems like a non issue to me
One of Labours strongest members - about to do a Nick Smith exit left sage door for a while, I think. They wont let him go for good - he is one of the few with any talent in the party.
If you call what he's got "Talent" you obviously have low standards. He's a buffoon at best
hair hair
Agree
Imagine what other Old Boys deals are being done now!
Chch has always done things differently and always for the benefit of its ruling first ships class.
Dropped abit off the cow-yard shovel this time Mikey boy!
Whoops another Labour slip up ! like the photo of Nash at the gay show !
Cosgrove ,Mallard they are all the same .
Mind you they had a good teacher in Helen , just sign here boys !
More evidence that NZ needs:
1) An enforceable 'Code of Conduct' for MPs?
2) A 'Register of Lobbyists' and 'Code of Conduct' for lobbyists?
3) An Independent Commission Against Corruption?
Penny Bright
'Anti-corruption campaigner'
www.dodgyjohnhasgone.com
His electorate worked him out as well in the last election,they dumped him.Go figure.