Member log in

Cosgrove scents blood with former Solid Energy CEO's no-show

Labour MP Clayton Cosgrove will attempt to force former Solid Energy chief executive Don Elder to appear before the commerce select committee.

Mr Cosgrove dominated the committee hearings throughout the day at parliament, using the opportunity to torment the chairwomen and chief executives of MightyRiverPower and Genesis Energy, but was at his most aggressive in pursuing information on Solid Energy.

Newly appointed Solid Energy chairman Mark Ford was unable to answer questions on the company's dire financial position, prompting Mr Cosgrove to say he would seek to have the committee subpoena Mr Elder to appear and seek a parliamentary inquiry.

However, in a sign of the uphill battle he will likely face, the National Party majority on the committee blocked attempts to add an hour to yesterday's hearings.

Mr Ford repeatedly met opposition MPs' questions relating to Mr Elder's stewardship over 12 years at the head of the company with insistence he was not there at the time.

He confirmed that Mr Elder remains on the payroll on a two-month contract to assist the new board as it negotiates for a rescue package with its banks and Treasury.

"There were decisions made at the time. I was brought in by this government to turn this company around," Mr Ford said. "The benefit of hindsight is very easy. I'm not looking at that. I'm looking at the market today, the company today.

"This company will convert back very quickly to a very proud and profitable company." 

Pressed on responsibility for the debt escalation that sparked its current crisis, Mr Ford said: "It starts off with the board."

With respect to $23 million of senior executive bonuses paid in recent years, he said: "We will be looking at all jobs and all salaries attached with those jobs."

Mr Ford told the committee it would have been "unusual" for a former CEO to have attended today's hearings, but the company would not object to Mr Elder appearing before the committee.

He said the primary factor in Solid's current trouble was a 50 percent fall in global coal prices and confirmed the new board and senior management is planning to return a slimmed-down Solid Energy to profitability to 2015, based on a "very conservative base case".

(BusinessDesk)

More by Pattrick Smellie

Comments and questions
8

Wasn't Don Elder offering his views and leadership in the Christchurch rebuild? Quite strong views from my recollection.
Thank goodness the city and government didn't allow that to happen.
Bob Parker must be over the moon this hasn't occurred after Elder's supporters were Parker's detractors.

We pay these huge international market rates to CEOs in NZ to ensure that they don't run businesses into the ground with poor decisions and also remain fully accountable to investors and shareholders when asked to explain their decisions and behaviour.

So Lucky, the article says that coal prices dropped 50%. There isnt a business in NZ that could sustain that sort of drop in its margin over a period of time and survive. Sure, there may have been a few poor decisions, but the overiding issue is the bottom has fallen out of coal prices. And you can just imagine the reaction of the socialists if Solid had started closing mines a lot sooner, Cosgrove would have led the way in the savaging, I'm sure (and that's because he hasn't a commercial bone in his body).

The US system works.. appear or go to jail !

On Ford's TV3 encounter.. scary, dithery, wouldn't go to the front-line with him !

The NZ taxpayers are entitled to hear the facts in this sad case.
National should stop trying to cover up.
WG

A question to Cosgrove might be, how or why he was dumped by his electorate in the 2011 election? Yet he proceeds like nothing happened. Cosgrove is still on the public payroll as well, even though his electorate that dumped him - saw him as inept. How can he interrogate anyone after his questionable track record?

Solid Energy was well known in Christchurch as paying above-market rates at lower levels, so there is no reason to think that didn't apply at the top as well.

Is no one questioning the COMU, Treasury and shareholding Ministers' performances? If they too have been caught by surprise, butts should be kicked!