Court of Appeal throws out Hotchin bid to join trustees

Mark Hotchin (Photo: TVNZ)

Mark Hotchin and the Hanover boys have lost another bid to share blame for any Securities Act breaches with Hanover’s trustees.

Mr Hotchin and co had tried to make NZ Guardian Trust Company and Perpetual Trust parties in the Financial Markets Authority’s civil action against them.

The FMA is suing directors and promoters of Hanover and two related companies to recover lost millions for investors.

When the Hanover group of companies collapsed in July 2008, it owed about $554 million.

Mr Hotchin's claim that the trustees did not monitor the affairs of Hanover properly and should have to contribute to any penalties they have to pay if the FMA’s case against them succeeds, had already been dismissed by the High Court in July last year.

In a judgment released today, a Court of Appeal panel of Justice Rhys Harrison, Justice Doug White and Justice Christine French agreed with chief High Court judge Justice Helen Winkelmann’s approach. (see the judgment attached)

The court said Mr Hotchin owed the investors a duty to make accurate statements in prospectuses and certificates.

“The trustees cannot be liable in respect of the damage suffered by the investors where they did not owe a duty to protect them against the harm of inaccuracies in the directors’ statements.”

It dismissed the appeal, saying the trustees’ duties were of a very different nature and not the same obligations owed by Mr Hotchin.

The Hanover trial is to take place over 12 weeks in July next year.

Last week Nathan Gedye QC, Mr Hotchin’s lawyer, sought access to FMA investigation files about his client, saying the defence needed to know why the Securities Commission (as it was then known) might have been able to investigate earlier but didn’t.

vyoung@nbr.co.nz


Got a question about this story? Leave it in Comments & Questions below.

This article is tagged with the following keywords. Find out more about MyNBR Tags

NZ Market Snapshot

Forex

Sym Price Change
USD 0.7135 0.0016 0.22%
AUD 0.9575 0.0041 0.43%
EUR 0.6422 0.0024 0.38%
GBP 0.5347 0.0056 1.06%
HKD 5.5358 0.0127 0.23%
JPY 73.4120 0.1950 0.27%

Commods

Commodity Price Change Time
Gold Index 1320.6 1.800 2016-06-30T00:
Oil Brent 49.7 1.480 2016-06-30T00:
Oil Nymex 48.3 -1.510 2016-06-30T00:
Silver Index 18.6 0.220 2016-06-30T00:

Indices

Symbol Open High Last %
NZX 50 6897.5 6912.9 6897.5 0.19%
NASDAQ 4793.8 4843.1 4779.2 1.33%
DAX 9566.1 9695.6 9612.3 0.71%
DJI 17712.8 17930.6 17694.7 1.33%
FTSE 6360.1 6504.3 6360.1 2.27%
HKSE 20736.8 20828.0 20436.1 1.75%
NI225 15698.0 15765.0 15575.9 0.62%
ASX 5233.4 5278.9 5233.4 0.64%