Cushings edge closer to Kirkcaldie takeover threshold
BUSINESSDESK: Selwyn and David Cushing have edged closer to the takeover threshold in Kirkcaldie & Stains, the iconic Wellington department store owner whose property assets are worth almost twice the company’s market capitalisation.
The Cushing family’s investment arm, H&G Ltd, increased its stake in the company to 18.49% from 17.08%, according to a substantial security holder notice to the NZX.
H&G picked up the 144,000 shares in 15 separate trades this month, underlining the difficulty in acquiring the illiquid stock.
Kirkcaldie’s Harbour City Centre building has an August 2011 valuation of $46.5 million, which will increase to $48.7 million when earthquake strengthening is completed. At today’s share price of $2.68, the company is valued at $27.5 million.
The Cushings paid between $2.68 and $2.75 apiece for shares, or a total of $387,917, the statement says.
They first appeared on the register in 2006 and were joined last year by veteran corporate raider Sir Ron Brierley, who disclosed a 5.7% holding in September.
"At this price we have been very happy to add to our holding, we will be heading to 19%," David Cushing told BusinessDesk. "At this stage we are happy to accumulate shares” and there are no plans to make a full takeover though he added “never say never”.
The NZX-listed company operates its flagship store on Wellington’s Lambton Quay and the Harbour City Centre, a historic six-floor retail and office building next door.
"It is an interesting company with some prime Lambton Quay real estate,” Mr Cushing said. “That is an attractive long-term asset and we are long-term investors."
Kirkcaldie told shareholders in February it was looking to expand its property arm amid ailing retail sales. The company has struggled to attract customers without discounting goods since the global financial crisis prompted households to focus on repaying debt.
The store’s exposure to Wellington also means it has been hit with a double whammy as the government’s austerity plans slash jobs in the public sector, which pads out the city’s consumer base.
In April, the company posted a wafer-thin first-half net profit of $11,000 in the six months ended February 28, down from $380,000, a year earlier. It flagged a full year pretax loss.
The shares, which trade infrequently, have shed about 12% this year.





















Comments and questions9
- the property assets in the Interim Report have a book value of $29.7m, not $48.7m (the difference is a collection of other assets, including inventories and intangibles)
- In any event, total assets are not comparable with market cap, which is an equity valuation. The apples and oranges comparison ignores the debt of $16.7m
Thanks. The valuation came from the full-year results in October:
"The Harbour City Centre building is shown in our accounts as an asset of $23,261,000 but the most recent valuation of August 2011 values the asset at $46,500,000 (last year $38,000,000. This valuation will increase to $48,650,000 when the current earthquake strengthening and refurbishment project is complete."
The directors obviously think the valuation is a crock as otherwise why is it recorded in the Annual Report (and then just recently in the Interim Report) at a completely different value?
Maybe the valuer hails from the Bridgecorp School at Asset Valuation?
Actually the disrepency between the two valuations is quite weird when i think about it. I see they repeated your quoted language in the interim results too, but no explanation why is recorded so much lower in the accounts? Quite strange given they may be under threat of takeover...you qwould think they would want to value up the assets...?
No no, don't value it up. We want a quite, well discounted takeover. Already used some smuck as a stalking horse.
This is the NZX, the boys looking after the boys.
Interesting to see who controls the largest shareholding at 20% LQ Investments and who their directors and shareholders are!
Exactly the ex Strategic Finance boys and their mates
Maybe they are selling up to pay out the aggrieved investors in Strategic Finance as a measure of good faith??
Brierley ... Cushing ... the same names who came together to asset strip Air New Zealand. I feel for everyone at Kirks who can kiss their jobs goodbye once the inevitable strip of Kirks begins so that the property can be liquidated. And this is what passes for "business" in New Zealand.
Hey, Sir Selwyn wants to buy the store so he can make it up to the wives of every leaky home owner 'cos he 'believed' the BS research the Timber Barons confected. It showed that climate conditions were the same in NZ as they were in Oz....only we didn't have the bugs.
He and his fellow spidery spinners who sat on the Fletcher and CHH boards at the time should do the same. It is still our greatest ongoing scandal