Member log in

Delaying ETS would cause instability - Smith

New Zealand's emissions trading scheme (ETS) will start on July 1 because delaying it would create instability and uncertainty, Climate Change Minister Nick Smith said today.

Australia has put its ETS on hold because the government can't get sufficient support in Parliament to pass it, and there have been calls for New Zealand to do the same.

Federated Farmers and other business organisations are saying New Zealand will be at a competitive disadvantage unless it aligns itself with Australia.

Dr Smith said New Zealand's ETS, which was passed by Parliament last year, represented "a modest step forward" on climate change.

"This is a long-term issue requiring a steady and consistent approach. Our strategy has been to start the transition early but at a softer rate," he said.

"There would be real instability and uncertainty in deferring the emissions trading scheme's introduction at this late stage."

Dr Smith said he had been contacted by a number of businesses who were making substantial investments or had entered into significant contracts that would be severely disadvantaged by any change.

He said he had not been surprised by the news that Australian Prime Minister Kevin Rudd had decided to wait until the expiry of the Kyoto pact in 2012 before again trying to pass its ETS, which is one of the world's most comprehensive regimes.

"I would much rather be in New Zealand's position of having a settled emissions trading scheme passed in our Parliament than in the position of Australia or the United States, where there is agreement at government level on the policy and the right way forward, but they just can't get the necessary legislation through their parliaments," he said.

However, Dr Smith said New Zealand would be unlikely to proceed with its full obligations for energy, transport and industrial sectors, and to add additional sectors to the ETS, if there was no progress in other countries, particularly trading partners like Australia, Japan and the United States.

Agriculture is not due to come under the scheme until 2015 and there will be reviews in 2011 and 2014.

Dr Smith said claims that New Zealand was the first country in the world to bring in an ETS were wrong -- 29 of the 38 countries with Kyoto obligations already had them.

Prime Minister John Key said New Zealand's ETS was always going to come in ahead of Australia.

"Our scheme is different to Australia's and others. We think we've got a good and fair scheme," he said.

Labour leader Phil Goff did not support delaying the ETS.

"We have obligations under Kyoto, we're paying for these things anyway and we have obligations to the forestry industry," he said.

Delay would hurt New Zealand because it would be seen to be doing nothing about climate change.

More by NZPA

Signup to free NBR email alerts here

More on:

Comments and questions
11

Is there no end to this mans drivel.

National was not elected to commit the equivalent of economic self mutilation. This is what the decision on Emissions Trading amounts to, when we are going it alone without the equivalent moves from our major trading partners.

National was deaf to the public on the smacking issue, is irresponsible on Maori issues and now this!

the only thing uncertain is Dr Dickhead Smith's mental stability.

Likewise, given that delaying the ETS will expose just how corrupt, how negligent, how inept and how poor the Key/Clark government is - New Zealand NOW has a serious problem.

Key won't expose the corrupt deals that supported SMITH's corrupt ETS deal.
Smith now has admitted to exposing NZ's tax payers to a massive tree planting bill - but, is cowardice and lacking in moral fibre to front up.
Bill english is pooping in his pants and nows that NZ is stuffed.

Both commit New Zealand's economic demise due to a mutual confluence of corruption and idiocy.

Both Key and Smith should be removed from office for treason immediately.

The earth is in no imminent threat of any human caused environmental catastrophe. The ETS is nothing more than a tax grab - designed to launder money from my pocket, via my conscience and into the government's bare coffers. Key and Smith are being dishonest about the real reasons for pushing ahead with this destructive scheme. Hang your heads in shame Key and Smith. And the balance National's MP can do likewise. Shame on the lot of you for your dishonesty and abuse of trust.

Meanwhile let us all proceed & be first to take off our clothes at the picnic

"Doing nothing about climate change"
The only country in the world with a national ETS, already enacted and ready to roll if ever the others catch up.

The only country to even think about an all-sectors all-gasses ETS.

One of only two countries outside Europe that currently complies with Annex 1 of Kyoto.

The world leader in research on climate change and agriculture

One of the top 3 in the world with 2020 target of 10-20% reduction below 1990 (compare Australia with 5% since 2000)

What more could TESCO customers insist upon - that an ETS must be implemented by July 2010??

The only instability is his.....a well-documented medical fact.

Cause: He knows he's to blame for the Leaky Building fiasco and he cannot change that fact

When the global markets go into meltdown, Key and co. will be left with white faces. When the financial pressure goes on Joe public, Key and co. will be forced to scrap the ETS. What other Govt. in the World is going to have one if they want to get re-elected?

Rushing in will cause much more insatability.
Simple where fools rush in.
A rushed vote on no confidence in the house should be rushed.

Jimbob:

Answer: A world government.

I think this is the last straw. The National Party will pay at the next Election.
My family all votes for the National Party and I like many others feel that we have all been let down. This ETS is a joke. the hard working people seem to just have to pay,pay,pay.

Post new comment or question

Login to use your NBR member name
Full HTML is not supported but you can use the following tags in your comments:
Link: <url>link</url>
Quote: <quote>text</quote>