Member log in

Ecan's performance under the spotlight

Environment Canterbury's water management was so bad that immediate government intervention was necessary, Parliament was told last night.

Environment Minister Nick Smith was speaking during the first reading on a bill, introduced under urgency, which gives the Government the power to appoint commissioners to replace the council and take over the region's resource management.

"You've got people flexing their muscles over water while the weakened referee, Environment Canterbury (ECan), is struggling to maintain order," Dr Smith said.

"Allocation decisions are ad hoc, water quality is deteriorating, storage opportunities are being lost in the muddle."

Dr Smith said long-standing systemic issues relating to ECan's performance had reached a critical stage.

"The Canterbury community has lost faith in the ability of ECan to deliver on its statutory responsibilities," he said.

"The views of the people of Canterbury are very clear to me -- that it has been patently obvious, for a number of years, that something needed to be done."

Dr Smith said the threshold for intervention in local government was high, and could only happen when there was serious failure.

"The Government's intervention is required for three reasons," he said.

"The council has failed to effectively manage Canterbury's fresh water, it does not have a fully operational regional plan and policy framework for resource management, and there is an enormous gap between what needs to be done to effectively manage water in Canterbury and the council's ability to do so.

"There is a compelling case for immediate and direct intervention by government."

Dr Smith said the ECan election in October this year would be deferred until the commissioners had completed their task.

"But, under whatever circumstances, the next regional council elections in Canterbury will take place no later than those scheduled for late 2013."

Labour's Christchurch Central MP Brendon Burns, the party's associate environment spokesman, said the bill was "a constitutional outrage on a whole number of levels".

"It replaces Environment Canterbury's elected councillors with government-appointed commissioners," he said.

"This will disenfranchise the voters of Canterbury for the next three-and-a-half years. This isn't a quick fix, it's a long-term assault on democracy."

Mr Burns said the Government was going to pass the bill, under urgency, without any chance for public submissions.

"What we're seeing is National and ACT removing a democratically elected council so Nick Smith and his colleagues can run the decisions in Canterbury in terms of water.

"That's what this is about. People in my province will not get a chance to have a say on who manages their water, their public transport, their Clean Air Act, their coastal environment, for the next three-and-a-half long years."

More by NZPA

More on:

Comments and questions
1

As a Canterbury resident I see water resources as being the most important issue in our community.

I have my own well and am exceptionally pleased with the quality of the water I extract for my home use. What is of greatest concern to me is the over extraction and pollution of this well recognized precious resource.

I have no faith that a person or persons from outside this area can know what it means to properly maintain this resource for this and future generations.

The Wellington crooks that are stealing our water will pay dearly I am sure. Canty is a very community minded area and top down decrees will be resisted and overturned at the first opportunity.

I see the demise of Mayor Bob and the others that have so surreptitiously undermined Ecan and I see this being the straw that breaks Nationals back, they will be out next election because of this.

However I will not be surprised if we see this government insist on installing those diebold LieBold electioneering machines so insidiously used in American elections, and that as this will be the end of democracy as we knew it.

ps Go to hell Wellington bureaucrats. We will decide ourselves what corporations we want to own our resource.

Post new comment or question

Login to use your NBR member name
Full HTML is not supported but you can use the following tags in your comments:
Link: <url>link</url>
Quote: <quote>text</quote>