Ken Wikeley has lost a $US1.5 million lawsuit brought by an investor in a failed mining venture related to Orion Minerals Group in a judgment that describes the businessman as "frequently evasive under cross-examination".
Mr Wikeley is best known for his involvement in Rainbow Corporation in the 1980s, as managing director of Aquaria 21 in the 1990s and in the affairs of the serial NZX Listing Rules infringer, Plus SMS.
Justice Stephen Kos found for the plaintiffs in his April 10 judgment, dismissing arguments from Mr Wikeley's lawyer that loans from the trustees of the Genset Trust were actually payments for shares in Edel Metals Group or were not enforceable because they had not been ratified by shareholders as a major transaction.
"Mr Wikeley's present contention that what he structured, and described at the time, as a loan was in fact subscription for share capital is in my view opportunistic nonsense," Justice Kos says.
"Much of his evidence seemed calculated to deflect attention from the real issues. Or to offer somewhat improbable explanations for why documents did not mean what they appeared to say," the judgment says.
"I did not regard him as a reliable witness."
Genset Trust had invested $US250,000 in the Chilean mining start-up OMG in 2008 and that year trustee Michael Jacomb visited Chile, where, according to the judgement, he met Mr Wikeley, who was by then "captivated" by a new business idea – a prototype rock crusher – in which he saw a separate opportunity.
"I thought there was a fortune to be made from it," Mr Wikeley said in evidence. "It all seemed like an amazing opportunity to me."
The judge noted that "nothing in evidence suggested that Mr Wikeley had relevant technical qualifications or experience in mining engineering".
Came a cropper
Genset, whose substantial cash reserves came from the sale of a large electrical engineering business in 2004, had come a cropper with investments touted by Mr Wikeley before. In 2006, Mr Wikeley "induced" Mr Jacomb to invest in Plus SMS, a listed telecommunications firm that failed in 2009.
Still, he was persuaded to loan $US1.5 million to Edel Metals (EGM), set up in late 2008 to buy mining equipment including the crusher technology from German-Iranian businessman Parviz Gharagozlu and his Chilean associates.
EMG issued 100 million unpaid $1 shares, of which the trust held about 24 percent and the remaining 76 percent by Geier Ltd, which was notionally owned by a number of parties in Chile linked to Mr Wikeley, including Mr Gharagozlu.
Mr Jacomb insisted on personal guarantees from Mr Wikeley for 50 percent of the funds advanced to EGM, the judgment shows.
Justice Kos ruled that because of the $100 million of unpaid capital, the loans could not be deemed a major transaction requiring approval of 75 percent of EMG's shareholders.
He allowed that 12 million OMG shares transferred to the trust as security for the EMG loans by Mr Wikeley needed to be taken into account and ordered that any sale proceeds from those shares be deducted from the judgment debt and any remaining transferred back to Mr Wikeley.
Shares of OMG, which abandoned its South American mining dreams and is now focused on investments in China, last traded at 2.2 cents.
Mr Wikeley has a long track record as a businessman and the judgment notes that "by his own admission he has had a chequered career".
He had at one time owned a share of the electrical firm whose proceeds funded the Genset trust.
This article is tagged with the following keywords. Find out more about MyNBR Tags
Most listened to
- Business Week in Review with Grant Walker & Andrew Patterson
- Matthew Hooton on the state of the British Labour party under Jeremy Corbyn
- Rodney Hide on the Ombudsman’s investigation into SSC conduct of MFAT leaks inquiry
- David Cohen on how to walk out of a TV interview
- Imperial Tobacco lobbyist insists NZ visit about “contributing expertise,” not pressuring government on plain packaging law