Member log in

UPDATED: Fonterra botulism scare - MPI tells parents to avoid two Nutricia Karicare products

UPDATE / Aug 5: The Ministry for Primary Industry is now recommending parents avoid two products until further notice:

  • Nutricia Karicare Infant Formula Stage 1 for babies from birth
  • Nutricia Karicare Stage 2 Follow-on formula for children from six months old

LATEST: AUT prof says Fonterra delay hard to fathom; calls botulism concern 'real and justified'; outlines fatal effects

---------------

Aug 4: The Ministry for Primary Industries has provied details of one product in New Zealand potentially containing contaminated whey protein from Fonterra’s Hautapu manufacturing facility: Nutricia Karicare follow-on formula products for children from 6 months old. 

Fonterra has said none of its brands (listed here) are affected, but that eight of its customers are involved.

“Since we were informed by Fonterra [Friday] afternoon that three batches of concentrated whey protein contain Clostridium botulinum, MPI has been working intensively to identify what, if any, products on the New Zealand market may be contaminated,” Acting Director General Scott Gallacher said.

“The batches of whey product have been on sold and mixed with other ingredients to form 870 tonnes of consumer products sold in a variety of markets, Mr Gallacher said.

“MPI has been advised that in the case of the Nutricia Karicare, five batches of follow-on formula were manufactured using the contaminated whey protein.

“Nutricia has advised that three of those batches are in a warehouse in Auckland, one is on a ship, and the other is in storage in Australia. Nutricia has advised it has locked down those batches, and they will not be sold on the market.

“MPI is still in the process of verifying this information, and today sent a team to Nutricia's Auckland warehouses” Mr Gallacher said.

“Until this process is completed, I advise parents and caregivers with infants consuming Nutricia Karicare follow on formula products from 6 months, to use infant formula for children aged 0-6 months, ready-made formulas or alternative brands.”

Number of markets "very concerned"
Mr Gallacher said the government had last night advised regulatory authorities in markets where affected product had gone.

“MPI and the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade are continuing to work with overseas regulators to provide information as it becomes available. Clearly, a number of markets are very concerned about this situation.”

Fonterra assured consumers in global markets including Australia, Asia, China, Latin America, New Zealand and the Middle East that none of its range of branded consumer products contains the affected whey protein concentrate (WPC80). 

Despite criticism about the time taken to name the affected brands, Fonterra says it will be up its customers to name them.  "Any product recalls that may be necessary in the coming days will be announced and initiated by the respective customers, in conjunction with local regulators," the company said in a statement yesterday afternoon.

At this stage no products have been recalled, Fonterra said (although as noted above, MPI has warned against using Nutricia Karicare follow-on formula products for children from 6 months old untiil it has more information on NZ distribution of affected product)


 Fonterra chief heads to China amid botulism scare
Aug 3: Fonterra chief executive Theo Spierings is heading from Europe to China this weekend for meetings with manufacturers who have used contaminated whey powder supplied by the New Zealand dairy giant for use in infant formula and other products.

The dairy cooperative is in crisis communications mode as it seeks to do the right thing by notifying that eight unnamed customers have received batches of a whey protein concentrate containing a "virulent" strain of a commonly occurring bacteria, clostridium, linked to the potentially fatal disease, botulism.

Fonterra's managing director of New Zealand Milk Products Gary Romano fronted a media conference this morning, where he reluctantly conceded that no products bearing Fonterra brands are affected by the scare.

The reactions from the eight affected customers, whom Romano declined to name, had reacted "as you would expect" to the news of the contamination, which occurred when the product was manufactured at a Waikato processing plant in May of last year and involves a total of 38 tonnes of product.

Romano was initially unwilling to answer whether Fonterra brands were safe from the contamination because of "the commercial aspects", an apparent reference to the potential for unaffected Fonterra brand products to experience better sales than competitors.

Other food manufacturers, potentially including others unaffected, will need either to confirm they haven't used the contaminated product or that they have and may need to issue product recalls.

Fonterra first became aware of the potential contamination in March of this year, 10 months after the dried product was manufactured, and subsequent testing revealed on July 31 the presence of Clostridium Botulinum. The bacteria take hundreds of variant forms with affects on milk products ranging from nothing through to food-spoiling and health risks.

"There have been no reports of any illness linked to consumption of the affected whey protein. Dairy products such as fresh milk, yoghurt, cheese, spreads and UHT milk products are not affected," said Spierings in a statement.

The contamination arose because a "very little-used" piece of pipework was not properly sterilised before a batch of the whey protein, WPC80, was produced, said Romano. Asked whether there had been disciplinary action taken or systems upgrades to prevent a recurrence, he said the immediate focus was on informing customers and the public of the issue.

Discovery of the Cloridium Botulinum strain was "very rare" in the dairy industry, he said. "Our aim is to have that not happen again."

He confirmed the notification was "one of the reasons" for Spierings travelling to China this weekend but declined to elaborate on the length of time that elapsed between manufacture of the product and the testing which first set alarm bells ringing in March.

The fact that Fonterra had made the discovery was a consequence of the company's rigorous testing regimes, which went beyond the levels required by regulators, Romano said.

Under repeated questioning as to the identity of other affected brands, Romano stressed it was up to the eight customers in question to make their own decisions on how to communicate with their customers.

It was not possible to restrict concerns about the products to any particular territory, as they could subsequently have been sent to other markets.

Comments and questions
6

BIG,BIG, BIG.
Hope the PM and Government all over this one.

Fonterra has done the right thing to nib it at the bud. It is up to the customers to assess this whether the reputation is intact followed the announcement or they switch to other supplies who cover up such problems.

Surely the immediate reaction from other countries will have to be full recall of all potentially affected products - they can't afford to wait for test results.

How will this affect our GDP??

Few months ago we had the issue with DCD and the government so relaxes with their approach particularly to our biggest export market, China. This time it's clearly more disastrous so I truly hope that bothe the government and Fonterra are working in concerted manner.

Fonterra will be complicit with the eight companies that it will not name if anyone dies from its products.
It will cost more than money if this occurs as no-one will never trust this company again.

What baffles me is this stuff got out to consumers. So some of it must have been used. So where are all the cases of botulism? I haven't seen ANY reported.