Goff warns US on TPP expectations, cuddles China
"As a small country, we will do best by playing China and the US off each other, while avoiding attachments to either."
Featured commentBUSINESSDESK: A Labour-led government would not allow the United States to dictate terms on the Trans-Pacific Partnership free trade agreements or allow it to use any pact as a pretext for containing "China's economic advance".
In a significant speech to the Asia Forum in Wellington, Mr Goff claims New Zealand Labour government heritage for the TPP initiative, which has recently attracted participation from the US, Canada and Mexico trade bloc, otherwise known as Nafta, along with Japan.
The former leader of New Zealand's main opposition political party warned against choosing between relationships with China and the US, preferring "good relations with both superpowers".
"New Zealand for the first time in its history finds itself in a situation where its strategic security relationships based on commonality of political values and history do not match its strategic economic interests," Mr Goff said. The same was true other countries in the region.
"The goal of Asia-Pacific nations should be to ensure the two superpowers co-operate rather than end up in conflict."
The US should be welcomed into the TPP, which a Labour-led government initiated, but not allow US attempts to "contain" China, and "not on all of the terms that the US would like to impose in negotiations."
"The opportunity to co-operate more closely with the US, including in military training … is unlikely to, and should not, seek reinstatement of a military alliance that would tie its hands."
"New Zealand should not, and I believe does not, see the TPP as an agreement exclusive of other countries or as a means to contain China’s economic advance.
"Rather, Labour initiated it and sees it as a means" of achieving an Asia-Pacific FTA, as envisaged when Labour prime minister Mike Moore initiated the process known as Apec.
"Our ideal would be a totally inclusive high quality multilateral trade agreement through the World Trade Organisation," Mr Goff said.
"Many view China from the background of a history of competition and conflict with that country. They also have a strong desire born from colonial times not to be dominated or instructed on what to do by the US or any other power.
"They want the US to be active in the region to achieve an equilibrium of power. They welcome the Obama regime’s pivot towards Asia but they don’t want the United States to crusade or seek confrontation with China," he said.
A fundamental difference with China was "real concerns in the area of human rights".
"It goes without saying that we do not have the power to tell China what to do," Mr Goff said. "China resents the tone of the US’s approach to its treatment of human rights more than the message.
"We need to continue to make our case quietly but insistently and offer our co-operation in changes that must come from within China itself."
























Comments and questions12
It's a very wise distinction that Mr. Goff makes.
In spite of the approximate commonality of language, NZ and the US have little in common. China will be a major trade partner, even more so in the future.We have a free trade agreement with China. We will never get an agricultural free trade agreement with the US.
As a small country, we will do best by playing China and the US off each other, while avoiding attachments to either.
"As a small country, we will do best by playing China and the US off each other, while avoiding attachments to either."
That stance is as dangerous as it is arrogant.
How about we treat everybody as equal and deal with each issue on its merits rather than on the nationality of its author?
Is that too much to ask?
USA democracy 1950-90s.. .. FEAR of reds under the bed; 2000s ..FEAR of headscarves; 2010s........FEAR of Confucius?
"cuddles China"? as opposed to the British approach of licking US feet, perhaps?
Fortunately for NZ, the TPP, USA and China – Labour will not get back into government for at least another 2 or 3 terms.
Labour’s incompetence compounded by their own inability to promote & keep a leader their entire political party are happy with, coupled with Labour’s obfuscation of murky and highly questionable political donations from unions – some of whom haven’t filed minimum legal financial statements since 2006 – will all ensure the NZ public don’t want anything to do with these bunch of corrupt politicians and rorting union organisers.
Besides – the last time Labour dealt with Chinese “interests” their MP’s privately sold NZ citizenship and passports for about $15K to an individual with 2 or possibly 3 names – no one in NZ really knows his real name. Even Interpol suggested otherwise to the Labour government MP’s at the time – but arrogant, rorting Labour MP’s couldn’t help keep their sticky, greedy fingers out of the government coffers.
NZ won’t have that happen again – and especially not with Labour politicians who will only be a minor party to the more credible and “ethical” Green party anyway.
Labour will be the “last cab off the rank” behind the Greens, Maori, ACT, NZ 1st, United Future, Mana, Conservatives, McGillicuddy Serious Party, Legalise Marijuana Party, Bob Jones for PM party and Ronald McDonald for President Party.
Oh good. As China invades the South China Sea (as happened in the last 24 hurs), Labour would prefer to cuddle up to the communist free marketeers. One more step to the Labour-Green goal of the Chinese Aoteoroa Industrial/Agricultural Zone.
"As China invades the South China Sea" ? Sounds a bit like NZ invades Sth Island LOL!
Pay a visit to the AKL Library then you will realise the South China Sea belong to China long before Maori set a foot on Aotearoa, and that's why it carries a "China" mid name at the first place.
Annonymous 26minutes ago, is writing absolute rubbish. The South China Sea no more belongs to China than the Indian Ocean belongs to India. There are recognised territorial limits acoss the oceans and sea, 12 mile and 200 mile basically; the remaining water belongs to 'no one'.
China needs to learn, that if it is going to have any acceptable credibility in the world, it needs to start respecting the rights of others, and stop subtly trying to dominate.
A good place to start earning this credibility would be at the United Nations, where China regularly thwarts the desire of 'responsible' nations to reduce/prevent internal conflict i.e Syria at present, and many past examples.
Rubbish is what you own Rob. "There are recognised territorial limits acoss the oceans and sea, 12 mile and 200 mile basically; the remaining water belongs to 'no one'." is a piece of "law" claimed by the West and tried to impose on everybody else since colonial age, then a Western power can "lawfully" get into someone's backyard. The UN also recognize this "law" can not revoke any existing sovereignty over the waters concerned. So save the breath.
And is it really a "law" well observed by its advocates? Try tell that to the US, Canada, Russia and even Norway when all of them want to claim North Pole and seas around it based on "previous discoveries" done by "respective countries". Funny isn't it?
The united states is just a shell of it's former self, run by the federal reserve and the globalist 1% who care nothing about the country or the citizens, only about themselves. It's funny growing up how I heard that they have 'slave labor' in China, but when you step away and see the bigger picture you realize everyone in america is a slave to a system that keeps them dumbed down and locked into place, cheap labor that forever serves the rich in america, and they don't care if it's an ethiopian or illegal mexican doing it. The Chinese people get a much better deal, a government that works for the Chinese people, keeps foreigners out and helps to better the Chinese culture. Every day I get on my knees and cry realizing I am not Chinese. They are the chosen people I can only wish I was one of them. I live in america and i despise this sick dying shriveling shell of it's former self, a literal Hollywood/media-tainted cesspool of immorality suffering from a broken economy it feels like a freak show from the circus, only an entire nation that's like this. You can't even walk into a walmart without seeing some freak on a pogo stick, or an illegal mexican. You can't even go see a movie without a batman shooter waiting there for you. I can only hope the Chinese, the chosen people of God, completely buy out america with debt, and reshape and change it to their superior ideals.
who cares what goff thinks.
he had nine years to say all he wanted to say.
IMO the US wouldn't be so palsy-walsy with NZ in recent years IF it were not for the rise of China, so be grateful they've sent their top rankers for politicians here to cuddle up to.