Member log in

Injunction granted in Yellow database 'theft' case

At the High Court in Auckland this morning, Yellow gained an injunction against Image Marketing Group (IMG), which it accuses of selling a pirated version of its database.

Justice Woodhouse granted the injunction, pending a full trial, after IMG failed to defend itself at the hearing. In a fax, the company said it had been unable to find funds to engage a lawyer. 

Yellow - owner of the The Yellow Pages in print, the yellow.co.nz website and the 018 calling service - claims that IMG illegally obtained around 315,000 business names featured in its directory.

IMG, trading as NZ Data, then sold the business names in a product called New Zealand Data Database Version 3.0, which was advertised for $6500.

Yellow said that several sales had been made for $3500, although it did not know the exact number. Additional sales had been made at half that price again since Yellow began to take action on November 6.

IMG is owned by Brendan Battles, best known on the New Zealand IT scene as “the spam king”.

Mr Battles hit the news most recently in March as he switched his junk marketing efforts from email to cellphone txt messages.

Speaking to NBR after this morning’s hearing, Yellow legal counsel Toby Sharpe said it was unknown how Mr Battles obtained a copy of his company’s database.

The matter will be addressed at the trial.

However, Mr Sharpe noted that there are a number of “data scraping” tools available, which allow a copyright infringer to automate the process of copying listings en masse from a public site like yellow.co.nz.

Although Justice Woodhouse allowed media to cover the hearing, some information held in affidavits, including steps Yellow takes to protect and identify its own data, was not revealed to reporters.

Businesses typically plant "seeds" in a database, or a handful of bogus names and addresses that will betray anybody who tries to claim a copy was in fact their own work.

Innocent businesses out of pocket
The number of companies that bought IMG’s database is unknown.

Justice Woodhouse also ordered IMG to hand over the names of every business that had bought its database product. All will be required to stop using it.

Mr Sharpe said it would be up to each company that innocently bought the stolen data to take its own action against IMG.

Suspicious competitor
Yellow does not sell its business listings en masse, but has a subsidiary, DataMarket, which sells subsets of its database.

Mr Sharpe said Yellow first became aware of Mr Battles' operation when its DataMarket customers began telling its sales reps they'd found a cheaper alternative.

Justice Woodhouse also awarded Yellow costs for the proceedings up until this point.

The action was brought by Yellow and its fully-owned subsidiary Finda.

The trial is expected to take place in around six months.

More by Chris Keall

Comments and questions
3

Brendan Battles is an intelligent businessman with a passion for marketing and helping NZ businesses grow. If you think he's a spammer you obviously don't know the difference between trashy spam and genuine business marketing. NZ should be ashamed of their corrupt legal system, where a big company can flash their money around and get what they want without so much as a trial. I've personally seen stacks as high as the ceiling of faxed in business names & addresses that are obviously the base of this so-called stolen database. I've also heard that Yellow had approached Mr Battles some time ago wanting to "purchase" and take over his product..they obviously thought it was cheaper to take him to court than to buy him out. If Mr Battles does return to the US..well then the braindrain continues, soon NZ will be left with nothing but brainless zombies! And as for Yellow f**k them, I'm going to continue using my database thank you very much..do they really think they own every business address in the country?

and should be deported. He's not from around here. Send him home.

[Mr Battles came to New Zealand from the US in 2006 - CK.]

Mr Battles should be removed from NZ he is nothing but a dirty low bag spammer. He sold a personal email address of mine to a company a few months back I followed through with a complaint to the DIA. Mr Battles if you are reading this I hope you are removed from NZ for good and you are made to swim home so the NZ tax payer does not have to pay for your airline ticket.

Post new comment or question

Login to use your NBR member name
Full HTML is not supported but you can use the following tags in your comments:
Link: <url>link</url>
Quote: <quote>text</quote>