Key takes issue with Bollard's Australia comments

Prime Minister John Key says Reserve Bank Governor Alan Bollard's opinion that New Zealand cannot catch up with Australia is negative and wrong.

Mr Bollard yesterday told TV One's Q&A programme, that he thought the goal, which the National Party campaigned on, was unrealistic.

"I don't think we can catch up with Australia," he said.

"Australia is a most unusual country... blessed by God sprinkling minerals across the top of the surface in very easily accessible areas."

Instead, New Zealand should focus better on taking advantage of the crumbs that fell from Australia's table.

Catching up with Australia's economic growth and wage rates is one of the Government's main objectives because it wants to stem the trans-Tasman brain drain and raise the standard of living.

Mr Key was clearly unimpressed when asked about the remarks on TV One's Breakfast programme this morning.

"It's a fairly negative view about New Zealand's future and I just don't agree with it," he said.

"It's not to say its not difficult or challenging, everyone knows that."

While Australia had easily accessible minerals it struggled with water resources and had other problems.

Thirty years ago New Zealand had the same wage rate as Australia.

"They still had their minerals back then. There are lots of things we can do to turn our country around."

He said, for example, the Avatar film contributed $307 million to the economy and created 700 jobs.

"So to sort of write off the future of New Zealand and say we can never catch Australia is a fatalistic view that I just don't buy into it... It's an aspirational goal but I think it's also realistic. I think we can get there."

He said the Government was focused on working to benefit from Australia's gains and had made it easier to businesses to operate between the countries.

Comments

Catching up

Did we ever think that Australia would wait for us to 'catch up'?

And, in any case, catch up with what? Bigger salaries? Bigger costs? Drought-dogged agricultural land? Terror from the north? Insoluble aboriginal problems? Commitment to illegal US invasions?

It may be that Australia needs to catch up with us: clean water and plenty of it; extremely good underlying race relations; less interference from the nanny state; less inclination to dig up and export unrenewable resources; excellent trout fishing; and export of ex-politicians to places where they can forget the land of their birth and stop messing up people's lives.

I know who I think is ahead and it aint' the Aussies.

Some of us need reminding occassionally

Very true Don - Key is right, yes it isn't a small challenge to emulate the per capita wealth that Australia has, but its not impossible. Singapore doesn't have mineral wealth but has created it own wealth, not that we'd like to emulate every aspect of their society either.

You have to be aspirational to improve your lot, but you won't do it sitting on your hands. We have alot of positive things going for us that can be a foundation, but we need to start seeing some action to go with the rhetoric - I'm hoping that's what we start seeing now strating with Key's speech this week in parliament

Apart from food, petrol and

Apart from food, petrol and borrowing money, pretty much everything in Australia seems a lot more expensive than it is here in NZ. Housing, Insurance, Car Registration, Tax , Air Fares - you name it.

Sure their wages are higher, but they need to be to cope with a much higher cost of living. Can't say that their STANDARD of living is any higher either. So why all the fuss?

I know where I'd rather be and it's not in the Western Pacific, that's for sure.

Well John if you reckon we

Well John if you reckon we can catch up what about some positive steps to commence the process???

May be NZ should have a more

May be NZ should have a more positive Reserve Bank Governor to catch up with Australia.

The Reserve bank does not

The Reserve bank does not set monetary policy for the economy it actually follows behind what the economy has done. E.g The official cash rate follows the previous business undertaken, it does not set the future business for this is already in motion. The Reserve Bank is always chasing a tail. Perhaps the catch up with Australia will have happened before the Reserve Bank finds its tail.

Post new comment

The information entered here will appear with your comment.
Leaving this field blank will default to anonymous.

More information about formatting options