Labour engages in schoolyard behavior

Jamie Whyte

David Cunliffe and his Labour Party colleagues remind me of some of the bullies at my old high school. They would grab the forearms of weaker children and then force them to slap themselves in the face with their own hands. That is the effect of Labour’s policy of making KiwiSaver compulsory, which they announced today.

Suppose you are an employed 35-year-old with a mortgage charging 6% interest. You would be well advised to use any money you can save to repay your mortgage. That is a better way of saving for your old age than investing in a pension fund, such as KiwiSaver. No pension fund can produce an annual risk-free return of 6%.

But Mr Cunliffe won’t let you. He will force you instead to invest in KiwiSaver, despite the fact that such investments can provide a risk-free return of only 3% or thereabouts.  He will use his superior strength – that is, the government’s power to confiscate your money – to force you to slap yourself in the face (financially speaking).

Or suppose you are 25-years-old and starting out on a career in which your pay will rise sharply over the coming years. It would be foolish to save $2000 this year. That would materially damage your standard of living while you are earning only $35,000. In 15 years’ time, when you are earning maybe $150,000, you will be able to save much more at less cost to your quality of life. Any sensible person would delay saving until their income was higher, especially since consumption can be so much more enjoyable when you are young.

But no, if Mr Cunliffe becomes prime minister, he will stop you making this sensible choice. He will force you to save that $2000 right now, whether you want to or not.

This is typical Labour Party policy. First, they wrongly assume themselves to know what is best for others; then they declare that people who disagree with them will be deprived of their liberty to follow their own judgment.

Ignorance and thuggery naturally go together, not only in school bullies but in politicians. With wisdom comes an appreciation of the uncertainties and complexities of your subject. A skilled financial adviser knows that how much people should save, when they should save and in what ways they should save are complex matters, and that the right answers vary from person to person.  A skilled financial adviser wouldn’t dream of commanding everyone to save the same percentage of their incomes in the same way at all times, even if he had the power.

To do such a thing, you need to be unusually ignorant and even more arrogant.

Jamie Whyte is the ACT party leader

Got a question about this story? Leave it in Comments & Questions below.

This article is tagged with the following keywords. Find out more about MyNBR Tags

NZ Market Snapshot


Sym Price Change
USD 0.6681 -0.0017 -0.25%
AUD 0.9172 0.0052 0.57%
EUR 0.5849 -0.0053 -0.90%
GBP 0.4391 0.0023 0.53%
HKD 5.1775 -0.0139 -0.27%
JPY 79.6660 -0.7340 -0.91%


Commodity Price Change Time
Gold Index 1164.4 6.730 2015-10-12T00:
Oil Brent 50.2 0.920 2015-10-12T00:
Oil Nymex 47.6 -2.580 2015-10-12T00:
Silver Index 15.9 0.046 2015-10-12T00:


Symbol Open High Last %
NZX 50 5689.8 5718.8 5689.8 0.23%
NASDAQ 4839.8 4846.7 4830.5 0.17%
DAX 10128.5 10187.1 10096.6 0.23%
DJI 17082.3 17139.2 17084.5 0.28%
FTSE 6416.2 6416.2 6416.2 -0.70%
HKSE 22614.3 22779.5 22458.8 1.21%
NI225 18335.2 18359.7 18438.7 -0.67%