Marlin directors Carmel Fisher and Rob Challinor say that any move to delist the fund could involve forced asset sales if a rush of investors apply to withdraw their money.
Marlin shareholder Gary Cross has been advertising in national media for investors to contact him and join the call for a vote on delisting the fund.
Mr Cross argues that investors would benefit if Marlin delisted and became an open-ended fund, such as a unit trust. Unit trusts are valued at net asset value for investors to buy and sell units.
Marlin, on the other hand, has been trading at a discount to its net asset value since listing in 2007. The current discount is around 24%.
In response to Mr Cross’s proposal, Marlin’s directors have written to investors saying that they are also frustrated with the discount to net asset value but that in the current market many companies are trading below valuation.
Marlin investors chose a closed-ended listed fund, they said. If it became an open-ended unit trust in which the fund managers paid out exiting investors, rather than the investors selling shares on market, a large rush of redemption requests could force the managers to sell investments to find cash.
This could hurt the share price of investee companies and the value left to remaining investors.
Moreover, investors have to sell at net asset value and cannot choose a market price at which they want to sell.
Marlin’s board said the young fund had outperformed competitors during a difficult period. “Marlin has played its part ... now we need to wait for the markets to recognise that,” the directors wrote.
They said they did not think Mr Cross's views were in line with most investors.
But Mr Cross said he was confident of getting the numbers for a vote. "It's only really just getting momentum."
Investors would not rush to redeem their shares if they saw a more positive net asset value under a unit trust structure, he suggested.
Marlin is managed by Fisher Funds, who have recently introduced a new distribution policy at fellow listed fund Kingfish.
The plan is to pay out 8% of net asset value each year to investors who want dividends or access to some of their funds.
This article is tagged with the following keywords. Find out more about MyNBR Tags
Most listened to
- Zero Emission Vehicle's Andrew Rushworth says his company may have been naïve
- FMA markets oversight director Garth Stanish tells NBR improvements in professional scepticism are particularly needed
- Restaurant Brands general manager of sales and marketing Geraldine Oldham talks about the "salacious" Carl's Jr ad
- Westpac’s David Norman: a big job to be done but lifting Auckland’s building rate is achievable
- Head-to-head: Federated Farmers director Katie Milne and SAFE executive director Hans kriek debate dairy industry's treatment of bobby calves