Media swallowed Hobbit embargo while politicians blabbed

After all the hoopla surrounding The Hobbit there were just two questions on most people’s lips after the premiere.

Was the film any good and did it live up to everyone’s expectations?

Not unimportant questions, you might think, given that the trilogy cost the thick end of $700 million, including almost $100 million in taxpayer subsidies, and provoked a bitter industrial dispute.

So did anyone in the news media bother to ask any of the 850 lucky souls who attended the premiere whether they thought the vast sum of money was well spent?

People like Transport Minister Gerry Brownlee and Labour leader David Shearer, who were among a gaggle of politicians in the auditorium.

With one or two honourable exceptions the answer is a resounding No, all because they cravenly kowtowed to an embargo imposed by Warner Bros.

Perhaps the worst offender was Radio New Zealand’s flagship news programme Morning Report, which in three hours singularly failed to raise the issue, let alone discuss it.

Instead, we got to hear Council of Trade Unions’ president Helen Kelly bleating on about John Key’s “dishonesty” in a speech he made before the screening.

This was followed by a succession of gushy reports from the red carpet, where an endless stream of besotted fans were asked for their impressions of the occasion.

And adding to the mix were interviews with the Greens about how the movie would create a low wage economy and an animal rights activist harping on about alleged mistreatment of animals during its making.

Scintillating stuff, but as they say, there was more.

In the rural news section we were told the film could help boost sales of New Zealand wool or something to that effect.

Quite frankly, it defies belief that Morning Report ignored the most obvious and important questions about the entire event or, at the very least, failed to explain why it felt unable to ask them.

Or did I nod off while listening to other worthy but dull stories about the Privacy Commission, Felix Geiringer and the Novopay system and miss something?

To clear the matter up, NBR ONLINE contacted Radio New Zealand News.

Spokesman Tony Vale conceded there had been no review of the film but said it was because of a Warner Bros embargo.

“We were admitted to the media screening but like other media signed an agreement that we would broadcast no thoughts, comments, views or reviews until the film screened in the States.”

Which begs the question: why the state broadcaster did not show the same enterprise as Stuff, which thumbed its nose at the draconian demands of the Hollywood mogul?

Its reporters interviewed a raft of people as they left the theatre after the screening and beat everyone else to the punch, which is what good journalism should be about.

They even got to talk to Gerry Brownlee and Peter Jackson’s 16-year-old daughter Katie, who was  bowled over by the movie.  

“It was amazing,” she said. “It’s very close to home with Lords of the Rings and I think Hobbit fans will enjoy it very much.” 

Comments from others were equally fulsome, ranging from fantastic and gorgeous, to awesome and arresting.

Of course, not everyone got to see the show, including the Greens – who were not invited.

Asked whether they would have attended had they been invited, Greens communications director Andrew Campbell told NBR ONLINE:

“I don’t know. That’s a moot point. We hadn’t discussed it because we weren’t invited.”

So were they miffed at not getting an invitation?

“Oh no. Obviously, going to those things is a bit of a perk of the job for some MPs, but we’re not overly fussed.”

The Labour party, though, was luckier and did receive some invitations.

As a result Mr Shearer and MPs Grant Robertson, Annette King and Jacinda Ardern turned up, notwithstanding the Hobbit-hating party’s shared distaste with the Greens of the way in which the film deal was put together.

In fact, Mr Shearer, unfazed by the embargo, told NBR ONLINE that he “really enjoyed the movie, particularly the amazing cinematography”.

“It was a great example of the fantastic skills we have in New Zealand when it comes to special effects technology and film making.

“The film showcased the amazing beauty of our landscape and the smart technology we offer.”

Mr Shearer said Labour is a strong supporter of the film industry and introduced an incentive scheme under the previous government.

“We did not support the current government’s decision to rush through changes to employment law without the proper process for New Zealanders being able to have their say.” 

Not surprisingly, Mr Brownlee, who was heavily involved in the negotiations with Warner Bros to keep the movie in New Zealand, was mightily impressed with what he saw and did not let an embargo get in the way of a good news story.

Mr Brownlee, an embargo enforcer, launched an attack on NBR earlier this year for reporting major Christchurch announcements on their news value rather than when the government wanted them spun.

He told NBR ONLINE it was “very entertaining and a truly brilliant film”.

“I’m sure it’s going to be just as popular as the Lord of the Rings.

“The technology is incredible, you’ve got that 48 frames a second 3D, a sound system that’s quite unique and then all of the extraordinary work done by the digital people.

“It was most definitely worth all the money and taxpayer subsidies that went into it.”

Mr Brownlee says he is convinced New Zealand will receive “some extraordinary exposure from these films and also send out a message that New Zealand is a good place to do business in”.

“I will personally be paying to see the movie again – I want to take my younger kids along to have a look at it and I can’t wait for its public release.”

Mr Brownlee believes the arguments over the concessions which were made to have The Hobbit made here “have very much fallen by the wayside because we can all see the very clear benefits from engaging in this sort of activity”.

“I mean, we are really talking about an industry that sits in behind those movies that will have huge ongoing benefits.

“It was also pretty amazing last night to see Sir Peter Jackson and James Cameron, two of the most innovative movie-makers in the world, having a conversation about their projects and doing it right here in Wellington, New Zealand.

“I can tell you it was pretty impressive.

“The best bit for me, though, were the 3000 names on the credits at the end, all the people who worked on this production.

“That was great.”


This article is tagged with the following keywords. Find out more about My Tags

Post Comment

13 Comments & Questions

Commenter icon key: Subscriber Verified

Shearer and his hobbit-hating mates hobnobbing as if they didn't try to torpedo the whole project. Shameless hypocrites.


Back to the days of picking winners!
Let's hope our pollies are more successful this time; previously, their picks have been disastrous.


Congratulations to Sir Peter Jackson on the way in which he has successfully steered this project through,and has corralled politicians and the overseas interests to bring it to a successful conclusion.


@ #2 come on buddy. If the Hobbit isn't a winner what the heck is? LOTR has done more for New Zealand tourism and brand NZ than the countless hundreds of millions we've squirted down the cashflow urinal in the past.

Let's celebrate out successes and talk them up. Stop being such a bunch of grumpy old grinches.


The issue isn't whether the Hobbit s a winner or about celebrating local success. The issue is using public money to help the profits of private enterprise and changing the law to lower Kiwi wages.

If I want my money to fund movie making then I will buy shares in the enterprise. Stop expecting my taxes to pay for dividends in companies I am not a shareholder in.


Hardly public money. If the film wasn't made here the money wouldn't have been spent/tax paid. It's good for NZ regardless of whether you like dwarfs, etc. 3 x 1.5 hour advertisements for NZ is best bang for your buck you can get.


Can someone please show me where New Zealand appears in the Hobbit?


Well, with the attitudes here I am amazed anyone would bother. Would the last person to leave these god forsaken isles please turn out the lights.


Sad to see Radio New Zealand cede its editorial control to Warner Bros.

If there was one news organisation left in New Zealand that we expected to say no to opinion shaping it is RNZ.

Please put Mary Wilson in charge immediately.


No one ceded control to Warner Bros or anyone else. You ought to get out more, get into business and see how the world works. Considering the multi-billions we spend every year for people to sit on their asses, $65M was a good investment.

And remember Labour started this with LOTR


Can we just move on from the bloody Hobbit ?? .. hasn't Rod Vaughan got better stuff to do that this ??? RNZ and the rest of the media can do what they like WE DON"T CARE THAT MUCH ...

Now, back to the business reporting eh ?


Hideous creatures. Would like to deal to all of them with a baseball bat.


We need a few more Fonterra-sized earners to drag us out of the mire ... and the film industry can be one of them. In fact, it's already proven.
Let's stop the bashing and start some encouragement.


Post New comment or question

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

NZ Market Snapshot


Sym Price Change
USD 0.7740 -0.0003 -0.04%
AUD 0.9511 0.0005 0.05%
EUR 0.6324 -0.0002 -0.03%
GBP 0.4954 0.0001 0.02%
HKD 6.0039 0.0001 0.00%
JPY 92.5100 -0.0050 -0.01%


Commodity Price Change Time
Gold Index 1195.4 -2.890 2014-12-19T00:
Oil Brent 61.4 2.110 2014-12-19T00:
Oil Nymex 57.1 2.740 2014-12-19T00:
Silver Index 16.0 0.090 2014-12-19T00:


Symbol Open High Last %
NZX 50 5518.5 5545.0 5518.5 0.17%
NASDAQ 4752.6 4782.1 4748.4 0.36%
DAX 9901.3 9901.3 9811.1 -0.25%
DJI 17778.0 17874.0 17778.2 0.15%
FTSE 6466.0 6566.9 6466.0 1.23%
HKSE 23158.3 23189.6 22832.2 1.25%
NI225 17511.0 17621.4 17210.0 2.39%