Agricultural chemical company Orion Crop Protection has successfully complained that one of its branded weedkillers has been hurt by comparative advertising used by rival Nufarm NZ
But the victory -- in which a panel put together by the Advertising Standards Authority ruled that Nufarm advertising for its Roundup Transorb attacked and disparaged Orion's GForce Max -- has come late in the day for Orion.
The panel today noted that Nufram had said its radio and television advertisements were due to end their run in three days, and it only had 1000 brochures for the product left over.
Both herbicides are unusual in having a 54 percent content of the active ingredient, glyphosate. Orion introduced its version in May 2005, and Nufarm then brought out its own, which had been registered two years before but not sold.
The panel said farmers would have been likely to have been misled by Nufarm's advertisements, which:
* made ambiguous comparisons, such as "up to 30 percent more effective";
* the content of the comparison appeared to have been chosen to give Transorb an artificial advantage;
* the comparative tests were conducted by a parent company, Monsanto, rather than an independent and objective body;
* the advertisements denigrated products labelled as "imitators", and in the process left consumers to assume one of those was GForce Max.
The panel said imitations were copies and intrinsically inferior to an original product -- it would have been better for specific products to be named, so that others such as the Orion herbicide were not smeared.
This article is tagged with the following keywords. Find out more about MyNBR Tags
- Loss of Premier League rights reveals limit to Spark's on-demand video ambition
- Milk price rise has economists scratching their heads
- Behold Fanpass, Sky's streaming video service that actually works – and today it's free
- This week in politics: Parliament starts
- Blame the architects for the building my company is about to destroy
Most listened to
- Sir Bob Jones on the state of New Zealand architecture
- ForBarr analyst Blair Galpin on the Premier League development - and the future of sports broadcasting as technology shifts
- Macquarie's Brad Gordon on Michael Hill's "very good" results
- Nevil Gibson in his latest Editor's Insight on whether we've seen the end of El Nino
- RNZ chief executive Paul Thompson on what it means to be included in the commercial radio survey