Member log in

Raunchy Moa prospectus paid ads a 'world first', says Ross

BUSINESSDESK: The inclusion in a prospectus of paid advertising for luxury cars, shotguns, scented candles and Working Style suits is thought to be a "world first" by Moa director and brand guru Geoff Ross.

Released yesterday, the prospectus is one of the first to be issued under the Financial Markets Authority's new guidelines, which specify offer documents should be concise and not overuse brand imagery or irrelevant material.

The 132-page blurb channels a mix of the Mad Men TV series and up-market men's magazine FHM, featuring black and white shots of Moa's all-male board and management striking macho poses in sharply cut suits, while attractive women in black skirts, white blouses and ties fondle cigars and bottles of Moa.

A section headlined Investment Highlights appears beside one such full -age photograph, while in another Moa general manager Gareth Hughes taps out a cigar into an ashtray a model is holding above her head.

Advertisements in the prospectus include plugs for Aston Martin sports cars and Beretta rifles, while a naked woman on a horse promotes Ecoya scented candles, which Ross floated on the NZX in late 2010.

The FMA says it saw and approved the document and that its role was to support the production of compelling, readable investment statements.

"We don't seek to stifle innovation," Sue Brown, the FMA's head of regulatory operations, says. "Innovation is an important part of promoting growth in New Zealand's capital markets.

"The key information potential investors need to make informed investment decisions is carried in the first three sections of Moa's Investment Statement, which is free of advertising and imagery.

"We are not, and do not seek to be, an arbiter of good taste."

The regulator was "satisfied that the Moa Investment Statement meets the legal requirements".

However, that process was not all plain sailing.

Moa took early versions to the FMA for advice and ended up stripping out all advertising and other extraneous material for the first 14 pages, covering the statutory requirements of the "investment statement" section.

This outlines key elements and risks of the offer, although financial information, projections and disclosures about directors' interests fall later in the document.

Mr Ross told BusinessDesk the document targeted the 30 to 50 year old, high-income men that Moa seeks as customers and investors as it pushes to create an identifiably New Zealand brand in the fast-growing boutique beer market, especially the US.

"It is somewhat Mad Men," he said, appealing to "men who want moments of manhood".

"If you go to [Wellington waterfront restaurant] Shed 5 on a Friday, there a whole lot of guys in suits having a drink. It's their vernacular, their mentality."

Mr Ross says part of the Moa proposition was the company's branding smarts, while the FMA was focused on "ensuring that people read the investment statement and that it's an engaging document".

"In many ways, it highlights the core elements of the offer."

Mr Ross believed the inclusion of paid advertising for other brands in a prospectus was "a world first", although not all investors are impressed.

"I know beer companies always sail close to the wind on advertising," professional investor Aaron Bhatnagar says.

"But having them advertise unrelated products for other companies in a financial statement? I think it's great we have new companies come onto the NZX, and we should have a culture of start-ups, but I'm not sure this helps."

The paid spots had helped offset, but not covered the cost of publishing the prospectus, Mr Ross says.

Comments and questions
18

It's not raunchy it is just nasty ! Nasty little men and their nasty little company.

Not bad, they take out $1.6m in relation to fees for the offer. Geoff gets $240k as CEO and for a company that's never made a dime and has just $1.2m in real assets, they value there holding at $17m.
This is breath taking.

Wouldn't be surprised if Tui rip off this concept and make an ad featuring raunchy women. Wait ...

Moa and Working Style are quite similar - very average products hiding behind inflated branding and imagery.

Although I expect Working Style spend most of their time marketing to their customers rather than their shareholders?

Although this offer is a complete crock you can't help but admire their marketing skills. These types have got the blueprint nailed down pretty well actually:

- invest as little of their own money as possible, as late as possible before the IPO so not too much of their own cash is burned
- float the crappy business and get plenty of cash in the door at a ridiculous valuation so they won't need any more for a while (key: use brokers with network of retail punters for clients who don't know anything about how financial markets work)
- rip out heaps of fees in the float to recoup some of their previous investment
- set aside some cash to prop up the share price over the first 12 months so no-one feels too bad about life
- appoint themselves as the CEO at a whopping great salary
- on the business side of things, spend a heap of money buying market share and burning cash
- in 1-2 years time when the cash pile gets a bit low, buy a much better existing business in the same space that, when combined with the initially floated business, disguises how crappy the original business was (think Trilogy / Ecoya, and think Phoenix/Charlies)
- use this acquisition to raise more cash at another ridiculous valuation so they don't get too diluted
- sit back and pray that some idiotic corporate will have a strategic shocker when someone with an ego gets to the top and wants to complete a public takeover for their CV

That about right boys?

Deservedly cyncial conclusion....I like it.

LOL, on the button. Well explained in laymans language. It's almost formulaic.

This erudite analysis is so on the money!

Wonder, where the neck of that bottle will up in?

Some un-hole-y place, I imagine.

Did he really just use Shed 5 as a reference site? I thought the brand was meant to be aspirational, not outdated.

A bunch of ambitious stylists playing in the commercial world!

OMG. Who are all of these people whose comments just tear down every new thing that people are trying. Get out and try something yourself!

A world first or a world worst? I WAS a potential investor until I looked at the front cover of the Investment Statement. That was enough to say NO NO NO NO thank you. And then I looked inside. Heaven help New Zealand

Not sure you're telling the truth here buddy. Sounds like the deal was 2x sold before launch so not sure how you could have got any stock now anyway given you're so incensed by the prospectus. Nice try though buddy.

Wow. This website has just become a bastion for negativity. Good on these guys. Go the nz capital markets for supporting this.

Great product. But Very difficult to reconcile FMA’s soft comments with their disclosure guidance notice (http://www.fma.govt.nz/media/1105126/guidance_note_-_effective_disclosure_june_2012.pdf)  at para 57 see
 
Brand information
Can and should support, but not dominate, a disclosure document, otherwise you risk selling the brand rather than the offer.
Photographs and other images
Should only be used if they do not dominate, or distract or detract from the disclosures. Where appropriate, they should be meaningfully labelled.