Wheeler drawn into Greens politicking, says bank returns still below GFC levels

Graeme Wheeler
Greens co-leader Russel Norman

Reserve Bank governor Graeme Wheeler has scotched claims by the Green Party that he has a bias in favour of the country's Australian-owned banks and defended statements saying the lenders' return on equity is still below pre-crisis levels.

Mr Wheeler, who delivers his maiden monetary policy statement on Thursday, released bank profitability figures given to the Greens, which he used to support comments before parliament's finance and expenditure committee that bank profits were "about average or below" other developed nations.

Greens co-leader Russel Norman accused Mr Wheeler of misleading parliament over the claim, which is not directly addressed in the RBNZ statement.

Mr Wheeler released charts showing New Zealand's banks' after-tax return on assets and equity between 2009 and 2001 was in the bottom half of OECD countries, excluding the euro-area.

Pre-tax returns show New Zealand lenders' returns in the top six for the period. The comparisons are not clean-cut with some countries shown as before tax, and others after tax.

"My response to the select committee represented my understanding of the information available at the time," he stays in a statement.

"Our analysis was completed after the hearing and we released to the Green Party in response to their request which followed the hearing."

The November 7 select committee hearing on the central bank's financial stability report was Mr Wheeler's first appearance before politicians and degenerated into a farce when the governor, his entourage and everyone else were cleared from the room so MPs could argue about whether they could seek more time after a late start.

Mr Wheeler rejected the Greens' claim the central bank is biased towards the Australian lenders, saying the bank "takes seriously its mandate from parliament to supervise the New Zealand banking system and does so without favour".

The Australian lenders' profitability has recovered on a return on assets basis, but was still below pre-global financial crisis levels as a return on equity, he says.

"That's partly because these banks are building up capital as part of the tougher Basel III regulatory requirements." 

(BusinessDesk)

This article is tagged with the following keywords. Find out more about My Tags

Post Comment

10 Comments & Questions

Commenter icon key: Subscriber Verified

Why is there an assumption bank shareholders should eat lunch for free while shareholders of other companies contemplate possible Pike River/Feltex-like returns on and of capital?

Reply
Share

Anyone can buy shares in the Australian banks... if you think the returns are good, go for it!

Reply
Share

Ultimately at taxpayers' expense. This is the moral hazard that raises questions around profitability and how much such are genuinely achieved though efficent market force operation and how much through 'sweetheart' positioning on the back of regulation and so-called market stability. Market efficiency arguably comes through businesses getting cleaned out once and a while - not all, but those that either over-reach or become obsolete. But with the banking system, the taxpayer is like a trooper at Bighorn.

Reply
Share

Why on earth would Mr Wheeler, or anyone else, take any notice of Russel Norman on any matters relating to business or economics?

Reply
Share

Russel Norman shows his shallowness and naivety of business and finance, but shows his ability to play the man and not the ball. It will be a sad day for NZ if this avowed communist gets anywhere near the nation's Treasury benches.

Reply
Share

"Shows his ability to play the man and not the ball" ... you would never do that, would you!

Reply
Share

Get used to it, sunshine, he will be on the Treasury benchs unless Jonkey and his team get to grips with reality. The trading banks are gouging SMEs with punitive OD rates. Unfortunately for this red-neck conservative, Russel makes more sense Bill English. At least he understands my situtation.

Reply
Share

It's about time someone reminded people that Dr Norman is, or was, a member of the Communist Party. I wonder how many of the 14% or so who support Greens know that? God help us if he ever became finance minister, which is his stated objective.

Reply
Share

Norman is on to it. Wheeler is simply an apologist for the Aussie banks.

Reply
Share

Crowd pleaser - inciteful not!

Reply
Share

Post New comment or question

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

NZ Market Snapshot

Forex

Sym Price Change
USD 0.7881 0.0049 0.63%
AUD 0.9235 0.0087 0.95%
EUR 0.6297 0.0021 0.33%
GBP 0.4992 0.0010 0.20%
HKD 6.1097 0.0367 0.60%
JPY 92.6790 0.4210 0.46%

Commods

Commodity Price Change Time
Gold Index 1197.1 3.900 2014-11-25T00:
Oil Brent 80.1 -0.140 2014-11-25T00:
Oil Nymex 74.1 -1.660 2014-11-25T00:
Silver Index 16.6 0.170 2014-11-25T00:

Indices

Symbol Open High Last %
NZX 50 5442.7 5465.6 5442.7 0.27%
NASDAQ 4760.2 4774.2 4758.2 0.27%
DAX 9894.6 9942.7 9861.2 0.53%
DJI 17812.2 17831.0 17814.9 -0.06%
FTSE 6731.1 6765.0 6731.1 0.06%
HKSE 23833.2 24176.6 23843.9 1.12%
NI225 17348.0 17432.6 17407.6 -0.14%