Rent vs Buy — a new financial calculator

Alistair Helm

The decision of whether to rent or to buy is often not purely a financial consideration. It may well be about flexibility and lifestyle or, as seems more common at the moment, the access to that deposit is limiting the opportunity to purchase.  

If the financial consideration is a big driver of the decision, you will be pleased to know there is an excellent online tool published by The New York Times that helps to answer the question "when is it financially better to rent than to buy." To be clear, the online tool is primarily built for renters to help see the point at which it becomes better to buy than to rent.

The beauty of the app is that there are a wide variety of inputs that dynamically allow the calculation to be personalised and while it is a US app it can be just as relevant to the New Zealand market.

The app requires some inputs to begin which you key into to the calculation such as real estate fees, mortgage rates, inflation, investment rates, local and personal taxes as well as current inflation in property prices and rents. With all of these inputted, the key factors to examine are how long you plan to stay in the house and the price of the type of house you are looking to buy. It is also valuable to then go back and see the impact of property price inflation and rent increases as they affect the decision threshold. 

Before you have a go with the app I would recommend you have a watch of this screencast I have published which walks you through the app together with advice around the input levels.

Former CEO Alistair Helm is founder of Properazzi.

Got a question about this story? Leave it in Comments & Questions below.

This article is tagged with the following keywords. Find out more about MyNBR Tags

NZ Market Snapshot


Sym Price Change
USD 0.6625 0.0095 1.45%
AUD 0.9122 0.0050 0.55%
EUR 0.6261 0.0101 1.64%
GBP 0.4390 0.0051 1.18%
HKD 5.1357 0.0729 1.44%
JPY 81.4100 1.2610 1.57%


Commodity Price Change Time
Gold Index 1065.8 9.600 2015-11-30T00:
Oil Brent 44.7 -0.510 2015-11-30T00:
Oil Nymex 41.6 -0.120 2015-11-30T00:
Silver Index 14.1 0.040 2015-11-30T00:


Symbol Open High Last %
NZX 50 6107.5 6150.7 6100.1 0.83%
NASDAQ 5139.6 5141.4 5127.5 -0.37%
DAX 11268.3 11430.9 11293.8 0.78%
DJI 17802.8 17837.2 17798.5 -0.44%
FTSE 6375.1 6387.1 6375.1 -0.30%
HKSE 22197.8 22459.7 21996.4 2.07%
NI225 19799.1 19962.6 19747.5 0.96%