Stiassny's $127m GST claim hits Supreme Court

Michael Stiassny

Lawyers in the Supreme Court fighting to recover a $127.5 million GST payment say the money was paid to the IRD on a "mistaken assumption".

KordaMentha receivers Michael Stiassny and Grant Graham have been battling for some years to recover a GST payment they made when they took over as receivers of Forestry Corporation of New Zealand and Citic New Zealand in 2003.

Although FCNZ and CNZ were placed in receivership, the receivers were not appointed in respect of the Central North Island Forest Partnership.

In court today, CNIFP's lawyer Ralph Simpson said the crucial question in the appeal is whether or not the money was paid from the receivers' account or the partnership's account.

The 170,000ha forest was sold in 2003 for $US621 million, and a GST payment of $127.5 million was made to the IRD from Messrs Stiassny and Graham.

In March, the Court of Appeal struck out Mr Stiassny’s claim against the IRD to recover the funds and stopped creditors from gaining access to the millions.

However, at the time, Court of Appeal Justice Tony Randerson concluded:

"It is not in dispute that if the CNIFP (as the person registered for GST purposes) had been placed in receivership, then the receivers would have been the specified agent of the CNIFP.

"As such, the receivers would have been liable personally on the basis they were the specified agents of an incapacitated person within the meaning of the section.

"Counsel all agreed the difficulty for the commissioner is the CNIFP was not placed in receivership and was not therefore an incapacitated person.

Prima facie, the receivers were not therefore specified agents within the meaning of the section and were not personally liable for the payment of GST."

That ruling followed an earlier High Court decision which declined to strike out an application to recover the GST.

In May, the Supreme Court granted leave to appeal to look at whether any of the appellants can recover the amount of GST "so paid from the commissioner on the basis it was paid by the receivers under a mistaken belief they were personally liable to pay it or on any other basis".

A full court of Justices Tom Gault, William Young, John McGrath, Robert Chambers and Peter Blanchard is hearing the appeal.

Mr Simpson says the receivers' payment was based on a mistaken assumption they would be personally liable for any penalties.

He says when the payment was made, it was split into two components – the $US621 million was calculated in US dollars and placed into a US account, while the GST payment was made in New Zealand dollars, put into an account and deposited over the Christmas period.

The hearing continues tomorrow.

This article is tagged with the following keywords. Find out more about My Tags

Comment & Question

Commenter icon key: Subscriber Verified

Post New comment or question

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

NZ Market Snapshot

Forex

Sym Price Change
USD 0.7845 0.0017 0.22%
AUD 0.8994 0.0002 0.02%
EUR 0.6203 0.0010 0.16%
GBP 0.4929 0.0003 0.06%
HKD 6.0847 0.0131 0.22%
JPY 84.0120 0.0180 0.02%

Commods

Commodity Price Change Time
Gold Index 1233.8 -1.760 2014-10-14T00:
Oil Brent 85.4 -4.470 2014-10-14T00:
Oil Nymex 81.2 -4.530 2014-10-14T00:
Silver Index 17.4 0.035 2014-10-14T00:

Indices

Symbol Open High Last %
NZX 50 5145.9 5168.7 5145.9 0.33%
NASDAQ 4246.2 4281.3 4213.6 0.32%
DAX 8765.4 8854.4 8812.4 0.15%
DJI 16321.9 16463.7 16321.1 -0.04%
FTSE 6366.2 6403.4 6366.2 0.42%
HKSE 23087.5 23230.3 23048.0 0.67%
NI225 15009.8 15044.3 14936.5 -0.13%