Strategic Finance investors get another 1.5 cents in the dollar
BUSINESSDESK: Investors in Strategic Finance this month got paid another 1.5 cents in every dollar they had put into the failed lender and are still facing a best-case scenario of clawing back 26% of their principal, says the latest receiver's report.
Some 10,000 investors owed $367.8 million have been paid 8.5 cents in the dollar, or $31.3 million, of their principal, and receivers John Fisk and Colin McCloy of PwC have kept their forecast recovery of between 12% and 26% in their latest update on the failed finance company.
Between September 11 and March 12 the receivers recorded $2.1 million in receipts from the loan book, taking total recoveries to about $31 million.
"We iterate that realising property in the New Zealand market remains challenging and on a number of the loans, secured over property, it is difficult to assess the level of recovery," the report said.
"This is particularly so for development and coastal properties, of which SFL [Strategic Finance] is heavily exposed."
In March, the Financial Markets Authority said it had dropped its investigation into the late Jock Hobbs, a former All Black and Strategic Finance director, after the extent of his cancer was made apparent to it.
At the time, the market watchdog was still looking at the failed lender and has yet to decide whether to lay charges.
The receivers have launched marketing campaigns for property in Gulf Harbour, Fiji and Northland, where Strategic holds loans over the sites, and is likely to recover funds from any sale.
They are also undertaking remedial work or securing resource consents on property in Northland, Australia and the Coromandel before putting the lots to market.
Strategic’s transactions came under scrutiny in December 2009 when former ACT Party MP and former associate commerce minister John Boscawen told the Parliament the finance company misrepresented about $68 million worth of debt which it classified as second mortgages when they were effectively a third-ranking security.
The receiver said it has concerns over "several transactions undertaken during February 2007 to August 2008" and is assessing whether to proceed with legal action.
The finance company was put in receivership in March 2010 after missing a milestone repayment, ending a moratorium arrangement that had been in place since the end of 2008.
It had tried to get out of trouble in a Hanover-style debt-for-equity swap with South Canterbury Finance that would have given Strategic investors a mix of SCF debentures, shares and preference shares, but Perpetual Trust chose to call in the receivers instead.























Comments and questions11
Nice to see the Stratgic Directors still have their Aston Martins !!!
Perpetual Trust. PwC. Strategic co. diretors.
Pity the investors!
How lame the authorities are with Strategic Finance and even politics stalled any action to cater for Jock hobbs and the Rugby World Cup
What a joke
Meanwhile the Strategic Finance turkeys drive top of the range cars like Astin Martins and live in Marine Parade and Cremorne Rd Herne Bay
It's not their fault that they still owe 91.5% of the investors money back - it was that horrible GFC thing.
Isn't it funny how property prices have not fallen 91.5% ( more like 30% ) and yet the Strategic Finance book has fallen that much. And the authorities don't smell a rat - or rats??
Even Hubbards SCF only lost about 40% but the authorities and politicians crucified him.
Are the Strategic Finance directors and Consultant that scary that the authorities are so frightened to touch them??
these boyz even call themselves the untouchables
If the Strategic Finance directors and Consultant had any credibility they would offer investors some of their millions as a measure of good faith - even if they don't accept responsibility for any wrong doing
This would be a sign that they acted in good faith and feel for the plight of the investors who fed the company which enabled extraordinary fees and dividends to be paid to these guys - even right up until the death knell these payments occurred.
Unlikely though
I also suppose that the legal fraternity who fed off Strategic and its directors will be staying quiet - in cas ethey get a knock at their doors by the receivers and liquidators advisors - the problem is the same professional fraternitys are unlikely to pot their cobbers who they went through Varsity with or who they have worked with at some of the big law and accounting firms.
Most people thought this only happened in Sicily - but it is alive and kicking here in good old NZ
The Auditors and Trustee should be held to account - they were both in a position of oversight - and had rights to access to all information - a Government agency ( FMA or Serious Fraud office) should lead the legal action against these two parties.
The Strategic Directors and Consultant are way too smart to get caught on anything here. They cranked that business up as far as it would go, then flicked it on to the Aussies and took circa $100m off the table in cash. Then when it all collapsed who was left to carry the can? simple the depositors. The FMA will struggle here because (a) they used the best lawyers and advisors and (b) they are not going to lie down and surrender....plus they have heaps of cash to fight. The Consultant has been through several of these issues before and has never lost, there is a reason for that.
The Banks are also culpible here.
They themselves borrowed of investors and lent large sums to Strategic Finance and its directors/Consultant.
They continue to this day to lend to their new companies and property developments.
So nothing has changed in the financial markets since the 1980's when these retribades first dipped into the almightty investor trough