Member log in

iPhone 4 released - a review of reviews

[UPDATE - Telecom has now announced its own Micro-SIMs, and iPad plans]

The fourth generation iPhone hit the shelves in the US, Japan, France, Germany and the UK today, provoking another wave of Applemania. US media reports say there were still queues at Apple stores hours after they opened.

The almost unanimous critics’ verdict: it’s the best smartphone on the planet - see the review round-up end of article for more.

(Separately, Apple has released version 4 or iOS 4 of the software that runs iPhones this week. This free upgrade can be installed on an iPhone 3GS, but not with all the features available for iPhone 4 owners. Read more about iOS4 here.)

In July, iPhone 4 it will be available in 18 more countries in July  and in September another 40.

New Zealand was among Apple's official list of countries to get the iPhone in July, but yesterday  a Vodafone NZ rep still not confirm for NBR when the iPhone 4 would arrive here. The official word is still "within a few months".

Uh-oh XT
Nevertheless, iPhone 4 is excellent news for Vodafone.

For a key feature of the iPhone 4’s squarer design is that it’s 24% thinner than its predecessor.

To help accommodate the super-thin design, Apple has become the first major phone maker to switch to a totally new type of SIM card called a MicroSim (also used by the 3G version of the iPad) which, as its name suggests, is physically smaller than the SIMs used by most today.

That means Kiwi iPhone users will no longer be able to simply pop an XT SIM card into their Apple handset then connect to Telecom’s network (and, indeed, a certain Telecom division will not be able to sell the iPhone 4 on the sly, as it does with today’s model).

Fanboys point to Telecom’s plan, vague expressed by one of its staffers, to release a MicroSIM for XT. But the telco has no official timeline. And with no cellphones in its line-up (or near future line-up) that require the new format chip, it lacks the necessary (if thin) excuse for releasing a MicroSIM.

(It is possible to execute a "scissor hack", whereby a traditional SIM is quite literally cut to fit a MicroSIM slot. If you're comfortable with a cleaver, checkout this illustrated guide. But I'm not sure whether average customers or corporates will be comfortable with the cut-up.)

All 3G, all the time
The other big bonus for Vodafone: iPhone 4 supports 900MHz, the 3G frequency the mobile operator uses nationwide (the previous model only supported 2100MHz, the frequency Telecom and Vodafone use in urban areas; iPhone 4 also supports the 850MHz frequency used by Telecom nationwide).

A quick recap of iPhone 4’s headline features:

  • a 9.3mm thick case, 24% thinner than the iPhone 3GS. Apple claims this makes the iPhone 4 the world's slimmest smartphone
  • a front-mounted camera for videoconferencing, and video chat software
  • the ability to record video in high definition 720p
  • a move to a micro-SIM card, as used by the iPad (but none of today’s cellphones, making it harder for Telecom users to network hop; more on that here)
  • rear camera upgraded to 5 megapixels with LED flash
  • the same size screen (3.5-inch) but, at 960 x 640, four times the pixel count of the current iPhone 3GS and, according to Apple, the highest resolution smartphone display on the market
  • HSPDPA/HSUPA support (7.2Mbit/s down and 5.8 Mbit/s up)
  • space saved by micro-SIM has been used for a larger battery, which Apple says increases talk time by 40% to seven hours

Here’s what the most influential US critics made of iPhone 4 this week:

Walter Mossberg, The Wall Street Journal
What’s hot:
“With the front-facing camera, and clever new software called FaceTime, Apple has brought simple, high-quality video calling to mobile phones, albeit, for now, only over Wi-Fi and only among iPhone 4 owners.”
“Dramatic redesign ... radically sharper screen.”
Pointed criticism:
Only available on one phone network in the US.
Verdict:
"In both hardware and software, it is a major leap over its already-excellent predecessor, the iPhone 3GS [that] keeps it in the lead in the smartphone wars.”

David Pogue, The New York Times
What’s hot
“The first thing you notice is the new shape. Despite a beefier battery (16% more likely to last a full day), a faster processor and upgraded everything, the new model is still noticeably thinner and narrower than before. How is that possible? It’s beautiful ... it feels solid and Lexus-like”.
Pointed criticism:
“It’s now impossible to tell by touch which way it’s facing in your pocket.”
“The new metal mute and volume buttons are much stiffer”
Verdict:
“The iPhone is no longer the undisputed king of app phones. In particular, the technically inclined may find greater flexibility and choice among its Android rivals. [But] if what you care about, however, is size and shape, beauty and battery life, polish and pleasure, then the iPhone 4 is calling your name.

Melissa Perenson, PCWorld.com
What’s hot:
“The new ‘Retina display’ - so named because it surpasses the number of pixels the human retina can process - greatly improves the sharpness, clarity, and visible detail of images. I'd liken the magnitude of difference to that between a standard-definition 480p DVD and a high-definition 1080p Blu-ray Disc: When you view both on an HDTV, the differences are striking. And once you see them, you can't go back.”
“[Apple delivers on the promise of making multitasking work smoothly.”
Pointed criticism:
None.
Verdict:
“A must-have for anyone with an original iPhone or iPhone 3G. And people who have an iPhone 3GS will find this a worthy upgrade, too.”

More by Chris Keall

Signup to free NBR email alerts here

Comments and questions
19

which will help Vodafone users in the cities.

[The metal strip around the outside of the iPhone 4 houses an aerial; a new design touch. It's the first time we've seen external antenna - albeit disguised - since the days when cellphones had pull-up aerials. - CK]

XT micro sim solved?
http://tinyurl.com/2f6dhah

Isn't Voda's 900MHz coverage mainly outside urban area's where they still rely on 2100MHz (which has issues with signal penetration into buildings etc.)?
Quick check of their coverage map tells me I can get 900MHz coverage in Huntly, but not Auckland CBD...

Also starting to see reports of signal issues with the new aerial: http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/technology/8759590.stm

The new 3GS 8GB is on Vodafone's online store at a sharp price.

Gen-i are planning to launch micro sims and sell the ipad and iphone 4.

Sounds like you and your work mates at Gen-i are dreaming again!

Vodafone use both 2100Mhz & 900Mhz UMTS for their 3G Network, around New Zealand.

2100Mhz UMTS is used in Urban areas, for capacity reasons & this is utilised in larger cities & towns, proven by your "quick look" with Auckland having 2100Mhz UMTS.

900Mhz UMTS is used in rural areas & smaller towns & your "quick look" on the Vodafone Coverage map shows this to be true, with Huntly having 900Mhz UMTS.

Chris clearly outlined this in his article, by saying "The other big bonus for Vodafone: iPhone 4 supports 900MHz, the 3G frequency the mobile operator uses nationwide (the previous model only supported 2100MHz, the frequency Telecom and Vodafone use in urban areas".

So, what is your point exactly??

Because Steve Jobs doesn't trust the XT network to give his customers a good experience.

Until they can prove they have the network working as it's supposed to, there will be no iPad or iPhone sold through Telecom, even by Gen-i.

Gen-i isn't helping by buying them at retail and selling them to its own customers - Apple hates that kind of thing and won't be impressed.

Same goes for Two Degrees - most of its customer base roams on Vodafone's network so it too won't get a look in until it can provide evidence that Steve's customers will have a good time with them.

If you hold it correctly.

But its not a hardware issue - its a user issue.

I guess my point is that existing iPhone users on Voda who have complained about poor 3G performance based on 2100MHz urban coverage won't see any benefit in those urban area's from the addition of 900MHz support!

The issues of 2100MHz in built up area's are still there, and I'm not sure it's at all true to say that XT uses 2100MHz exclusively in Urban area's, I'm sure i've read that it's only used for in-fill coverage and that the main frequency is 850MHz accross the board.

Until the iPhone 4 Handset "is actually released in New Zealand" we don't know what the performance will be like on 2100Mhz UMTS. iPhone 4 has a new aerial (although some reports are concerning about this) new radio hardware/software, new everything.

Are you telling me, you don't travel outside of the major cities??

2100Mhz is being improved upon all the time, more coverage is being added, see here:

http://forum.vodafone.co.nz/topic/140-new-coverage/

Having 900Mhz UMTS is a major benefit, compared to the 3Gs which didn't have it, as it now means you get 3G coverage on vodafone, anywhere Vodafone have coverage in NZ. Before with the 3Gs - you dropped down to a pultry GPRS.

So, the addition of 900Mhz is a major boost......

If you watched the Apple iPhone 4 keynote presentation you can see an entire list of countries that will release the iPhone 4 in July! They aren't unnamed!

Also Vodafone's 900mhz 3G network is for rural areas only so Telecom still have the upper hand in terms of 3G coverage with the better 950mhz 3G frequency in urban areas.

I think you mean 850Mhz 3G - lol

@ Anonymous at 01:53 pm on June 25, 2010
re XT network performance... If Apple cared about network performance then surely Apple would have avoided AT&T's problematic network (it drops calls).

I’ve tested my iphone 3GS and data cards on XT and Vodafone in NZ and Vodafone / Telstra in Australia. I can categorically says the XT and Telstra networks (use the same frequencies) are the best for consistent 3G speed and reliability by far for 3G. It’s like night and day once you leave the main cities.

This is further supported by … even in my office in ChCh the Vodafone signal doesn’t work for 3G as the signal cannot penetrate the concrete walls and this is despite being close the the tower. Go Figure.

Funny how AT&T use 1900Mhz & 850Mhz UMTS - yet they still have still have so many issues with dropped calls & poor network performance.

I still get the odd dropped call for vodafone. I just figured thats what mobiles do.

In terms of the XT network I was really talking about data not calls. XT is soo much better for 3G data. Im connected to both XT and vodafone for data and don't work for either of them. Just my opinion based on experience.

Well, that's understandable, but as I understand it - XT are still well short of the total number of 3G customers that Vodafone currently have, therefore having more bandwidth to throw around.

Vodafone are upgrading with more Fibre backhaul as well, I follow @vodafoneNZdata on Twitter to get my updates about that aspect.

It's interesting to see side by side Speed Test comparisons with XT vs Vodafone Mobile BB, here is a link that makes interesting reading & may surprise you:

http://www.geekzone.co.nz/forums.asp?forumid=49&topicid=45681

Would be good to see some results from you as well :-)

If you want an average smart phone that looks good and you don;t mind coupling to iTunes that sucks your PC CPI dry when running then iPhone is great.

If you want a go forward, powerhouse smart phone, that has equally good looks (just pick any HTC model) and can sync over the air, that you can change the battery for, has USB and has FLASH. (frankly I don't care much for the animation of flash but to not support it leaves huge blanks in your browsing experience) Imagine reading a newspaper with article cut out throughout the paper, stupid.

Then get an Android phone.

The sooner Telecom twig onto this then the better. It's clear the Andriod OS will outstrip iOS within 24months or less

If you want an average smart phone that looks good and you don;t mind coupling to iTunes that sucks your PC CPI dry when running then iPhone is great.

If you want a go forward, powerhouse smart phone, that has equally good looks (just pick any HTC model) and can sync over the air, that you can change the battery for, has USB and has FLASH. (frankly I don't care much for the animation of flash but to not support it leaves huge blanks in your browsing experience) Imagine reading a newspaper with article cut out throughout the paper, stupid.

Then get an Android phone.

The sooner Telecom twig onto this then the better. It's clear the Andriod OS will outstrip iOS within 24months or less

Post new comment or question

Login to use your NBR member name
Full HTML is not supported but you can use the following tags in your comments:
Link: <url>link</url>
Quote: <quote>text</quote>