Units in 'overvalued' Fonterra fund take a tumble

Fonterra shareholder fund units dropped by more than 1% today as it joined the NZX50 and a research firm says the units are overvalued.

The dairy giant's fund – the first chance for non-dairy investors to get a slice of the New Zealand industry – has surged above its $5.50 offer price since listing in late November.

The fund (NZX: FSF) displaced Cavalier Corporation on the NZX50 today but by mid-afternoon had dropped 8 cents to $7.26.

Before the bookbuild, Morningstar Research warned of uncertainties with investing in the Fonterra units and said fair value was $5.50.

A fresh report, released this morning, reiterated that line – despite the units appreciating more than 30% since trading began less than two months ago.

The Morningstar report says the majority of Fonterra's returns relies on commodity products such as milk powder, which generates mid-single digit operating margins and has "no pricing power".

Fonterra will struggle to lift returns in higher-margin branded goods, the note says, because of competition from established multinationals Nestle and Danone.

"We believe the company is overvalued compared to our intrinsic value of $5.50 per unit."

Fonterra – the world's biggest dairy exporter – faces increasing competition in New Zealand, with two Chinese dairy companies announcing investments of $420 million in recent months.

dwilliams@nbr.co.nz

This article is tagged with the following keywords. Find out more about My Tags

NZ Market Snapshot

Forex

Sym Price Change
USD 0.7838 0.0010 0.13%
AUD 0.8932 -0.0009 -0.10%
EUR 0.6199 0.0011 0.18%
GBP 0.4888 0.0005 0.10%
HKD 6.0802 0.0082 0.14%
JPY 84.7660 0.1190 0.14%

Commods

Commodity Price Change Time
Gold Index 1228.6 -12.490 2014-10-23T00:
Oil Brent 86.8 2.120 2014-10-23T00:
Oil Nymex 82.0 1.530 2014-10-23T00:
Silver Index 17.1 -0.080 2014-10-23T00:

Indices

Symbol Open High Last %
NZX 50 5292.8 5344.4 5292.8 0.77%
NASDAQ 4427.4 4475.6 4382.9 1.60%
DAX 9008.6 9044.9 9047.3 -0.22%
DJI 16468.1 16767.5 16461.3 1.32%
FTSE 6419.1 6419.1 6419.1 -0.26%
HKSE 23311.9 23352.6 23333.2 -0.13%
NI225 15354.4 15377.0 15139.0 1.01%