Fisky business
Robert Fisk, the bestselling author and Middle East correspondent of the Independent, has lived in Beirut for three decades and holds more British and international journalism awards than any other foreign correspondent.
Among his less glittering accomplishments, however, the man who would "speak the truth to power" has allowed something of a cargo cult to be created around him here in New Zealand, where his first visit to these shores a couple of years ago was treated with the kind of rapturous media sycophancy that Fisk has supposedly spent a professional lifetime cautioning against. And nor did the reverential treatment end at that point, with reporters now routinely calling “Beirut Bob” to find out what’s really happening out on the Arab Street.
One imagines Fisk back in Beirut, perhaps, out on the balcony of his apartment enjoying a wine, and silently shaking his head in puzzlement as the cricketing cellphone announces another journalist calling him from New Zealand. All the more so, one supposes, since few, if any, of those antipodean callers would understand that his bravest work — in some respects, his only truly brave work —has been in maintaining a consistently anti-Shia line in his political writing about Lebanon, especially against the ghastly Amal but also the Party of God, while remaining resident in a city where writing these things can very quickly get you killed.
More of the same sycophancy is on the cards again for early next month when the famous correspondent returns to this country for what almost certainly will be among the most ubiquitous media tours in local publishing history.
Somebody thought to send us a copy of Fisk's confidential itinerary, helpfully put together by local publisher HarperCollins, which shows the guest already booked in with virtually every local reporter this side of the gardening and water polo beats. The schedule will also take in half the country's universities.
Among the confirmed sessions will be appearances at Auckland, Canterbury, Victoria and AUT Universities, meetings with Fairfax Media and APN editorial staff, television and radio spots without end and a no doubt reverentially attended public lecture chaired by Scoop's Gordon Campbell (whose first exposure to Fisk in book form happened to be our own copy of Fisk's swollen Lebanon study, Pity the Nation). And this is the same gent who endlessly claims to have been snubbed by large swathes of the mainstream international press?
Nor will the activity commence the moment the revered guest first steps off his flight from Dubai. A number of pre-recorded appearances have also already been scheduled, starting next week with a 20-minute interview with Radio New Zealand's Kathryn Ryan.
Probably the most headline-grabbing interlude is set to take place on September 9, when Fisk is booked to visit the Te Tirahou Marae in Glen Innes to meet with a number of the individuals nabbed in last year's anti-terrorism raids.
The publisher has arranged for the defendants to be at the venue for "an opportunity to engage with the first people subject to the terrorism suppression laws in this country in a Maori context." The timing is opportune, of course, and some would say mischievous, as the defendants' depositions hearing begins in September and is expected to last for the entire month.
Still, no one will be able to accuse the visitor of poking an unwelcome nose into local legal affairs simply for the money. The asking price for his marae visit, according to HarperCollins, is no more than "a mattress," should Beirut Bob wish to end his national tour by kipping over at the marae for the night. Pity the nation indeed.
Among his less glittering accomplishments, however, the man who would "speak the truth to power" has allowed something of a cargo cult to be created around him here in New Zealand, where his first visit to these shores a couple of years ago was treated with the kind of rapturous media sycophancy that Fisk has supposedly spent a professional lifetime cautioning against. And nor did the reverential treatment end at that point, with reporters now routinely calling “Beirut Bob” to find out what’s really happening out on the Arab Street.
One imagines Fisk back in Beirut, perhaps, out on the balcony of his apartment enjoying a wine, and silently shaking his head in puzzlement as the cricketing cellphone announces another journalist calling him from New Zealand. All the more so, one supposes, since few, if any, of those antipodean callers would understand that his bravest work — in some respects, his only truly brave work —has been in maintaining a consistently anti-Shia line in his political writing about Lebanon, especially against the ghastly Amal but also the Party of God, while remaining resident in a city where writing these things can very quickly get you killed.
More of the same sycophancy is on the cards again for early next month when the famous correspondent returns to this country for what almost certainly will be among the most ubiquitous media tours in local publishing history.
Somebody thought to send us a copy of Fisk's confidential itinerary, helpfully put together by local publisher HarperCollins, which shows the guest already booked in with virtually every local reporter this side of the gardening and water polo beats. The schedule will also take in half the country's universities.
Among the confirmed sessions will be appearances at Auckland, Canterbury, Victoria and AUT Universities, meetings with Fairfax Media and APN editorial staff, television and radio spots without end and a no doubt reverentially attended public lecture chaired by Scoop's Gordon Campbell (whose first exposure to Fisk in book form happened to be our own copy of Fisk's swollen Lebanon study, Pity the Nation). And this is the same gent who endlessly claims to have been snubbed by large swathes of the mainstream international press?
Nor will the activity commence the moment the revered guest first steps off his flight from Dubai. A number of pre-recorded appearances have also already been scheduled, starting next week with a 20-minute interview with Radio New Zealand's Kathryn Ryan.
Probably the most headline-grabbing interlude is set to take place on September 9, when Fisk is booked to visit the Te Tirahou Marae in Glen Innes to meet with a number of the individuals nabbed in last year's anti-terrorism raids.
The publisher has arranged for the defendants to be at the venue for "an opportunity to engage with the first people subject to the terrorism suppression laws in this country in a Maori context." The timing is opportune, of course, and some would say mischievous, as the defendants' depositions hearing begins in September and is expected to last for the entire month.
Still, no one will be able to accuse the visitor of poking an unwelcome nose into local legal affairs simply for the money. The asking price for his marae visit, according to HarperCollins, is no more than "a mattress," should Beirut Bob wish to end his national tour by kipping over at the marae for the night. Pity the nation indeed.
Signup to free NBR email alerts here
Share
Delicious
Digg
StumbleUpon
Reddit
Google
Yahoo
Technorati
Scoopit
















Comments and questions11
Can we move on from these obsessions with Robert Fisk and Nicky Hager? I'm no card-carrying fan of either, but lately it seems like every second column of yours is taking a swipe at them.
Criticism and obsession are rather different things, Bob. An example of the latter would be Hager on the National Party; hardly in the same league as a couple of brief items.
Hang on, who's got the obsession? Cohen's one of the few people in the NZ media who haven't interviewed Fisk!
The National Business Review's attempt to belittle international prize winning journalist Robert Fisk for meeting with Tuhoe activists at a Glen Innes Marae. and indirectly labeling him a traitor by calling him "Beirut Bob" (a clear reference to such names as, Hanoi Hanna, or Tokyo Rose.)
However the NBR saves most of its bile for the rest of the New Zealand media for straying from the anti-terror script, and accuses them of "rapturous media sycophancy" for daring to give coverage of this meeting.
Coming from one of the Washington's biggest war on terror sycophants in this country, it is, excuse the pun, a bit rich even for the NBR.
Realising they may have lost this particular media battle,"Pity the nation" is the NBR's final bitter comment.
Obviously the NBR are uncomfortable with any journalistic spotlight being shown on this particular scab on New Zealand's recent history, and would be far happier if their pro-war right wing journalism was the only voice allowed. And berates the rest of the media here for failing to obey the unwritten rules on self censorship that the 'International War on Terror' demands.
The National Zionist Business Review ?
Do I detect a certain "burn the intellectuals" tone? Goodness me not only has this man booked an appointment with our own home grown terrorists (believably and scornfully denied by Mr Fisk) but he has also been caught out communing with that other part of society that the right loves to hate -universities and intellectuals! Pity some of Mr Fisk's tenacity for the facts wasn't more evident in this medium.
Boo hoo. i love the fact that those who make the most whingey and negative comments are too gutless to put their names to it. Atleast Mr Cohen does. Even if i don't always agree with him, at least he's not towing the easy 'follow the herd' mentality that so many conglomerate owned media insist on.
There are two sides to every story, perhaps 'Mr University' (i assume as such, due to the fact that he/she puts university and intellectual together) might want to remember that.
Pat o'dea: did you note the date of this post? Written before Fisk had arrived, the 'rapturous media sycophancy' clearly applies to his last tour and anticipates the general tone of his current one. How do you take the sycophancy comment as an accusation of the media for 'daring to give coverage of this meeting'?? In fact David Cohen reported on it before anybody else knew it might be happening and pointed out that it would be a newsworthy meeting.
Anonymous, perhaps you should read some of the other articles David Cohen tends to write for the NBR including many news reports on the tertiary education sector.
David
Seeing as Fisk didn't visit the Te Tirahou Marae, I would be interested to know whether the itinerary you received was
A) A publisher's wish list?
B) The itinerary as planned but Robert Fisk declined the marae visit?
or C) A fabrication?
www.hidinginyourcupboard.blogspot.com
[url=http://www.mp3hunting.com] music search engine [/url]
[url=http://www.mp3hunting.com] music search engine [/url]
Post new comment or question
To share this article, click on a service below