KeallHauled

Chris Keall



Google leak will dent faith in the cloud

A glitch saw a small number of private Google Docs files stored on the net made public – and could put a big dent in people’s confidence in cloud computing.

US PC World reports that a Google error over the weekend that exposed 0.5% of private Google Docs files exposed to public scrutiny.

Google says if you were affected, you would have been notified by email, and that the hole has now been patched.

Google Docs product manager Jennifer Mazzon says, "The issue affected so few users because it only could have occurred for a very small percentage of documents, and for those documents only when a specific sequence of user actions took place."

Regardless, it’s going to make consumers think twice about using Google's various online Apps, which let you use a word processor, spreadsheet, presentation programme and other software - and files created by that software - that’s stored online rather than your PC.

Already, I’ve found chief information officers at large New Zealand companies wary of any software that stores information out on the internet (or “in the cloud” as the latest buzzspeak goes) rather than the safe confines of their own companies' networks.

Their reservations centred on fears of “user error” –such as Mr Computer Illiterate manager ticking the wrong box and inadvertently sharing his Google Calendar with the world – rather than Google being hacked, or as was the case over the weekend, spilling data by mistake. But this won’t help.

Others have found legal reasons for giving an all-Google Apps solution a swerve, such as the University of Auckland as it battens down for the Public Records Act coming into force next year.

Google’s privacy glitch is poorly-timed, too, coming on the back of a multi-hour Gmail outage that saw users of the $US50/year Premier version of Apps (including yours truly) receive a 15-day credit.

But, guess what? I’m sticking with Google Docs. A few glitches - heck, usually more glitches than this - happen with all systems (and user-error – if I had a dollar for every time somebody sent me a Microsoft Word document with revision-tracking left on ...).

But, for now, I’ll also be keeping my most secure documents on own PC, and on Microsoft Office.

Microsoft says its coming cloud computing version of Windows will let companies calibrate how much data they store out on the net, and how much within their own walls. We'll see how that goes.

Comments

The fact remains

The fact remains for millions of home users this remains a great option over the purchase of expensive software AND a cheap method of backing up data.

Company Security

I would beg to differ about an actual companies security. Most people assume that it is safe "at home", however I very much doubt that many people have the accurate skills to even make their company network secure. Even if their servers are secure, their network may not be thus I would trust Googles security anyday over an internal network.

Great Resource If Used As Intended

Our organisation uses google docs - excellent for sharing docs around an organisation that people are working on similtaneously.
We would never contemplate using it for information containing critical organisational information in the same way as we'd never email passwords and usernames details e.g. bank account logins. Afterall the internet is a public network that needs hefty security in place to make it secure.

Second time issue arises for Google this year

not a good or trustworthy look; especially considering it was second a glitch reported in Google cloud in only a couple of months: http://ebiztoday.wordpress.com/2009/01/23/cloud-computing/

Second time a problem for Google in 2009

not a good or trustworthy look; especially considering it was second glitch reported in only a couple of months: http://ebiztoday.wordpress.com/2009/01/23/cloud-computing/

Don't paint the cloud one colour

As will all discussions around the "cloud", ambiguiity reigns. There are three recognised layers to to cloud computing services: (1) Infrastructure as a Service or IaaS, (2) Platform as a Service or PaaS, and (3) Software as a Service or SaaS.

Issues with ther services offerings from one vendor in one layer should not be misinterpreted as issues with all vendors across all three layers.

The service in question is a SaaS offering from Google. An ambarrassing issue for them, indeed, but considering the reliability of some of their other SaaS offerings and the fact that they are not really marketed to the enterprise, not really a big issue. Indeed, think of all of the SaaS offerings you probably use every day as a consumer without questioning their security or reliability - or even that they are actually Software as a Service.

Most companies - from small to large enterprises - also make use of SaaS offerings, such as accounts software from Xero, CRM software from Salesforce.com, etc.

Post new comment

The information entered here will appear with your comment.
Leaving this field blank will default to anonymous.

More information about formatting options