Member log in

NZ iPhone 4 owners’ verdict on ‘grip of death’

[UPDATE: Ben is consumed by Grip of Death.]

In the US, Consumer Reports has put a damper on iPhone 4 “grip of death” hysteria.

READ ALSO: 
Telecom confirms Micro-SIM plans (hello, iPhone 4!)
Telecom reveals CDMA kill dates
Vodafone to offer dedicated iPad plans - how they could stack up

A study by the publication found the iPhone 4’s reception problem - caused when a user’s hand covers the lower left of the handset, inadvertently blocking the signal - is no better, or worse, than that of any typical smartphone [UPDATE: Consumer has now reversed its original finding.]

iPhone 4 has yet to be released in New Zealand, but those who’ve already snagged a handset have not encountered the problem.

“There’s no ‘grip of death’ that I am able to replicate,” tech blogger and possible super mayor candidate Ben Gracewood emailed Keallhauled, after using his iPhone 4 (from Parallel Imported) around Auckland for a day.

“I grabbed it in unnatural ways: double handed, wrapping my hands completely around the phone and covering both of the sensitive ‘black bands’, and noticed no signal decrease. I even tried bridging the bands with metal and couldn't see any issue,” Ben said.

And Layton Duncan, a developer with Polar Bear Farm, said he’d had no problems since buying an iPhone 4 in the UK then bringing it home to Christchurch.

“I've tried holding it the worst possible way at home (which has dodgy signal at the best of times) and I can't get it to lose connection,” Layton said - unlike his old iPhone 3GS, which did drop calls.

Faster than iPhone 3GS
Incidentally, Ben has got decent download (1.9Mbit/s) and upload speeds (1.3Mbit/s) speeds from his iPhone 4. That's faster than I've achieved with my iPhone 3GS, and it's as you'd expect given the 4's superior 3G technical smarts.

SIM cut down to size
And although Vodafone NZ has  just begun selling iPhone 4 and iPad-friendly Micro-SIMs  (for $29.95), Ben used a template provided by Parallel Imported to perform the scissor hack and literally cut SIM down to size (more on that issue here).

But although very impressed overall - especially by the new retina display - the uber-geek was said he was not feeling "that new gadget frission".

Asked by Keallhauled if he would spend his own money on an iPhone 4 (his Parallel Imported handset is a loaner), Ben replied:

"Probably not. It's not enough of a change from the 3GS. The screen is incredible, but the software is identical. I'm going to wait and see what Android 2.2 and Windows Phone 7 are like before making a purchase."

More by this author

Comments and questions
6

So I'm here in a spot in the ASB tower that has shockingly bad reception (I'm guessing something to do with being bathed in RF from the skytower microwave dishes). I'm lucky if 2 calls out of 3 work on my iPhone 3GS in this spot.

Gripping the iPhone by the base, I can make the bars drop from 4 to 2, but call quality is still massively better than the 3GS.

So my completely amateur conclusion is that the iPhone 4 issues are probably cropping up in very marginal signal areas.

Hey Ben,

Did you try the same thing but with 3G turned off?

On my 3G, especially out of Auckland, 2G reception was very poor on Vodafone.

Apple's calculation for signal strength was admitted as being wrong. Hence the grip 'o death oonly occurs in places of marginal reception where 4 bars of reception is shown, when the phone was actually only getting 1 or 2

Just to clarify, there is a $29.95 charge to swap your Prepay SIM to a MicroSIM, existing On Account and new On Account connections incur no cost.

Vodafone External Communications

2 degrees will sell a sim for much less. Whats the motivation to stay with vodafone when you charge so much for a sim? Price gouging at all?

hagving bought an iphone4 while overseas I've had frequent issues with the grip of death. abysmal 3g coverage on vodafone combined with dropped calls and some signal being reduced to no signal has seen me dump this piece of rubbish for an android device. needless to say the move to a new phone and a new network has dramatically improved things. take my advice the iphone 4 is a dog with fleas, dont buy it!

Post new comment or question

Login to use your NBR member name
Full HTML is not supported but you can use the following tags in your comments:
Link: <url>link</url>
Quote: <quote>text</quote>