Telecom XT: launch day speed tests
Pre-launch, Telecom boss Paul Reynolds claimed that a song could be downloaded over XT in 13 seconds.

This morning, using a Sierra Wireless 885u USB stick for XT ($399; a data card version costs $199), Keallhauled was able to down a 5MB song in 15 seconds.
No doubt that two second discrepancy will have some rivals screaming “Reynolds is a LIAR!” in our Comments section, as per usual, but like XT’s overall mobile data performance, it’s a solid result.

Wandering Auckland’s CBD, with the USB modem attached to a Lenovo Ideapad netbook, I was able to clock download speeds of between 1.4Mbit/s and 2.73Mbit/s.
That compares to a the peak speed Vodafone Vodem USB modem speed I’ve registered of 1.9Mbit/s (which was back in September). And the fastest I've clocked Telecom's T-Stick, which runs on its old CDMA netork, is around 0.5Mbit/s.
Others have clocked up to 3.6Mbit/s on XT, and you can squeeze more speed if you turn of all other internet apps, such as instant messaging and Skype, and tweak your operating systems comms settings. NBR preferred to test a regular, everyday experience.
Like Vodafone 3G (and the coming Two Degrees network) Telecom’s XT has a theoretical top download speed of 7.2Mbit/s. However, the vagaries of any cellular connection, anywhere - including how close you are to the nearest cell tower, how many obstacles are in between, the traffic-load on that cell tower, the quality of local backhaul from the tower etc etc - mean you can reasonably expect to hit about half the rated top speed.
By this measure, XT is performing capably. I do have the benefit of being one of only a handful of users so far. We’ll see how things shape up over the coming months as this particular data highway starts to fill with more traffic.


I clocked 2.73Mbit/s connecting to a New Zealand-based server (at speedtest.net).
Trying the same test from a server based in Australia, top speed dropped out to around 1.8Mbit/s.
Downloading data from the east coast of the US, it dropped again to 1.1Mbit/s (in terms of those so-so star ratings in the screen grabs, note that most benchmarks in the SpeedTest.net data base are for DSL or cable connections).
Again, there’s no surprise there; landline connections slow by a comparable amount when you tap international sites, which inevitably involve several weak links in the data chain.
Latency (lag) was not enough to slow multimedia. I was able to watch tvnzondemand videos and others as smoothly as on my landline DSL connection.
But, as with any wireless, internet connection, the lag was still too great for, say, heavy-duty multiplayer internet gaming.
Hitting download.com in the US, I pulled down the most popular file over XT - the 62MB freebie antivirus programme AVG. It took about five minutes, with XT maintaining consistent speed.
Fast downloads, slow price movement
I’d have no problem using XT for larger mobile data downloads, even it wasn’t Telecom’s pricing which, like Vodafone's, remains relatively steep compared to Australia and elsewhere..
At Telecom’s investor briefing yesterday, a questioner from the floor asked if XT would get so fast (and an upgrade to 21Mbit/s and faster is on the way) that it would start to Telecom’s DSL landline business.
Head of retail Alan Gourdie replied that there could be some cannibalisation, but it would be limited as Telecom rolled out faster landline products (such as its VDSL2 upgrade coming later this year), keeping DSL head (and way ahead in latency).
However, with Telecom and Vodafone (and, seemingly, even Two Degrees’) mobile data pricing so much higher than landlines, and twice the cost of Australia or Sydney, simple economics dictates that most users will prefer DSL.
That said, XT mobile data is clearly capable, and if you steer clear of huge downloads, it won’t break your bank balance (Telecom is charging $54.95 for 1GB/month, or $5 more than Vodafone, and $84.95 for 3GB/month to Vodafone's $69 to $79/month depending on plan).
Mr Gourdie says Telecom wants to increase the number of its customers regularly using mobile data from 5% to 20%, and double its number of mobile data devices to 185,000 in XT’s first year. By my experience today, he’s got a good shot.
Incidentally, the Sierra Wireless 885u USB was easy to install. Like other data dongles from Vodafone and others, it sell installed its software after I plugged it in, and getting online was as simple as clicking a connect button.
Like the Vodem, the Sierra Wireless 885u it takes a SIM card, and has bundled software for managing contacts, or sending txts, from your PC.
A microSD slot can take a memory card of up to 4GB, on a bring-your-own basis.
Speaking of BYO, I did have to rope up a Lenovo netbook myself. Telecom needs to get netbook and laptop embedded 3G deals happening, a la Vodafone's hook-up with Dell.


Voice performance
In terms of voice performance, I've been using XT with a Nokia 71 and Nokia 95 for several days now. Call clarity on both has been fine, with no drop outs or other problems. I doubt if, in a blind test, anybody could pick between XT and Vodafone 3G; both are running on essentially the same 3G technology, and again the usual vagaries of distance, traffic etc apply.
In short, XT's performance is fine. It's broader competitiveness, and success, is going to be shaped by factors like pricing, bundling with other Telecom services, and the Hammond campaign (personally, with the delayed launch, I've already reached my limit of Hamster tolerance and race for the remote when he appears).
Below, for the benefit of the Comments crowd, a command line ping to what I'm assured is a most popular site, nbr.co.nz:

Signup to free NBR email alerts here

Share
Delicious
Digg
StumbleUpon
Reddit
Google
Yahoo
Technorati
Scoopit
















Comments and questions31
Chris - the pricing for the 3GB plan on Vodafone is significantly better than Telecom's, as I detailed in your article "XT pricing revealed: Two Degrees boss says it doesn’t hold a candle to Singapore".
Here is part of what I posted again:
Vodafone's pricing on a term contract is:
http://www.vodafone.co.nz/shop/plansMobileInternet.jsp?plantype=data&billingMethod=onAccount&menuKey=mnit600004
3GB for $69.95 PLUS another 3GB for $10 = ***6GB*** for $79.95
On a 24 month term - this includes $300 off the device on the 3GB plan.
Additional Data is 50 cents per MB.
So - for less than what Telecom charge - you get ANOTHER 3GB of Data on Vodafone, on a 24month term contract. Telecom offer a discount on the device if you choose to go on a term plan, but the exact discount is not mentioned.
Also, as you mentioned - any speed tests are largely irrelevent due to next to no customers being on the Telecom network **at present**, whereas Vodafone have over 500,000. Do some more speed tests in another 6-12 months, then it may be be more accurate.
Furthermore - Speed tests are not accurate for ping response - can you provide any Command Prompt ping tests?
Further to my post above - just to clarify - Vodafone have over 500,000 customers on their 3G Network alone - & around 2.6Million on their whole network in New Zealand.
That's a good deal for 6GB - as far as it goes - but 50 cents a megabyte for additional data (=$500 a gigabyte) is a nosebleed.
I totally agree - BUT - Telecom also charge the same for overage @ 50cents per MB.
My point being - Vodafone's Mobile Broadband Plans still offer significantly more Data in the first instance.
Even with Vodafone's Open Term Plan - which costs $79.95 for 3GB & $89.95 for 6GB (being $10 "insurance" if you go over 3GB) compares more favourably than Telecoms offer.
http://www.telecom.co.nz/mobile/mobilebroadband/plansandpricing
Telecom charge $84.95 for 3GB & $15 for another 1GB - then 50cents per MB thereafter.
Furthermore - Chris - could you please post some Command Prompt ping times to popular websites??
I've added a command line ping for what I'm assured is the most popular nbr.co.nz.
I feel stupid I went out and purchased a E71 on a XT plan I have dropped 4 out of 6 calls today using the phone in my house. Never did that before on my Sanyo phone. So now I am testing the XT network for you telecom and not impressed. I will give it another week if not fixed I want my Sanyo phone hooked up again or another provider is looking better.
Calls are not ringing on my phone but going to voice mail, Should this happen? I called my number from office phone and it did the same thing twice and then the 3rd time phone rung. What am I doing wrong??
I was advised Telecom do not have SIM cards and my phone must be a Vodaphone handset and to call them. Now I am confused
Mark
That comment is just unbelievable - take it further Mark
Funny, just been reading the forums on Geekzone. Seems a number of new XT customers have been waiting hours just to have the SIM card registered. Lots of advice to leave the phone off and switch on often. Ah well it is new !! Good job they didnt launch 2 weeks ago !!! Everyone, why do you think after numerous attempts at getting it right, Telecom will get it right now. Look at the stats. 80% of world carriors have bought 900 / 2100 mhz at auction for huge sums of money many years ago for the 2G network, which means the deployed networks on 3G will be 900 mhz /2100 mhz. Telecom bought 850 15 years ago and have no choice but to deploy 850 3G. What do you think will happen outside of NZ. Also, The XT network is the only one in world without a 2G overlay.
I am trying to figure out what is going on my phone dropped 2 calls this evening right before Auckland Harbour Bridge. Not going over the bridge and the calls were from my wife on the homelne. I think I might return the phone I got today and go back to my Sanyo. What would you do?
I just saw a TV as and maybe their phones are designed for working while out on boats/ containers off the Auckland coast. I want to smash that top gear person.
Do you have a copy of the contract paperwork you signed? There will probably be a period during which you can change your mind, I'd find out how long that is and then give them until the day before to sort it out.
Don't want to lose my Telecom mobile number!!! angry angry angry
You won't lose your number, all networks allow number porting.
You can have an 027 number on Vodafone and vice versa.
But it will start with 021 and then the rest of my number the same
What I have now for example is 027 1234567 and that would change to 021 1234567 am I correct? This would not work out
Mark
Not at all.
You can be a Vodafone customer and have 027 1234567 as your number, even 029 1234567 if porting from TelstraClear.
Or you can be an XT customer with 021 1234567 as your number.
The govt said they wanted it that way and the telcos had to comply.
Reading all about it now. Looks like now I have another option. My E71 will work on the Vodafone 2G network in some places and 3G in main towns. This suits me fine. I might looking at moving my 027 number to Vodafone.
To gain FULL benefit from the Extended 3G Vodafone Network - of which the roll out was completed on Thursday 28.05.2009 (900Mhz UMTS) you should take the phone back (14 day right of exchange) & use the money to purchase the Nokia E71-1 to use on the Vodafone Network.
Their extended 3G coverage is very impressive.
i havent had any issues with my new XT mobile. calls are fine and the download speeds are awesome. I dont mind spending a few extra $$ for faster data speeds than what i got on vodafone.... maybe those dropped calls can be blamed on vodafones network interfering with the xt network!
Nice bit of uninformed comment there Rochelle.
Perhaps we should ask 2 Degrees how much interference they suffer from Vodafone as due to the arrangement of the spectrum, interference between Voda and XT must pass through 2 Degrees' frequency allocation first.
There is no issue with interference from either Vodafone or Two Degrees... all the interference came FROM Telecom's XT network and washed over not only Two Degrees but Vodafone's 900MHz spectrum allocation as well.
Telecom has fitted filters - problem is solved. As it should have been back in November when Telecom first said there would be interference, not in the weeks before launch after they'd refused to address the issue.
Cheers
Paul Brislen
Vodafone External Communications Manager
After all this Telecom XT hype they are doing nothing but disappointing people. I was in at Telecom at 8:30am on Friday and its 9:30 on saturday night and my iPhone 3G is still saying "Searching..." Way to go Telecom, your speeds better be super fast otherwise this wait has been all for nothing and the Voda sim will be put back in.
do you think that it could be the phone and not the XT network. Telecom cant guarantee that the iphone will work so you cant blame telecom for that. I know alot of people that are using the iphone on XT so maybe you need to check the configuration of the device to make sure it is set up properly. have you tried putting your XT sim into a telecom supported device to see if your SIM is working, if it is then you know it will be your iphone and not the network
What is wrong with people are they all born stupid. XT is a motorway with very few cars on it of course it will be faster at first until more traffic gets on the roads.
You are right Kristina regarding XT as a highway with very few cars, however they are also already overlaying the 850Mhz XT network with 2100MHz in the main cities which is like building an 8 lane highway rather than 4 lanes. With that I guess any Vodafone that does 2100Mhz UMTS could be used on XT in the cities.
So I've got me a BlackBerry Bold, I get no voice mail notification, no txt message indicating I have a message waiting... anyone else with this problem? I call my voice mail number to configure notifications/alerts but there is nothing available under the menu option relating to txt msg alert etc...
Having read all the comments here, I have to wonder whether CarKitter, 'G' and Mark C are really all Vodafone employees... Seriously. It looks and sounds like bad marketing.
No I'm not a Vodafone employee, just a mobile enthusiast and long time Vodafone customer.
How many 5MB songs are out there that are popular these days?
i would say ~ 90% of the songs you hear on the radio are less than 5MB
Not many if any (excuse the pun)
Sister told me about this and all I can think is how lame it is, I was expecting to read abotu XT as some super fast Next G network like they have in OZ which goes up to 42mbps theoretical. I'm sure just before moving off shore I had a Vodafone VMC express card that was rated 7.2mbps on 3g or hsdpa??? and I'm quite certain I was getting around 2mbps on speedtest.net in Wellington CBD at various locations. So I can't see how getting up to 3.6mbps is something remarkable. Another disappointing read about NZ infrastructure :(
Post new comment or question
To share this article, click on a service below