Member log in

Chch building owner: demo crew 'looted' native timber

UPDATE: This just in from Mr Kepes:

As at 4pm this afternoon all the salvaged materials [including several thousand dollars worth of Australian hardwood and native timber] had disappeared.

We managed to talk to the person supervising demolition in that part of the city who was adamant that all materials had been sent to landfill.

But clearly, as the pictures illustrate, the materials had carefully been separated for salvage.

Civil Defence doesn't want to know about it, and when I reported the incident to the police they advised they were too under-resourced to investigate."

Civil Defence national controller Steve Brazier told RNZ's Checkpoint that there is enough security in the central city red zone.

"We have engineers who are on the site, we've got police who have roving patrols, we've got the industry who are hopefully policing themselves. It's not wide-scale pillaging by any means," Mr Brazier said.

Mr Kepes characterised this statement as bluster. The Civil Defence boss was avoiding the facts.


Keen readers of this blog will be familiar with Ben Kepes, the Christchurch entrepeneur who, along with his business partner, owns IT consultancy, cafe, coffee supply and outdoor camping businesses, plus a three-story building - or, we should now say, former building.

Mr Kepes was plucky through last year's quake. On February 22, when Keallhauled last caught up with him, he was in despair.

Last night, despair had turned to rage.

Two things make the entrepreneur furious.

1. His Litchfield Street building was demolished without him being contacted.

2. He suspects the demolition company has made off with materials from his building, including valuable native timber (echoing a case reported yesterday, in which Christchurch cafe owner Chris Meyer claimed a demo crew had taken valuables).

"Despite being in the CBD on the day of the February 22 quake, and registering on the various websites, we've had zero contact from either the council or Civil Defence - this despite it being all of a two minute exercise to find our contact details (most of which the Council has on its files anyway)," Mr Kepes told NBR.

"Our building has been demolished under the state of emergency, and last I saw it appeared that the demolition company had been recovering materials in, what can only be assumed, is opportunistic salvaging - that some would call looting," he said.

"Demo companies are creaming it."

Utter rot
"I'm a rescue worker so I understand that this is a calamitous event and hence people need to be flexible, but the issue here is the huge lack of consistency and poor communications across the various agencies," Mr Kepes said.

Yesterday, in telling parliament that 140 buildings have been demoiished so far, Civil Defence minister John Carter said "thorough efforts" were made to make contact with owners. For Mr Kepes, this claim was "utter rot".

Who took the native timber?
"We don't 'know' for sure that their intention was to make off with the stack of native timber in these photos (above), but since it's been piled on the very road they're trying to open access to it seems very suspicious. Have contacted Civil Defence and council but no answer yet."

Mr Kepes said his insurance company had paid a sum to clear the mortgage, but a claim over $3 million needed to rebuild was still been finalised. 

More by this author

Signup to free NBR email alerts here

Comments and questions
8

Another utterly foreseeable consequence of the PC police and civil defence jobsworths' health and safety BS. Keep the owners out and give the crims a free hand. Policing at it's finest.

I have been wondering just who are these people and companies who have been given licenses to pillage Christchurch? Where do I get one?

Any an owner can salvage will reduce the insurance payout so unless Kepes' insurance company are troubled by the alleged 'looting' probably not much is going tohappen. Kepes should make a formal written cmplaint of theft to the Police then they will have to look into it. They wont give it priority of course but ifthere is no response then he should complain tothe Police Complaints Authority.
As to the Minister's announcement to Parliament, Kepe 's should make a formal written complaint to the Speaker that Minister has either lied to or misled Parliament.. If Minster Carter hides behind ' my announcement was based on the advice of my officials' then those officials have lied or misled. Either way the Minister is responsible.
It is obvious from the media that Kepes is not alone in his complaints. All property owners who have the same complaints should take these formal steps.

Who the f**k is in control here? Civil Defence are causing a whole new disaster.

that's just really awful, been trying to imagine yr frustration levels...

This is outrageous that this can occur in NZ. A Facebook site has been opened to allow business in the Red Zone to coordinate and put pressure on the Civil Defense Controller. It is only via a coordinated public protest, they take notice.
http://www.facebook.com/pages/Christchurch-Business-in-Red-Zone/107798492634675

The demo companies have presumably been employed to demolish and remove the damaged buildings in their entirety.

Do you really want it all to go to landfill? Better that what can be salvaged is salvaged rather than just dumped.

Do you want them to drop the pile of timber, some sheets of iron and a few truckloads of bricks over to your house?

What reduction in your insurance payout will you accept for the value of salvaged materials sitting on your lawn?

The authorities do need to ensure they get the right balance between the actual cost of demolition, and the potential value in the salvaged materials.

Maybe the size and pace of the recovery will mean this isn't fully realised, but who has got a year to stop and put it out to tender, then think about it for a while... While your bit of land sits danagerous and un-useable.

The pile of timber in question might sit in the demo yard for a week, a year or a decade before finding a buyer, if ever. Very hard to put a value on it.

Presumably the owner will get a full payout from the insurer, so what do you care what happens to the rubble or the salvage?

The contents is another matter. But again, if fully compensated by insurance, what do you care if some demo guy spends his time flogging off your old furniture.

This ain't looting. Yeah, someone is making good money off it. Such is a natural disater of this scale surely.

"There is no corruption in New Zealand"?

Nope, it's just "perking".

Post new comment or question

Login to use your NBR member name
Full HTML is not supported but you can use the following tags in your comments:
Link: <url>link</url>
Quote: <quote>text</quote>