Ridgecrest NZ, a property investor, has won an appeal in the Supreme Court over insurance cover provided by IAG New Zealand for a Christchurch building damaged in four successive earthquakes.
The closely held Ridgecrest had originally taken its case to the High Court after a dispute with the local unit of Insurance Australia Group about the nature of its policy. Ridgecrest had contended it was entitled to the maximum cover of $1.98 million for the final quake on June 13, 2011, that damaged the building beyond repair, and also for losses caused by the three preceding quakes.
IAG, which hadn't been able to complete repair work from the earlier quakes by the time each new one hit, maintained it was only liable to pay the maximum cover for the final 'happening' and only for cost of repairs actually undertaken in the three previous quakes. The High Court found in IAG's favour and the Court of Appeal came to the same conclusion, albeit on different grounds.
The Supreme Court pondered three issues: whether IAG was required to make payments in relation to the earlier quakes; whether losses from the earlier quakes should be treated as merged or subsumed into the loss from the final quake; and whether Ridgecrest's claim was precluded by the "indemnity principle" under which insurance policies "are construed to avoid an insured recovering more than the amount of the loss." (see the judgment attached)
In the Supreme Court judgment released today, justices John McGrath, William Young, Susan Glazebrook, Peter Blanchard and Andrew Tipping unanimously allowed the appeal. They found that Ridgecrest was entitled to be paid out to the policy limit of $1.98 million in each of the earlier quakes and that the merger principle did not apply. They also concluded that the indemnity principle didn't apply because the policy limit was below the replacement value of the building.
However they did find that Ridgecrest wasn't entitled to recover more than replacement value of the building or to double-count its losses.
Ridgecrest was awarded costs of $25,000 and orders for costs in the High Court and Court of Appeal were set aside. Instead, IAG would meet Ridgecrest's costs in those courts.
IAG New Zealand is the nation's biggest general insurer, with local brands State, NZI and AMI. In the 12 months ended June 30, it posted a 56 percent gain in profit to A$183 million after lifting household premiums and making more online sales.
IAG said this month it had settled about 58 percent of its Canterbury earthquake claims as at June 30, amounting to more than $3.3 billion in claim settlements. Projects were taking longer than expected and the company expected the rebuild completion date to extend out to mid-2016, it said, later than the previous target.
This article is tagged with the following keywords. Find out more about MyNBR Tags
Most listened to
- Sunday Business Episode 34 featuring Hayden Cox
- Matthew Hooton on what a National win in Mt Roskill could mean for Labour
- Tim Hunter on Sky's awkward Chinese problem
- Paul Goldsmith's attempt at insolvency law reform has been hijacked by a 'basked of deplorables' says Damien Grant
- Business Week in Review with Grant Walker & Andrew Patterson