The moot for the New Zealand Initiative's youth debate semi-final this year in Wellington is a good one -
"Should New Zealand tie MPs' and Ministers' salaries to a multiple of the average national income?"
When the Remuneration Authority was asking MPs about reform of the system 10 years ago, I urged that parties be given a material amount they could distribute among their members according to their pre-Parliament incomes, to do three things:
- reduce the income cut involved in going to Parliament for people for whom there is much more to lose, and
- reduce the overpayment of the kind or people who would never be thought useful enough outside Parliament to get anywhere near their Parliamentary income, so they don't cling quite so desperately to their places; and
- have the supplement reduce each year after entry to Parliament, to encourage turnover of people who have not progressed.
I also suggested a trailing commission, to induce longer term thinking among MPs. Exec incentive schemes that fail to add a trailing element or to defer vesting encourage manipulation of reporting and incentivise short term results. In politics that there is already more than enough incentive for false reporting and short-temism in the 3 year electoral cycle.
Accordingly MPs should have a material part of their remuneration deferred each year. If the MP demands immediate payment is should be substantially discounted. The deferred amount (say half) might be paid out say five years later, multiplied by 2 times or 5 times the GDP or average income growth in the five years. If it shifted MPs horizons, it would be money incredibly well spent even if they tripled or quadrupled their incomes.
For an even longer perspective, simply make the deferral period longer.
Stephen Franks is principal of Wellington commercial and public law firm Franks and Ogilvie.
This article is tagged with the following keywords. Find out more about MyNBR Tags
- Orion announces discounted rights issue, hints at possible takeover
- Budget aftermath shows opposition flailing
- PFI to pay $42m to swap one management contract for another
- TechDay and NetGuide publisher settles with liquidators, creditors left $2m short
- Turners expects finance and insurance businesses to fire this year
Most listened to
- Labour and Greens are flailing after the Budget 2017 reveal according to NBR's Rob Hosking
- PFI chairman Peter Masfen on the management contract buyout proposal
- Spark chief executive Simon Moutter says getting in tune with your market is a major benefit from diversity
- Turners chief executive Todd Hunter on the outlook for the business
- NBR Radio: best of the week ended May 26, with Grant Walker