The government’s newly announced "to-do" list is full of apple pie targets that no-one could really disagree with.
The question is, does National have the recipe, and is that mock cream on top?
Apparently, the already slimmed down public sector is expected to actually come up with the plans and prove they are achieving them with regular updates on progress – see Audrey Young’s Key sets tough 'to-do list' for public sector.
Most of the targets would be hard to criticise (which is the main political reason for having them) but there is, of course, a big difference between setting targets and having a realistic plan for achieving them. The most damning criticism comes from Russell Brown, who looks at the laudable target to reduce rheumatic fever by two thirds and plots it against the reality today and comments: "Did the poor civil servant who had to draw that graph believe it? Does anyone actually believe it?" – see: If wishing made it so ....
Rheumatic fever in New Zealand is overwhelmingly a disease of Maori and Pacifica children and one that numerous health professionals have said is a direct result of poverty and poor housing. Getting the Ministry of Health to reduce those causes will definitely "stretch their ability". A similarly damning critique is put forward by Gordon Campbell: On the government’s new social targets.
The prime minister’s track record on meeting targets isn’t that great, according to Scott Yorke: "Closing the income gap with Australia, creating more jobs, reducing the number of people fleeing to a better life in Australia. And now the promise to get back into budget surplus, which he's already backtracking on" – see: More Futile and Cynical Policy.
Some of the targets will be achieved in any case given current trends, while others can’t be fudged, and like the rheumatic fever target will be a challenge and require a dramatic reversal of trends.
In light of debates over ACC and education, however, there will be suspicion that public service CEOs with a careful eye on their bonus may find ways to meet the targets that aren’t in their clients or the public interest – see Andrea Vance’s State boss bonus for hitting targets.
The reduction in long-term beneficiary numbers is the most obvious example. Government enthusiast David Farrar praises the government for setting hard time frames and hard numbers and uses a hypothetical example: "such as 'reduce the unemployment rate by 25% in three years”’ – see: The Government targets.
That would be a target few could argue with, but it is actually very different from what the Government has actually set itself to do, which is: "Reduce those on Jobseeker Support for more than 12 months by 30%, from 78,000 to 55,000."
Bronwyn Pullar and the hundreds of other long-term ACC claimants dumped from ACC’s books may have a more cynical view of how those CEO bonuses may get approved.
And their suspicions will be reinforced by figures showing that the proportion of ACC’s decisions being overturned on appeal has increased form less than 30% to 45% in the past few years – see Adam Bennett’s ACC's tougher line fails to satisfy independent reviewers.
ACC’s problems are creating further fallout for the government, with the promised introduction of private competition into the work account again going into the too-hard basket – see Rob Hosking’s Key says ACC reform has been delayed – again.
Gordon Brown in the Taranaki Daily News praises the competition policy but criticises the abandonment of the original "pay-as-you-go" model that means We're paying too much for ACC. The two may be mutually exclusive as it seems private insurers can’t compete with ACC now, let alone under the old model that may see levies 30% lower.
Other important or interesting political items yesterday include:
• Where does real power lie within Maoridom? The power shifts are discussed in a very good blog post by Morgan Godfery, which examines the role and relevance of the two main non-parliamentary institutions in Maoridom, the Iwi Leaders Group, the Maori Council – see: Merging the Maori Council. Godfery also comments on the latest in the internal Mana Party debates on gay marriage: Refusing to budge on marriage equality.
• The success of the sales process will be vital to the government’s re-election chances writes John Hartevelt in Acid test of asset sales is who buys them. Not all may be for sale immediately as Bill English leaves the option open for shares to be set aside for Treaty settlements see: Adam Bennett’s Shares could be held back for Treaty claims – English. Colin James examines the debate over whether National can claim the moral high ground on the policy in his ODT column When a mandate is not a mandate. John Armstrong also paints a picture of how the sales could work out positively for the Government – see: Right price vital for credibility of power sale.
• The final Media 7 show on TVNZ7 is upon us, and Russell Brown is looking at the extraordinary and blatant grab for editorial control over Fairfax by Aussie mining magnate Gina Rinehart – see: Strange days for journalism.
• John Key has said World heritage sites will not be mined but what about our marine reserves? – see TVNZ’s Mineral exploration threatens rare marine life.
• Some principals took offence at suggestions that they are manipulating zoning and ballots to exclude poor areas and students from their schools, but now their own association is admitting the problem may be widespread – see: RNZ’s School zoning manipulation 'may be wider problem’. Kate Shuttleworth reports that the competitive model introduced in the 1980s is being blamed – see: Call to review Tomorrow's Schools model.
• The Timaru Herald is the latest to publish an editorial that is unimpressed with "Trasher Tolleys’" gleeful dance on a boy racer’s crushed car – see: OK, point's been made. They make the point that crushing rather than selling the car cost taxpayers $9000 but made no difference to the offender.
• Martyn Bradbury asks: Are Sky TV and TVNZ setting up the poor to be spied on? And Does Igloo represent corporate big brother or the worst crack cocaine TV ever created?
• Japan’s economy has been stagnating for nearly 25 years and Gareth Morgan Investments director Andrew Gawith wonders if this will be the new reality for the global economy – see: Low growth and interest rates might stick.
• Has the government put the fox in charge of the henhouse? Ex National MP and Food and Grocery Council chief executive Katherine Rich has been appointed to the Health Promotion Agency board – see Isaac Davison’s Lobbyist appointment no conflict: Key.
• Finally, the Taranaki Daily News editorial disagrees with its own readers over the significance of some local history – see: Parihaka deserves to be celebrated.
Audrey Young (Herald): Key sets tough 'to-do list' for public sector
Kate Chapman (Stuff): Govt targets unemployed
Tova O’Brien (TV3): Public service to be tested with targets
TV3/RadioLive: Public sector targets doomed to fail – PSA
Newstalk ZB: Govt releases a 'welfare wish list'
Andrea Vance (Stuff): State boss bonus for hitting targets
Gordon Campbell (Scoop): On the government’s new social targets
No Right Turn: Targets are not a substitute for action
Danyl Mclauchlan (Dim Post); A prediction
Scott Yorke (Imperator Fish): More Futile and Cynical Policy
Russell Brown (Hard News): If wishing made it so ...
David Farrar (Kiwiblog): The Government targets
Adam Bennett (Herald): ACC's tougher line fails to satisfy independent reviewers
Kate Shuttleworth (Herald): Prime Minister backs ACC staff
Rob Hosking (NBR): Key says ACC reform has been delayed – again
No Right Turn: Getting what they paid for
Gordon Brown (Taranaki Daily News): We're paying too much for ACC
Duncan Garner (TV3); 100,000 signatures oppose asset sales
TVNZ: Breakfast: Will Greens get enough referendum signatures? (4:10)
TVNZ: Breakfast: Should taxpayer money be used on asset sale referendum? (6:09)
Adam Bennett (Herald): Shares could be held back for Treaty claims – English
Adam Bennett (Herald): Sell-off could snooker referendum
John Hartevelt (Stuff); Companies on block before referendum
David Fisher (Herald): SOE board pay set to double after sale
John Armstrong (Herald); Right price vital for credibility of power sale
No Right Turn: Petition progress
3 News/NZN/RadioLIVE: Final vote on assets bill
John Hartevelt (Dom Post): Acid test of asset sales is who buys them
Colin James (ODT): When a mandate is not a mandate
Scott Yorke (Imperator Fish):Observations On Asset Sales
Vaimoana Tapaleao (Herald): Zone-fixing claim stirs call for change
Kate Shuttleworth (Herald); Call to review Tomorrow's Schools model
Kate Shuttleworth (Herald): Mining, surveying to go ahead in marine sanctuaries
Kate Chapman (Stuff): No mining in world heritage areas – Key
Isaac Davison (Herald): Key promises no drilling world heritage sites
Andrea Vance (Stuff): Mining to be permitted in marine sanctuaries
No Right Turn: Government of orcs, Act II
Morgan Godfery (Maui Street): Merging the Maori Council
Timaru Herald: Editorial: OK, point's been made
Danyl Mclauchlan (Dim Post): Duel mode government and diminishing returns of crushing
Danya Levy (Stuff): Govt probes Employment Court delays
Terence O’Brien (Dom Post): Care needed with US defence thaw
Tim Selwyn (Tumeke): Post-ANZUS
Nicholas Jones (Herald): Man tracked by SIS wins back state job in settlement
Isaac Davison (Herald): Lobbyist appointment no conflict: Key
Yvonne Tahana (Herald): Tuhoe leaders call for financial support for Iti appeal
David Farrar (Kiwiblog): More taxpayer funded lobbying
Martyn Bradbury (Tumeke): Exclusive: Does Igloo represent corporate big brother or the worst crack cocaine TV ever created?
Morgan Godfery (Maui Street): Refusing to budge on marriage equality
Russell Brown (Hard News): Strange days for journalism
David Chaplin (Herald): NZ Super fund on target or a target?
Andrew Gawith (Herald): Low growth and interest rates might stick
Taranaki Daily News: Editorial - Parihaka deserves to be celebrated
Scott Morgan (Stuff): Len Brown nominated for world's top mayor
Southland Times: Editorial: They know what they're doing?
This article is tagged with the following keywords. Find out more about MyNBR Tags
Most listened to
What's the story behind the story? Our special feature audio offers a mix of comment from journalists, experts and panel discussions.
- Deloitte's Scott McClay discusses which South Island companies are performing best
- TIN100's Greg Shanahan on this year's top trends and top movers in high-tech exports
- ASB senior rural economist Nathan Penny disagrees with ANZ's forecast and is standing by his bank’s $6.75/kgMS prediction
- Why is the FMA exempting robo-advice from the law? Liam Mason explains
- NBR Radio: The best interviews, with Grant Walker — updated daily