NZ POLITICS DAILY: Behind closed doors, Labour has different message

David Parker

Labour is marketing itself as the party of radical economic transformation. It says it is prepared to make the real changes that National won’t.

Yesterday David Parker advocated forcing the Reserve Bank to take on exporter and worker representation, and taxing property investment profits – see: Labour talks tough on economic reform.

That’s the public face, but as Chris Trotter writes, the message behind closed doors to the business sector has a very different emphasis.

What is not going to change under Labour, is a commitment to returning to a fiscal surplus in two years - meaning a newly elected Labour-led Government’s first budget in 2015 would have no red ink. There would have to be a dramatic turnaround in government finances over the next few years if significant new spending is going to be seen before the following election in 2018 – see Trotter’s blogpost, No Joke: Why I'm Not Laughing At Labour's Latest Speeches.

Another apparent contradiction between Labour’s ‘in public’ and ‘in private’ positions is with the status of core state assets. This has a major bearing on Labour’s critiques of National’s partial privatisation. Parker told his business audience that telecommunications and electricity generation are not included in Labour’s list of assets that need to be ‘run in the New Zealand interest’.
Trotter is unimpressed: ‘So, all those people standing on street corners with clip-boards collecting signatures for a Citizens Initiated Referendum on asset sales; all those thousands of people planning to march in the “Aotearoa Is NOT For Sale!” protest this Saturday; all those hundreds of Labour Party members who’ve been reassuring their workmates and neighbours that the Caucus is rock-solid against the sale of Mighty River Power and Genesis Energy; all of them are wasting their time. Because “energy generation” isn’t even on Labour’s “closed list” of assets that should never be sold.’
The lack of detail about Labour’s desire to ‘take some hard decisions and shatter some orthodoxies that are past their use-by date’ has Trotter worried that what the party is channeling is more Roger Douglas than Mickey Savage or Norm Kirk.
Of course it’s almost certain that the Greens will have a big say in how any of Labour’s plans are actually implemented. Ele Ludemann looks at Transtasman’s analysis of Australian Labor’s hostility towards the Greens and whether or not the current Labour leadership has the ‘smarts’ to keep them at a distance, as Helen Clark did – see: How close does Labour want to get to Greens?
Chris Trotter also looks at the Labour-Greens relationship in his must-read Taranaki Daily News column today – see: Labour seeks middle ground on policies. Trotter fires shots at the Labour Party and Grant Robertson, with warnings for the Greens, and praise for David Cunliffe. He characterises comments by Labour deputy Grant Robertson as ‘a simple and brutal warning: there's a Cabinet seat for you in the next Labour-led Government, but only if you're willing to leave your radical ideas ("uncompromising dogma") at the door, only if you accept that it will be business as close to usual as Labour can make it’. Robertson has now responded with a blogpost: For the benefit of Mr Trotter, implying that there is a historic personal element to Trotter’s criticism, and that his use of ‘uncompromising dogma’ relates to the importance of using evidence and science to back up our environmental policies. To read Robertson’s original speech itself, see: Green Growth.
With non-MPs likely to be given more say in who gets to be a Labour MP and Labour leader (see: Labour tiptoes towards perception change) the debate over Labour’s differing public and private positions may have to be resolved before coalition negotiations begin with the Greens.
There is much ongoing comment and analysis of the water claim issue. The best news item today are Kieran Campbell and Claire Trevett’s Settle doubts over water rights, PM told and Patrick Gower’s Key is 'trying to bash Maoris' – Paul. Gower has also put together a 49-second 'smoke on the water' video montage. Other useful analysis and opinion comes from Mai Chen (The murky issue of rights to water and PM may have breached the Treaty, today’s Taranaki Daily News editorial: Key fails to heed Clark's cautionary tale, and Tahu Potiki’s 'Ugly undertones' in tribunal hearing
Other important or interesting political items today include:
Kim Dotcom’s PR nous and the legal botch ups reflect badly – but unfairly – on the Government says Jane Clifton in Mega-spot of bother
Possible changes to our main environmental legislation are examined by Pattrick Smellie in Drawing the RMA battle lines . 
Former New Zealand journalist Anita McNaught gives her evaluation of the state of the media in Sarah Daniell’s Twelve Questions with Anita McNaught. See also, No Right Turn’s McNaught on the media
Reports of hostilities between the generations seem to have been overstated writes Eric Crampton in War of ages
Indoor-outdoor flow has a different meaning for some desperate Christchurch residents – see: Olivia Carville’s Homeless Christchurch couple sleep in dunes. But the housing ‘crisis’ isn’t just in Christchurch – see Hannah Spyksma’s Housing shortage creating homeless problem, MP says
There isn’t as much money in activism as there used to be for a local franchise – see: Big profit slide for Greenpeace
iPredict’s latest New Zealand Election newsletter is out, and its main predictions include: Turia and Sharples both picked to step down as Maori Party co-leaders, MMP review expected to propose reducing threshold to 4% and abolishing one-seat rule, Annette King to run for Wellington mayoralty and Shane Jones to be criticised by Auditor-General. The expected party votes at the 2014 election are: National, 40%, Labour, 35%, Greens, 10%, NZ First, 5%, Conservatives, 4%, and Act, Maori, Mana and UnitedFuture at around 1%. 
Finally, innovation is good for the economy, but not for statistics says Toby Manhire in Steven Joyce: crimes against bar graphs
Bryce Edwards

Today's content:
Water rights and asset sales
Kieran Campbell and Claire Trevett (Herald): Settle doubts over water rights, PM told
Katie Bradford-Crozier (Newstalk): PM confident relationship with Maori Party to continue
Katie Bradford-Crozier (Newstalk): Tribunal still relevant – Key
Mai Chen (Dom Post): The murky issue of rights to water
Mai Chen (Herald): PM may have breached the Treaty
Press: Editorial: Raising the stakes
Anthony Robins (Standard): Cute with semantics on water
David Kennedy (Local bodies): Maori Party in Abusive Relationship
Labour Party
Chris Trotter (Taranaki Daily News): Labour seeks middle ground on policies
Grant Robertson (Red Alert): For the benefit of Mr Trotter
Ele Ludemann (Homepaddock): How close does Labour want to get to Greens?
John Hartevelt and Danya Levy (Stuff): Plea to MPs over foetal alcohol syndrome
Catherine Issac (Dom Post): Charter schools 'not anti-teacher'
Herald: Editorial – Schools put onus back on churches
Pattrick Smellie (Stuff): Drawing the RMA battle lines
Simon Collins (Herald): More ACC files sent to wrong client
Cameron Slater (Whaleoil): The Political Future – National
Gordon Campbell (Wellingtonian): State/private ventures costly dream?
Lincoln Tan (Herald): System will fight fraud
Lois Cairns (Press): Pressure on Brownlee to intervene
Jane Clifton (Listener): Mega-spot of bother
Toby Manhire (Listener): Steven Joyce: crimes against bar graphs
Sarah Daniell (Herald): Twelve Questions with Anita McNaught
No Right Turn: McNaught on the media
John Drinnan (Herald): Peter Williams in SBW war of words
Warwick Rasmussen (Manawatu Standard): Editorial: Power struggle
Eric Crampton (Offsetting Behaviour): War of ages
Waikato Times: Editorial - Sauce for the gander
Vaimoana Tapaleao (Herald): Leader built Maori links with Govt, business




3 · Got a question about this story? Leave it in Comments & Questions below.

This article is tagged with the following keywords. Find out more about MyNBR Tags

Post Comment

3 Comments & Questions

Commenter icon key: Subscriber Verified

There would be real irony if labour started changing the big issues that John Key will not touch. Superannuation,interest free student loans, working for families, maori grievance completion, ACC..
But since national is labour lite I suppose anything is possible.

If NZ is to progress we certainly need Roger Douglas style changes and quickly.

  • 0
  • 0

Perhaps Labour NZ should learn from Labour Party Australia and/or the The French Government in order to return to early as 2014.

  • 0
  • 0

Labour has been rudderless since the Election of 2008. The grey Goff/Shearer leaderhip group are like rabbits in the headlights. Shearer was a mistake. They have lost their mandate from the party supporters. The only senior one doing any deep analysis of the underlying issues effecting the NZ economy, business, workers and consumer and putting forward coherent proposals is David Cunliffe. If Labour does not change course soon it will loose the next eclection.

  • 0
  • 0

Post New comment or question

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

NZ Market Snapshot


Sym Price Change
USD 0.7269 0.0000 0.00%
AUD 0.9101 0.0000 0.00%
EUR 0.5951 0.0000 0.00%
GBP 0.5249 0.0000 0.00%
HKD 5.6856 0.0000 0.00%
JPY 80.4820 0.0000 0.00%


Commodity Price Change Time
Gold Index 1331.0 4.850 2018-01-19T00:
Oil Brent 68.6 -0.710 2018-01-19T00:
Oil Nymex 63.4 -0.580 2018-01-19T00:
Silver Index 17.0 0.090 2018-01-19T00:


Symbol Open High Last %
NASDAQ 7312.0 7336.4 7296.1 0.55%
DJI 25987.3 26071.7 26017.8 0.21%