NZ POLITICS DAILY: The courtiers fight back

Serious beard, serious comeback: Cunliffe

Six months ago David Cunliffe’s image had taken a battering, particularly as the ABC (Anyone but Cunliffe) faction was identified as one of the main reasons for Shearer’s victory in the Labour Party leadership contest.

As the most experienced contender, the rejection could well have signaled the end of his political aspirations, but Cunliffe kept his head down and behaved himself as a loyal MP to the new leader.
With Shearer failing to make any immediate impact on Labour’s poll ratings and the clearly ambitious new deputy Grant Robertson being touted as a possible replacement, Cunliffe’s first move to publicly stake out his own position has clearly reignited tensions within Labour. Chris Trotter deals this with today in an extraordinary critique of Labour in his Press column – see: Cunliffe Muzzled: The Courtiers Fight Back.
The most recent materialisation of these tensions in Labour was a ban placed on Cunliffe appearing on TV3’s The Nation in the weekend. Duncan Garner is very clear that Shearer’s office had Cunliffe banned from appearing and, furthermore, that Cunliffe received a roasting from his caucus colleagues over his recent speech to New Lynn Labour Party members – see Garner’s Row over Cunliffe's absence on TV show, (or the video version). And you can watch TV3’s The Nation (with Duncan Garner’s introduction about Cunliffe) here
While the accepted wisdom is that Cunliffe has more party support outside of the caucus than within, he also has vocal support from outside the Labour Party, and it’s not just Chris Trotter. For example, Brian Edwards (On David Cunliffe, the political divide and why I’m still wondering) and Martyn Bradbury (Gagging Cunliffe is the most inane political self mutilation of the year) both slam Shearer for not allowing Cunliffe to express any view that might not currently fit with his media and policy strategy.
Labour activist Robert Winter steers clear of any criticism of Shearer but says debate shouldn’t be seen as subversion of the party and that the outcome of the party’s organisational review and the willingness of Labour’s leadership to promote debate will be crucial for Labour’s recovery – see: On Crises and Debate: things that are happening in the Labour Party.
Many critics on the left continue to be underwhelmed by what they see as Labour’s weak response to the Government’s agenda, including Giovanni Tiso (Public/Private/Foreign), No Right Turn (Labour doesn’t lead) and Chris Trotter again with National Attacks Unions ... Again. How Will Labour Respond?. The Tiso blog post is particularly interesting, because it presents a very good critique of what he regards as Labour (and the Greens) uses xenophobia to fight against privatisation and also buying into the neoliberal State Owned Enterprises model of state ownership. Incidentally, in an opinion piece in the ODT (Plan for Hillside prompts searching questions) David Cunliffe shows just how much he is now tilting to the left by challenging the SOE-type model in which state owned enterprises are effectively only concerned with making a profit, without any real regard for the impact of their activities on the community.  
For more on the situation in Labour at the moment, watch Chris Trotter’s interview on TV3’s Firstline today, and see Jordan Carter’s The Hope Project: changing Labour's organization
John Key doesn’t have A dose of second-term blues according to Patrick Gower who says Key still holds all the cards. He lists a number of reasons why Key is still on top and is keen to get on with the job. Gower makes some excellent counterfactual points. But as the Government’s response to nearly all criticism is about ‘the need to grow the economy’ and ‘pay down debt’, then after 6 years in Government the 2014 election may well come down to a counter-response of: ‘it’s the economy stupid’. With Europe teetering on crisis and the worst slump in New Zealand retail sales for 17 years Vernon Small reports that opposition parties are warning of a double dip recession – see: Key banks on forecasts despite slump. The Prime Minister is expressing confidence in Treasury forecasts showing continued growth to 2014. Fran O’Sullivan agrees with Patrick Gower saying that Key’s front footing of what she describes as ‘mini-scandals’ shows he has reverted to ‘CEO mode’ – see: Key gets serious over NZ's major issues.
If there is a change in Key’s response it may be reflected in his approach to the media. Key told Leighton Smith that ‘the media is in a more aggressive and hostile mood towards us’ (Key slams news media) and Toby Manhire thinks this signals Key reopening his war of words with the media which begun with the teapot tapes last year – see: John Key reopens war of words with NZ media.
It’s also worth pointing out that the Government’s relationship with the media was worsened when it was announced that the Solicitor General was going to attempt to recoup costs from cameraman Bradley Ambrose. This decision was said to be made independent from the PM, but in the weekend it was revealed that Key communicated with the Solicitor General’s office over the affair – see: Kathryn Powley’s Key's phone call over recording. See also, No Right Turn’s Deceitful
Bill English is clearly pushing ahead with his zero budget, announcing yesterday that increased prescription charges will be traded off for increased funding for cancer treatments. Mana leader Hone Harawira has warned of dire consequences for poorer families not being able to afford medicines – see: Isaac Davison and Paul Harper’s Meds price hike: 'Children will die'. The Medical Association and the Pharmacy Guild are supporting the increase with Pharmacy Guild CEO Karen Crisp dismissing fears and saying ‘You can barely get a cup of coffee for $5 these days’ (see: Price hike overdue, says Pharmacy Guild). However, Harawira is probably not referring to the families who frequent cafes but more likely those whose kids scavenge for food amongst pig slops. 
The trade off between increasing prescription charges and increasing funding for cancer treatment is very questionable according to Professor Tony Blakely of Otago University because research shows that 18,000 adults already put off taking medicine because of the existing part charges, with Maori and Pacific people twice as likely to do so. Blakely also questions the economics, as those who don’t take required medicine will end up in the hospital system at much greater public expense – see: Public health expert questions prescription charge move.
The Government’s attempts to hold the health budget line will come under further pressure with the Appeal Court decision that parents caring for their disabled children are entitled to payment – see: Tom McRae’s Disabled care Govt cost uncertain. The Government has spent $1.4 million so far fighting the claims but has lost three times in court. Chris Ford, from his wheelchair, welcomes the victory – see: Family caregivers of severely disabled people get justice at last!.
Other important or interesting political items today include:
Bryce Edwards


Today’s content:
Labour Party
Giovanni Tiso (Bat Bean Beam): Public/Private/Foreign
No Right Turn: Labour doesn’t lead
Anthony Robins (The Standard): Warming to Shearer
Cameron Slater (Whaleoil): The effectiveness of Chris Flatt
Increased prescription charges
Isaac Davison and Paul Harper (Herald): Meds price hike: 'Children will die'
Barry Soper (Newstalk ZB): Prescription charges to increase
Danya Levy and Tracy Watkins (Stuff): Opposition attacks prescription charge hike
David Farrar (Kiwiblog): Prescription Charges
Disabled care
Timaru Herald (Stuff): Editorial: A matter of principle
Catherine Delahunty (frogblog): Disability, fairness and care issues
Government-media relations
James Wheeler (Newstalk ZB): Key slams news media
Vernon Small (Stuff): Key bemoans 'hostile' media
David Farrar (Kiwiblog): A perfect example
Kathryn Powley (Herald): Key's phone call over recording
No Right Turn: Deceitful
Industrial relations
Katie Bradford-Crozier (Newstalk ZB): Minister saying little on labour law changes
Robert Winter (Idle Thoughts): National's Class War on the Labour Movement
Government performance
Fran O’Sullivan (Herald): Key gets serious over NZ's major issues
Patrick Gower (TV3): Key still holds all the cards
Gay marriage
Claire Trevett (Herald): Key hedges bets on gay marriage
Danya Levy (Stuff): Key: 'Let's have debate' on gay marriage
Felix Marwick (Newstalk ZB): PM won't say how he'd vote on gay marriage
Anthony Robins (The Standard): Gay marriage – what is wrong with us
Scott Yorke (Imperator Fish): In Defence Of Religion
Contraception for beneficiaries
Public broadcasting
Chris Trotter (Bowalley Road): In A Weakened State
Grant Miller (Manawatu Standard): Lessons Conservatives might learn
Danyl Mclauchlan (Dim Post): Big Picture
David Farrar (Kiwiblog): Sexual violence statistics
Vernon Small (Stuff): Key banks on forecasts despite slump
Andrea Vance (Stuff): Taming the new Wild West
David Farrar (Kiwiblog): Glaister on MMP review
David Farrar (Kiwiblog): Taxpayer funded lobbying
Carl Davidson (Dom Post); A better work-life balance helps NZ
Michael Forbes (Stuff): 80-plus age group the fastest growing
Charles Anderson (Stuff): Minto in court over police obstruction
William Mace (Stuff): More Kiwi's now saving
Joshua Drummond (Waikato Times): Bogan PhD brings the trolls to the surface





Got a question about this story? Leave it in Comments & Questions below.

This article is tagged with the following keywords. Find out more about MyNBR Tags

Comments & Questions

Commenter icon key: Subscriber Verified

Post New comment or question

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

NZ Market Snapshot


Sym Price Change
USD 0.7363 0.0044 0.60%
AUD 0.9148 0.0010 0.11%
EUR 0.6134 0.0031 0.51%
GBP 0.5441 0.0029 0.54%
HKD 5.7462 0.0399 0.70%
JPY 81.9070 0.2700 0.33%


Commodity Price Change Time
Gold Index 1310.9 3.470 2017-09-19T00:
Oil Brent 55.2 -0.260 2017-09-19T00:
Oil Nymex 49.5 -0.330 2017-09-19T00:
Silver Index 17.2 0.123 2017-09-19T00:


Symbol Open High Last %
NZX 50 7765.4 7819.2 7764.5 0.70%
NASDAQ 6465.6 6467.8 6454.6 0.10%
DAX 12550.9 12593.2 12561.8 -0.07%
DJI 22349.7 22386.0 22331.3 0.18%
FTSE 7275.2 7289.9 7275.2 0.05%
HKSE 28099.3 28149.4 28051.4 0.27%
NI225 20301.3 20339.4 20299.4 0.05%
ASX 5713.6 5713.6 5713.6 -0.08%