NZ POLITICS DAILY: Harsh verdicts on Shearer ahead of conference

Shearer: faces party conference in a fortnight

Tell us what you really think, Duncan.

The outgoing TV3 political editor leaves no room for doubt about his verdict on David Shearer’s leadership: ‘Labour promised an exciting back story that would impress and a new front man to rival the Prime Minister. Sadly for Labour - they're still looking for that person. David Shearer has failed. Labour's lucky it's not getting done under the law for false advertising’ – see: David Shearer has failed.

Garner outlines why the Labour leader has failed and he puts forward the theory that Shearer is merely being kept in the position to keep the seat warm for Grant Robertson – a situation that Garner labels ‘disingenuous’ and ‘dishonest’.

Garner is particularly critical of the way David Cunliffe has been kept under wraps by the ‘Anyone But Cunliffe’ faction.

Similarly, over at The Standard blog, there is anger that the anti-Cunliffe faction is still so influential: ‘when the Nats are incredibly exposed on the economy, the rump ABC crowd would rather attack the Left’s most articulate economic communicator then join him in getting on with the job’ – see: Is anyone ABC any more?  

Shearer will, literally, be under the spotlight at the Labour Party’s crucial annual conference in two weeks time.
Colin James evaluates Labour’s preparation for re-taking government – see: Testing David Shearer -- and his party. He says that they have done well in modernising the party’s organisation, but he thinks they have failed to modernise education and health policies, while making better headway in economic and social policy. Shearer’s first leadership anniversary is just over a month away and Scott Yorke is watching his calendar – see: And On The Forty-Fourth Day.
Many journalists and commentators now speak with a sense of inevitability about Shearer’s eventual demise. For example, yesterday the Southland Times’ Alex Fensome (@AlexSTLT) tweeted: ‘I really liked David Shearer when I met him. They've destroyed a good and decent man’. 
Jane Clifton asks in this week’s Listener, Could a Labour-Green-NZ First Government work? She thinks stranger things have happened but that the main tension will be between Labour and the Greens rather than with Winston Peters whom she describes as ‘secretly a bit of a pussycat’.
Clifton’s column follows on from Colin James’ ODT column, Wheeler stance uneasy with opposition, in which he suggested that the anti-free trade stances of the Greens and NZ First could eventually be the undoing of ‘the red-green-black dalliance’.
Labour does have a tendency to cause its own problems. Stuart Nash’s tweet about his desire for vigilante justice is a good example: ‘That guy who killed toddler JJ Lawrence should be shot. Would happily pull the trigger!’ – the reaction is covered in a blogpost by Keeping Stock: Action...reaction...overreaction?
Part of Labour’s problem at the moment is its lack of identity and any sort of strong ideological anchor – the party shifts around politically as if floating on a sea of constant change. For the latest indication of this, see David Farrar’s Two Shearer u-turns. Farrar also makes a similar point when he says ‘I think Shearer’s problem is more than he hasn’t been able to stamp a policy direction on the party’ – see: Garner on Shearer. It’s unclear however, to what extent Labour’s identity problems go further than just the current leader. 
Other recent important or interesting political items include:
There has been considerable reaction to the appointment of Cameron Slater as editor of The Truth, and I’ve extensively covered the reaction to this in a blog post on liberation – see: ‘Whale oil beef hooked!’. The strong interest in the issue reflects just how unique the situation is – after all, it’s perhaps the first time a high profile blogger has taken the helm at a newspaper. As the Listener’s Toby Manhire says, ‘the symbolism is pretty potent. I can’t think of another example in which a blogger has been parachuted directly into a newspaper’s editor chair’ – see: Whale Oil to edit Truth, 100% in your face, but no longer pro-union. For this reason, the new appointment has caught the eye of the UK Guardian newspaper’s media commentator, Roy Greenslade, who has blogged about it – see: Blogger hired to edit print newspaper.  How is the paper’s style and politics likely to change? Slater says he plans to reduce the adult sexual content – especially the dominance of sex work ads, and perhaps even get rid of the ‘page 3 girl’ – see Amy Maas’ Editor: Less sex, more news for Truth
Nicky Hager gave the 2012 Bruce Jesson lecture on Investigative journalism in the age of media meltdown: from National Party Headquarters to Afghanistan. In a wide-ranging speech, Hager challenges the left-right characterisation of our political parties by the media, as well as addressing the vital role critical journalism has to play to avoid ‘a world where the PR people had won’ – recommended.
New Zealand’s SAS troops are now back in Afghanistan, and according to RNZ’s correspondent, Jon Stephenson, the soldiers are known to be there in a combat role on a revenge mission. But John Key is denying this – see Matthew Theunissen and Abby Gillies’s PM denies accountability for SAS actions. Security specialist Paul Buchanan suggests that Stephenson is the person more likely to have the story right – see: Who to Believe?  Meanwhile, the Wall St Journal has reported that New Zealand troops have pulled out of the Bamiyan province in Afghanistan – the dangerous province where troops have been killed. Vernon Small reports on this in NZ troops pull back from danger zone
The new Reserve Bank Governor, Graeme Wheeler, may have a difficult job ahead of him according to Vernon Small, writing about economic policy in Wheeler speech close to politically fraught. Since the global financial crisis the political world has been moving on to some extent from the orthodox neoliberal economic settings of the past 30 years, but the bureaucracy apparently has not. Meanwhile, Treasury is doing its best to modernise its image – see Vernon Small’s Treasury boss takes aim at prejudice
Commentators are still evaluating the Government’s housing affordability proposals. Brian Fallow criticises the lack of attention paid to social housing in Govt housing plan misses mark, while Brian Rudman explains how the market has failed, and local and central government aren’t willing to remedy this – see: Council land banking way to get cheaper homes
One of the reasons that the National Government chose to axe regional elections in Canterbury was to protect economic growth – see Rachel Young’s Money talks in tight rein on ECan. ‘Suppressing democracy and suspending the rule of law because you don't like the outcome is the action of a tyrant’ says the No Right Turn blogger – see: National's tyranny
There are competing visions for a Wellington ‘Supercity’, but also a huge amount of jockeying for advantage writes Nick Venter in Divided councils spurn simple fix. The current Wellington City Mayor has been quick to put her hand up for the top job – see Michael Forbes’ Wade-Brown interested in lord mayor role.
With argument raging about just how good our education system is, teacher Peter Lyons reminds us that our schooling system was set up to be ‘a giant sorting and conditioning machine geared to producing compliant workers for the labour force’ – see: Hail the critical thinkers nose studs and all.
It’s time to call Rio Tinto's bluff says Murray Horton of the Campaign Against Foreign Control of Aotearoa ‘Stop crying wolf, stop using your New Zealand workers as disposable pawns in your cynical game, stop holding Southland and the country to ransom’ – see: Smelter NZ's biggest bludger
Race relations continue to be a hot topic – see three interesting items today: Bernard Orsman’s Cries of racism, sexism in fiery debate, Kirsty McMurray’s School removes offensive site, and Rod Vaughan’s Why Treaty-based constitution 'a disaster for New Zealand'
Finally, Danyl Mclauchlan helps those having difficulty figuring out what Hekia Parata is actually saying in Education Minister translated and Scott Yorke breaks his promise to end his online feud with Martyn Bradbury with My Resignation From The Truth
Bryce Edwards
Today's content:
Labour Party
Duncan Garner (TV3): David Shearer has failed
Colin James (Management): Testing David Shearer -- and his party
Scott Yorke (Imperator Fish): And On The Forty-Fourth Day
Scott Yorke (Imperator Fish): Speculation Grows About Speculation About Labour
David Farrar (Kiwiblog): Two Shearer u-turns
David Farrar (Kiwiblog): Labour trying jobs for the boys again  
David Farrar (Kiwiblog): Will the Greens get Finance  
Robert Winter (Idle Thoughts): Mr Nash: judgement wanting
Cameron Slater and Truth newspaper
Bryce Edwards (liberation): "Whale Oil Beef Hooked!"
Roy Greenslade (The Guardian): Blogger hired to edit print newspaper
Chris Trotter (Bowalley Road): Anything Cam Can Do ...
David Farrar (Kiwiblog): Whale appointed Truth Editor
Keeping Stock: This could be fun...
Scott Yorke (Imperator Fish): My Mate Gets The Truth
Scott Yorke (Imperator Fish): My Resignation From The Truth
NZ in Afghanistan
Matthew Theunissen, Abby Gillies (Herald): PM denies accountability for SAS actions
Matthew Theunissen (Herald): PM: SAS not on 'revenge mission'
Danya Levy and Nicole Pryor (Stuff): No SAS strike team sent to Afghanistan: Key
Paul Buchanan (Kiwipolitico): Who to Believe?
Vernon Small (Stuff): NZ troops pull back from danger zone
Brian Fallow (Herald): Govt housing plan misses mark
Gary Taylor (Herald): Radical moves needed on housing
Steffan Browning (Frogblog): The good life neighbours
Seamus Hogan (Offsetting Behaviour): Gareth Morgan on Housing Affordability
Robert Winter (Idle Thoughts): National's housing waffle
Robert Winter (Idle Thoughts): National Poodle?
Katie Chapman and Michael Forbes (Stuff): Palmer: Lord mayor needed for Wellington
Kate Chapman (Stuff): 'Lord Mayor' proposed for Wellington
Nick Venter (Stuff): Divided councils spurn simple fix
Press: Editorial: Local govt reform inevitable
Stephen Franks: Lord Mayor will sink it
David Farrar (Kiwiblog): A Lord Mayor for Wellington?
Treasury and Reserve Bank
Vernon Small (Stuff): Treasury boss takes aim at prejudice
Cancelled ECan elections
Rachel Young (Stuff): Money talks in tight rein on ECan
No Right Turn: National's tyranny
Labour law reform
Danya Levy and Joelle Dally (Stuff): Parata under fire over special school closures
Danyl Mclauchlan (Dim Post): Education Minister translated
Kristin Edge (Northern Advocate): Principal slams Govt drug changes
Bernard Orsman (Herald): Cries of racism, sexism in fiery debate
Diana Wichtel (Listener): Media junkies
Russell Brown (Public Address): When we had hope and change
Adam Bennett (Herald): Palmer wants wider ACC payouts
Mike Dinsdale (Northern Advocate): Private hospital funding risky: Labour
Ben Heather (Press): Numberplate tracker may be illegal
Wilma McCorkindale (Stuff): PM: KiwiRail close to making decision
Murray Horton (Southland Times): Smelter NZ's biggest bludger
Adam Bennett (Herald): Meridian chief's $800k bonus
Fran O’Sullivan (Herald): China anniversary party delayed
Jim Chipp (Wellingtonian): Growing old in turbulent times
Eric Crampton (Offsetting Behaviour): Drink-driving kids
Rachel Glucina (Herald): MP backs talent over TVNZ
Russell Brown (Hard News): Media3: Whistleblower Season

4 · Got a question about this story? Leave it in Comments & Questions below.

This article is tagged with the following keywords. Find out more about MyNBR Tags

Post Comment

4 Comments & Questions

Commenter icon key: Subscriber Verified

"the rump ABC crowd would rather attack the Left’s most articulate economic communicator [Cunliffe] then join him in getting on with the job"

If Cunliffe is the Left's most articulate economic communicator in this country then believe me, the Left's problems are far greater and far more serious than just 'the rump ABC crowd'.

The fact that they don't have insight into that is just another manifestation of their overall lack of insight into economic matters in general. And the Left's ultimate deceit and self-deception has been its steadfast and long lived refusal to acknowledge that on economic matters, they just don't get it.

  • 0
  • 0

The Labour party annual conference in being held soon in Auckland.
I suspect the critical groundwork, for the transition of power to Cunliffe, will be put in place then. The folly that's is Shearer's shoe-horning into the leadership role, by two votes, over Cunliffe will be dismantled. Ardern, Mallard and Robertson's fingers will be removed from the levers of power. Soon David Cunliffe will be party leader and he will the PM of New Zealand in 2014. He will be an excellent PM for all Kiwis.

  • 0
  • 0

As a Labour voter I do not agree. The damage has been done.

Labour have a lot of work to do to win the next election. Their last two leaders have both been impotent, and have failed to attack the incumbent Government when they had the chance, and when they have attacked it has been to their undoing. (dotcom video, worst mistake ever...)

This is sheer incompetence.

Labour simply does not deserve to be in power after the next election, as they have done nothing to earn it, and they will not get there through the greens, who are becoming ever unpopular with their ideological policy views which appear to have no good answer to the current problem on the mind of the voter, that is the economy, as it is real to them - work coming in, and money in the hand.

  • 0
  • 0

From Day-one, Shearer never had the makings of a Leader. Never. He was wasn't able to rise above being a mid-tier U.N. staffer. And we all know just how effective the U.N. has been in Rwanda, Sudan, Somalia Afghanistan, Syria etc.

  • 0
  • 0

Post New comment or question

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

NZ Market Snapshot


Sym Price Change
USD 0.7265 -0.0026 -0.36%
AUD 0.9128 -0.0035 -0.38%
EUR 0.5926 -0.0019 -0.32%
GBP 0.5268 -0.0021 -0.40%
HKD 5.6835 -0.0207 -0.36%
JPY 80.2300 -0.4650 -0.58%


Commodity Price Change Time
Gold Index 1340.6 4.480 2018-01-15T00:
Oil Brent 69.8 0.530 2018-01-12T00:
Oil Nymex 64.3 0.440 2018-01-12T00:
Silver Index 17.1 0.170 2018-01-12T00:


Symbol Open High Last %
NASDAQ 7307.2 7330.3 7261.1 -0.51%
DJI 25987.6 26086.1 25803.2 -0.04%