NZ POLITICS DAILY: Maori Party’s disastrous political management

Personalities always loom large over Maori politics, but the latest internal struggles played out at Ratana over the past few days reflect more than just personal political ambitions.

The tensions reflect, according to Morgan Godfery, ‘deep dysfunction within the parliamentary and party wings’ compounded by an ‘anaemic caucus and a debilitated membership’ – see his blogpost Trouble in the Maori Party: Act I.

Pita Sharples’ isolation from Tariana Turia and Te Ururoa Flavell is a growing problem says Godfery, not helped by Flavell’s drive – assisted by President Pem Bird – to become leader. He warns ‘Te Ururoa’s reckless ambition already led to the creation of the Mana Party, he must be careful not to let it lead to a death warrant for the Maori Party’ – see: Quick comments on a Mana Maori Party. Ex-Te Tai Tonga MP Rahui Katene has joined in with a bid for both co-leader and Turia’s Te Tai Hauauru electorate – see TV3’s Flavell, Katene want Maori Party co-leadership

While Maori politics is often played out more publicly than the pakeha version, the Maori Party’s political management has for a long time been little short of disastrous, particularly since Pem Bird took over the president’s role. To have a leadership challenge spill out at the annual Ratana gathering, surrounded by the assembled press gallery and political foes, is simply incompetent. 

Mana leader Hone Harawira may have actually forced it all out in the open by claiming that Maori Party members in Te Tai Tokerau want him to lead a unified movement. That could be dismissed easily (and quickly was by Turia and Flavell) but Sharples’ response that the two parties should be talking about a merger and that ‘it's a bit silly to have two Maori-kind of parties’ – see Newswire’s Harawira 'dictatorship' unwelcome – Turia would have raised the paranoia levels up several notches. 

Claire Trevett writes that such a merger is very unlikely given the antipathy, and that Harawira would just add to their problems rather than solving them – see: Harawira's offer doesn't deserve a look in. She says that what the Maori Party needs most is stability, which is undoubtedly true right now, but ignores the basic political pressures causing the ructions. It is always much easier for parties to appear unified and focused when the polls are good and careers aren’t in immediate jeopardy. Even if the Maori Party can sort out an orderly leadership transition – and there is little evidence of that to date – the reality is they face a huge struggle to hold on to their three current seats in 2014, irrespective of who is wearing what badges.

It is all a far cry from 2004 when, as Chris Trotter writes, the dream was that the Maori Party would harness the growing voting power of Maori and leverage it against National and Labour – see: Maori Party's founding tenets starting to unravel. Ignoring the material interests of the majority of working class Maori has been fatal to that dream, especially as ‘it was the Maori Party's misfortune to enter into a confidence-and-supply agreement with the National Party just as a global financial crisis was hurling tens of thousands of young Maori into joblessness and underemployment’.

The divide between Mana and the Maori Party has a real and clear ideological base beyond personalities. Despite this, there remains huge doubt as to whether two separate Maori parties can survive in Parliament in the long term. The call for a unified independent political movement, as unlikely as it is right now, continues to have wide political appeal, voiced at Ratana by senior leader Ruia Aperahama – see: RNZ’s Ratana Church supports Mana-Maori alliance. Those wanting a single independent Maori political force will probably have their wish granted eventually, but it is much more likely to come about as a result of attrition than negotiation.

Other important or interesting recent political items include:

• This week’s Cabinet reshuffle has been declared bold and impressive but there have been some naysayers. Both Danyl Mclauchlan (Respect!) and Mark Blackham (Cabinet reshuffle) are less convinced than some, with Blackham saying that ‘It's not much of a refresh. The real story is that in the fifth year of his administration, Key is in the same position as many predecessors; struggling to identify more good performers among ranks just outside Cabinet’. Gordon Campbell also identifies problems in his post, On the Cabinet reshuffle. Meanwhile, TV3 has reported my explanation for Hekia Parata being retained while other ministers were sacked – see: Edwards: Why Parata kept her job. And Cathy Odgers makes some similar points in her post, If It Looks Like A Spade And Smells Like A Spade.... Highly recommended is Jane Clifton’s A gutsy and weirdly blinkered National reshuffle

• Housing is the big policy issue of the day, with plenty of policy prescriptions being rolled out. Rodney Hide questions whether the various policies on state housing are simply about buying votes, and asks ‘whose interests do state houses serve? Politicians or tenants?’ – see: State house policy must free tenants from rentals

• Some difficult questions are also asked about the current Government policy on interest-free student loans in Richard Meadows’ Bitter pill should be swallowed

• We’re going to hear a lot about local government this year – and especially about amalgamations. That’s why it’s worth reading Pattrick Smellie’s Local reform coming, ready or not. For a lesson in central government intervention, see Kerry Burke’s How ECan fell to the irrigators.

• Are New Zealanders too anti-business? The departing head of NZ Coca-Cola has said so, leading to a debate about whether we value capitalists enough. The Herald has responded with an editorial saying that Business criticism hard to fathom. Matt McCarten has taken up the health aspect of the drinks manufacturer criticism, saying When your product benefits health, George, I'll show you some respect. But according to David Farrar, McCarten’s argument actually reinforces the CEO’s point – see: McCarten on Coke

• David Shearer’s upcoming ‘state of the nation’ speech will emphasise Labour’s economic differences with National, particularly the notion that Labour is now interventionist in contrast to National’s ‘hands off’ approach. John Armstrong says, ‘Shearer's more clear-cut position-taking will offer something voters have not enjoyed for a long time - a real choice between the two major parties on the fundamentals of economic policy’ – see: A new year, a new clarity from Shearer. But David Farrar makes some excellent points in his blog post, Not very hands off, in which in he illustrates just how economically interventionist this National Government actually is. He correctly points out that ‘the current differences between National and Labour in terms of involvement in the economy tend to be around the details, not a fundamental disagreement that the Government has a role in economic development’.

• If you want to look at what biculturalism means in 2013, John McCrone’s feature in The Press on Ngai Tahu's reach is highly recommended. Despite being the ‘whitest of New Zealand cities’, Christchurch is about to be rebuilt with the local iwi in the front seat, and it’s likely that even ‘street signage will also be dual language’, and the Avon River’s English willow trees could be cut down as part of the ‘Maorification’ of the new city.

• Steve Braunias’ wicked ‘Secret Diary’ series starts again this weekend, and he’s written a precursor to it, to explain what motivates him – see: Mocking Kiwis with a mix of love and loathing

• TV One’s Seven Sharp programme is still generating plenty of opinion, despite not actually being screened yet. The most useful recent items include Paul Little’s A hapless half hour, John Drinnan’s Dotcom mania too much, and Scott Kara’s Jesse Mulligan: I want to be like Jon Stewart

• Finally, if you want to know what’s going to happen in politics for the rest of the year, all you have to do is read Toby Manhire’s very funny and perceptive column, The year in review in advance

Bryce Edwards
NZPD Editor (

Today’s content:

Maori politics

Morgan Godfery (Maui St): Trouble in the Maori Party: Act I

Morgan Godfery (Maui St): Quick comments on a Mana Maori Party

Claire Trevett (Herald):Harawira's offer doesn't deserve a look in

Kate Chapman (Stuff): Labour works on Ratana appeal 

Herald: Editorial – Turmoil gives ammunition to party foes 

Claire Trevett (Herald): Turia plays down upheaval at top

Claire Trevett (Herald): Ratana choosy who gets the love

Newswire: Shearer to return to Ratana

RNZ:Battle heats up for Maori vote at Ratana

Claire Trevett (Herald): Flavell staying silent over leadership challenge

David Farrar (Kiwiblog): Wonder if other churches will be allowed to become Labour affiliates?

The Standard: Annette Sykes: a future MP?

Kate Chapman (Stuff): Don't take us for granted Maori warn politicians

RNZ: Ainu-Maori exchanges support Ratana legacy

RNZ:Labour says National running out of friends

RNZ: Ratana Church supports Mana-Maori alliance

Grant Duncan (Policy matters): Maori MPs provide the entertainment

RNZ: Death stuggle seen by Peters

The Standard: Maori Party in terminal decline

Newswire: Silence from Maori Party over leadership

Claire Trevett (Herald): Political leaders speak at Ratana

Pete George (Your NZ):“Maori Party…dead or dying”

Newswire: Harawira still pushing for party merger

Cathy Odgers (Cactus Kate): Maori Party Make John Banks Look Stable

RNZ: Harawira angles for Maori leadership role

Martyn Bradbury (Tumeke): MANA-Maori Party - Political Hybrid Vigor?

Laura McQuillan (Newswire): Harawira leader bid could affect Govt deal

Kate Chapman (Stuff): Flavell in hunt for Sharples' job

Laura McQuillan (Newswire) and TV3: Maori Party overshadows Ratana events

Katie Bradford-Crozier (Newstalk ZB): Cracks evident in Maori Party

Claire Trevett (Herald): Shearer to stay on at Ratana Pa

Claire Trevett (Herald): Sharples to stay after leadership showdown

Newswire: Harawira 'dictatorship' unwelcome – Turia

Anthony Robins (The Standard): Let it go Pita

Mike Barrington (Northern Advocate): Harawira: I'd lead Maori - Mana Party

Vernon Small (Stuff): Harawira mulls Maori Party return

Newswire: Harawira suggests party merger

Dan Satherley (TV3): Maori Party in 'terminal decline' - Harawira

Andrew Geddis (Pundit): Jesters do oft prove prophets

TV3: Flavell challenges Sharples for Maori Party leadership

TV3: Flavell, Katene want Maori Party co-leadership

Stuff:Leadership challenge in Maori Party

RNZ: Hui discussing Maori Party leadership challenge

Tim Selwyn (Tumeke): Oh, the madness

Claire Trevett (Herald): Maori Party leadership challenge confirmed

Stuff: Maori Party will have a 'way forward'

Laurel Stowell (Wanganui Chronical): Ratana speech rumours cause a stir

RNZ: How treaty settlement will be spent undecided - iwi trust


Cabinet reshuffle

Jane Clifton (Listener): Jane Clifton: a gutsy and weirdly blinkered National reshuffle

Dan Satherley (TV3): Edwards: Why Parata kept her job

John Armstrong (Herald): Smiling Assassin sets his bar for competence

Tracy Watkins (Stuff): Key ruthless in demoting Cabinet ministers

Tracy Watkins (Stuff): Return of the smiling assassin

Gordon Campbell (Scoop): On the Cabinet reshuffle

Kate Chapman (Stuff): Parata acknowledges mistakes made

The Standard:Late analysis on the reshuffle

Newstalk ZB: Mixed reaction to Cabinet reshuffle

Danyl Mclauchlan (Dim-Post): Respect!

Mark Blackham (Blackland PR): Political slate / Cabinet reshuffle

Dominion Post: Editorial – Reshuffle raises eyebrows

Herald: Editorial: Key shows boldness in choice of fresh faces

ODT: Editorial – Key learning from mistakes

Audrey Young (Herald): Changes aim to rejuvenate face of party before election

The Press: Editorial – Rejig lacks fireworks

Warwick Rasmussen (Manawatu Standard): Editorial – Key shaping his A team

Waikato Times: Editorial – Tonic or more of same?

Audrey Young (Herald): Rising young talent 'excited, humbled'

Robert Winter (Idle thoughts): Key and Kaye

Dan Satherley (TV3): Shearer questions PM's judgement over Parata

Dan Satherley (TV3): David Shearer wastes no time attacking Nick Smith

Andrea Vance (Stuff): Parata survives but Joyce called in

RNZ: PM confident of new ministers' performance

David Farrar (Kiwiblog): Ruthless

RNZ: Parata has done a lot of things right, says PM

Cathy Odgers (Cactus Kate): If It Looks Like A Spade And Smells Like A Spade....

Newswire: Sacked ministers accept their fate

Martyn Bradbury (Tumeke): The faux surprise by Key's 'bold' Cabinet reshuffle

Mike Dinsdale (Northern Advocate): Heatley takes positives from Cabinet dumping

Newswire: Cabinet to hold first meeting of 2013

RNZ: Farm lobby welcomes top job for Nathan Guy

The Standard: Hello everybody! Hi Dr Nick!

Hamish Rutherford (Stuff): I've served my time away: Nick Smith

Newswire: Key backs Parata to perform

The Press:Editorial – Hekia Parata is a minister with much to prove

Claire Trevett (Herald): PM defends Parata's performance


Labour Party

Kate Chapman (Stuff): Cunliffe 'not challenging Shearer'

TVNZ: Labour leadership bid ruled out by Cunliffe

David Farrar (Kiwiblog): Not very hands off

David Farrar (Kiwiblog): Salmond rejoins the Labour Leader’s Office

Chris Trotter (Stuff): Strategy vital for hopefuls before leadership vote

The Standard: For a February leadership vote

John Armstrong (Herald): A new year, a new clarity from Shearer

The Standard: Shearer to put it to the vote

Scott Yorke (Imperator Fish): A Labour Membership Vote Seems Unlikely

Greg Presland (Waitakere News): What has to happen to the Labour Party

Pete George (Your NZ): Labour Party members pissed on again

David Farrar (Kiwiblog): Is Shearer going to call for a full membership vote?  

Pete George (Your NZ): Te Reo Mokemoke promoting a certain Shearer win

Pete George (Your NZ): Another Eddie in murky Labour waters

Robert Winter (Idle thoughts): Mr Shearer's "clarity"?



Gordon Campbell (Scoop): On the crisis in affordable housing

David Killick (Stuff): New housing solutions desperately needed

Kieran Campbell (APNZ): Auckland stays near top of unaffordable list

RNZ: NZ housing 'seriously unaffordable'

Kieran Campbell (APNZ): Novice buyers told to lower sights

Michael Daly (Stuff): Govt could run housing land supply - English

Stuff: City houses 'severely unaffordable'

TVNZ:Green Party proposes 'Rent to buy' scheme

Kate Shuttleworth (Herald): Greens offer families homes

Dan Satherley (TV3): Greens unveil 'rent-to-buy' housing scheme

Pete George (Your NZ): Greens challenge Labour on housing policy

The Standard: Greens offer pathway to home ownership, better renters’ rights

David Farrar (Kiwiblog): Why not just have the Govt build and own all the homes?

Cameron Slater (Whaleoil): Green Taliban supports selling state houses… and rent control

Robert Winter (Idle thoughts): The Greens' Housing Package

Holly Walker (Frogblog): A tour of Auckland’s housing challenges

Eric Crampton (Offsetting behaviour): Housing, with a bit of English

RNZ: Housing NZ to sort out empty properties, mayor told

Stuff: Package needed to solve housing issues

Rodney Hide (Herald): State house policy must free tenants from rentals

TVNZ: Housing prices spark crisis fears

Matt Stewart (Stuff): Ghetto born from state housing neglect

Newswire: Greens' housing policy 'Monopoly' - Key

Cathy Odgers (Cactus Kate): Come To NZ - The Nice Stupid People Will Finance Your Home

Pete George (Your NZ): Major flaw in Labour-Green housing policies

Ben Clark (The Standard): Complementary Housing

Kate Shuttleworth (APNZ): Govt criticises Greens' housing plan

Gordon Campbell (Scoop): On the Greens housing proposals, and Pita Sharples


John Key state of nation speech

Audrey Young and Kate Shuttleworth (Herald): Key: NZ needs to be 'magnet for investment'

Tracy Watkins (Stuff): Plenty hanging on leaders' speeches

Newswire: Opposition parties scorn Key's speech

RNZ: PM lists 2013 issues crucial to next election.

TV3: Key's speech to focus on economy, RMA


Business-friend New Zealand?

Matt McCarten (Herald): When your product benefits health, George, I'll show you some respect

David Farrar (Kiwiblog): McCarten on Coke  

Herald: Editorial – Business criticism hard to fathom

The Standard: Think big & embrace the rot

Will de Cleene (Gonzo): Coke Pimp Leaves NZ with Case of Sour Grapes

Rob O’Neill (Stuff): World Bank wants us to think big

Herald: Sir Owen throws down a challenge for Kiwis to get NZ working

Robert Winter (Idle thoughts): No, Mr Glenn


John Key in Antarctica

Lynley Bilby (Herald): Maybe a wee dram of whisky will help your memory, John

Deidre Mussen (Stuff): PM hopes to follow Scott's footsteps

Isaac Davison (Herald): PM waxes lyrical after landing in Antarctica, 'a place of great beauty'


John Key’s health

Stuff: PM has 'out of body experience'  

Adam Bennett (Herald): Jetlag ruled out as factor in Prime Minister's collapse at restaurant

Kloe Palmer (TV3): Diners gasped as PM fainted


Ethnicity and Treaty politics

Gehan Gunasekara (Herald): Treaty principles here to stay

Ewen McQueen (Herald): There can be only 'one sun in the sky' and that's the Crown

RNZ: Lobby favours pre-emptive action to avoid jailing Maori

RNZ: Maori focus units promising - lobby

Morgan Godfery (Maui St): Fact checking David Round

Rod Vaughan (NBR): Why other Kiwis must stop fawning to the shrill cries of Maori

John McCrone (The Press): Ngai Tahu's reach



Claire Robinson (Spinprofessor): Is it any wonder that news media outlets have difficulty finding female “expert” commentators willing to stand up and speak out?

John Drinnan (Herald): Dotcom mania too much

Scott Kara (Herald): Jesse Mulligan: I want to be like Jon Stewart

Steve Braunias (Stuff): Mocking Kiwis with a mix of love and loathing

Paul Little (Herald): A hapless half hour

Victoria Young (NBR): Still no sponsor for TVNZ's Seven Sharp

John Roughan (Herald): Holmes gets to hear his best reviews

Paul Thomas (Herald): For making our country a better place ... a knighthood well earned

Sarah Stuart (Herald): Twelve Questions with Raewyn Rasch

Martyn Bradbury (Tumeke): The horror of Seven Sharp (Dear Mr Sainsbury - I am so very sorry)

Tim Selwyn (Tumeke): 7 sharp

Peter Griffin (Future news): Blogger rakes in hundreds of thousands with subs push

The Standard: Media Bias & Democracy II: beyond 2 sides

Karl du Fresne (Stuff): Dropping objectivity would be a disaster


Government film funding

Anthony Hubbard (Stuff): NZ a star paying to act in a supporting role

Kate Chapman (Stuff): Middle-earth not real, by the way

David Fisher (Herald): How Key's Tinseltown trip kept NZ industry in frame

David Fisher (Herald): Union weakness lured films

Garry Maddox (Sydney Morning Herald): Hobbit trilogy inspires another boom

Adam Bennett (Herald): Government to announce future of grants

Gordon Campbell (Stuff): Movies a wise investment



Toby Manhire (Guardian): Mega spectacle at launch of Kim Dotcom's new file-sharing site

David Fisher (Herald): Fake raid marks start of Mega

William Mace (Stuff): Dotcom: Now I'm after Google  

RNZ: Mega will be closely monitored - lawyer

Tom Pullar-Strecker (Stuff): Mega business model 'very different'

TVNZ: Dotcom to step back from spotlight

Russell Brown (Public Address): MegaBox: From f**k-all to zero

Waikato Times: Editorial – Lift lid on crime fighter



Yvonne Tahana (Herald): Doctorates where the big money is

Jody O’Callaghan (Stuff): Degrees ranked by earning potential

Sarah Robson (Newswire): Changes will hurt postgrad students

Georgina Hampton (ODT): Cuts 'short-sighted' for New Zealand

Southland Times: Editorial – Digital education

Herald: Editorial – Education, not hysteria, works to stop youth crime

Graeme Edgeler (Public Address): The hopeful disallowance of the New Zealand Teachers Council (Conduct) Rules 2004

Southland Times: Editorial – Protecting the wrong people

Waikato Times: Editorial – Lift this shroud of secrecy

Charley Mann (Stuff): Charter school bill gets big response



Jamie Morton (Herald): Govt accused of ignoring advice on clean, green brand

Peter Whitmore (Herald): Immediate action needed to reduce carbon emissions

Hamish Rutherford (Stuff): Government to finance irrigation


Local government

Pattrick Smellie (Stuff): Local reform coming, ready or not

Kerry Burke (Stuff): How ECan fell to the irrigators

ODT: Editorial – Dunedin's austerity budget

Taranaki Daily News: Time for a Cull-like epiphany here too?



Audrey Young (Herald): Welfare reform priority for English

Stuff: Tightened welfare heightens need

Dominion Post: Editorial – Unfairness in drug testing bill

Ben Heather (Stuff): Welfare drug tests may break privacy law


The Economy

Corin Dann (TVNZ): Economy 'front and centre' for Govt this year - Key

RNZ: Treasury not impressed with SOEs

Bernard Hickey (Herald): Fat cats egg us on to throw our cheddar down debt hole

David Farrar (Kiwiblog): Inflation

Peter Lyons (ODT): Greatest invention double-edged sword

Matthew Jones (Herald): Minimum wage rises destroy jobs for those most in need

Bryan Gould (Herald): Crisis in manufacturing goes unheeded

Jason Krupp (Stuff): Christchurch rebuild adds impetus for manufacturers

Michael Berry (Stuff): Flat tax rate for Christchurch opposed

Vernon Small (Stuff): Government deficit improves



Got a question about this story? Leave it in Comments & Questions below.

This article is tagged with the following keywords. Find out more about MyNBR Tags

Comments & Questions

Commenter icon key: Subscriber Verified

Post New comment or question

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

NZ Market Snapshot


Sym Price Change
USD 0.6952 0.0000 0.00%
AUD 0.8901 0.0000 0.00%
EUR 0.5907 0.0000 0.00%
GBP 0.5276 0.0000 0.00%
HKD 5.4294 0.0000 0.00%
JPY 78.9230 0.0000 0.00%


Commodity Price Change Time
Gold Index 1278.6 -9.430 2017-10-20T00:
Oil Brent 57.8 0.550 2017-10-20T00:
Oil Nymex 51.9 0.580 2017-10-20T00:
Silver Index 17.0 -0.177 2017-10-20T00:


Symbol Open High Last %
NZX 50 8124.1 8142.3 8124.1 0.07%
NASDAQ 6633.4 6640.0 6605.1 0.36%
DAX 13057.8 13063.6 12990.1 0.01%
DJI 23205.2 23328.8 23163.0 0.71%
FTSE 7523.0 7560.0 7523.0 0.00%
HKSE 28360.0 28519.8 28159.1 1.17%
NI225 21391.0 21489.3 21448.5 0.04%
ASX 5896.1 5924.9 5896.1 0.17%