Why Americans embrace nationhood but Kiwis do not

Paul Buchanan: No unifying foundational myth in New Zealand
Barack Obama: Spelled it out in his recent victory speech

If New Zealand wants a lesson in how to foster race relations and develop a sense of nationhood it needs to look no further than New York.

A two-week holiday there recently was an eye-opener into how so many people of vastly different ethnicities can largely co-exist harmoniously and take pride in their shared US citizenship.

Sure, it’s not all a bed of roses. But to me, this huge melting pot of eight million people, most of them immigrants or descendants of immigrants from all over the world, is a glowing example of what should be happening in our part of the globe.

Here, we are in the throes of developing a multi-cultural society, and for the most part we celebrate our growing diversity. But still the predominant immigrant groups, Maori and European, remain at loggerheads over so many issues.

For their part, Maori appear intent on achieving sovereignty, or at the very least pursuing a path of separatism, while Europeans harbour growing resentment at the seemingly never-ending demands of their blood brothers.

And, yes, Maori and Europeans are quite literally blood brothers today, their bloodlines inextricably fused after generations of inter-marriage.

Yet despite so much that binds us together, this is conveniently ignored by those intent on getting a larger slice of the economic cake, often for the most spurious of reasons.

Such are the divisions that we cannot celebrate our national day without the proceedings degenerating into rancor and sometimes violence.

It is truly a sad indictment of where we are as a nation and where we might be heading.

So why are New Yorkers, and all Americans for that matter, more willing than us to put many of their multifarious differences to one side and take pride in their joint heritage as citizens of the United States?

It’s a question that was given new meaning in President Barack Obama’s recent victory speech.

Consider this: “What makes America exceptional are the bonds that hold together the most diverse nation on Earth, the belief that our destiny is shared, that this country only works when we accept certain obligations to one another and to future generations, so that the freedom which so many Americans have fought for and died for come with responsibilities as well as rights, and among those are love and charity and duty and patriotism. That’s what makes America great.”

And this: “I believe we can keep the promise of our founding, the idea that if you’re willing to work hard, it doesn’t matter who you are or where you come from or what you look like or where you live. It doesn’t matter whether you’re black or white or Hispanic or Asian or Native American or young or old or rich or poor, able, disabled, gay or straight. You can make it here in America if you’re willing to try.”  

Cynics, of course, will dismiss much of this as political hyperbole, but they are wrong.

Mr Obama’s message is as relevant to New Zealand as it is for his homeland, but we seem to give it scant regard as we struggle to develop a true sense of nationhood.

To find out why this should be I turned to an American who has lived in New Zealand since 1997.

Dr Paul Buchanan is best known as a strategic analyst, but he is also an astute observer of NZ/US relations.

He says there are many issues and events which have made us evolve so differently and shape our sense of nationhood.

“I think there are historical and geopolitical factors at play in the differences in national identification between the US and New Zealand.

“The US fought a war of independence that broke ties with the mother country and removed the privileges associated with those ties.

“New Zealand remained a colony for a long time, with the country operating in a post-colonial fashion down to the point that British social hierarchies are emulated in some circles.

“In the US, the indigenous people were defeated by force of arms, dispossessed of their territory and forced to relocate on reservations.

“In New Zealand, the indigenous population was not conquered by force and negotiated a settlement that granted them specific and often privileged rights and entitlements into the future.

“As a very large country, the US has been able to assimilate large numbers of immigrants operating under a strong foundational myth that the US is the land of opportunity and freedom.

“But in New Zealand non-English immigration and assimilation has been a more recent phenomenon and there is no unifying national myth that encourages rapid identification as a Kiwi.”

Dr Buchanan says the issue of foundational or national myths is very important in terms of developing a sense of nationhood.

“Children are raised to revere the US flag, to the point that there are laws outlawing flag desecration and defining the proper ways with which to handle the national symbol.

“Kids recite the Pledge of Allegiance every day in school and are taught from early age that the US Declaration of Independence and Constitution are the world's pre-eminent political documents and charter.

“Much social pressure is placed on showing allegiance to the flag, to the point that flags are everywhere, not just during patriotic holidays but in everyday life.

“This constant inculcation and reaffirmation in words and in symbolic practice of American exceptionalism reinforces the general belief that the US is a special place, to which there is added a strong religious component for about a third of the population (who see the US as God's chosen place)."

Dr Buchanan says the US military is another strong bond uniting many Americans.

“The US is a highly militaristic nation that is semi-permanently at war or engaged in foreign conflicts to protect its global interests.

“The US military is an avenue of upward mobility for working-class people and ethnic minorities, where the meritocratic promotion system and the strong ideological focus of the armed forces reaffirms the commonality of interest and belief that makes US citizens 'American'.

“So there are a combination of factors that help bind shallow and deep nationalism into a coherent sense of national identity.

“This is more than flag on the shoulder or bumper sticker patriotism.

“It is a sincere belief that there is no better place than the US to be in terms of government or in material opportunity and however mistaken that belief may be, it is nearly universally shared.”

On the other hand, Dr Buchanan says New Zealand is not a strategically important country and is located in a remote part of the world.

“It has no historical or contemporary enemies and is physically insulated from foreign-based threats to national security.

“It has a long history of stability but also a long history of cultural difference between European descendants, Maori and other Pacifika cultures.

“This combination gives the population the 'luxury' of focusing on internal differences rather than common external concerns.

“Moreover, there is no unifying foundational myth to which all can subscribe to.

“Maori believe in their historical memory of the foundation of Aotearoa, Pakeha think of the early settlers and the Chinese and Polynesians have their versions of the foundational moment.”

Dr Buchanan also points to the New Zealand educational system, which he says does not promote a unified national vision, but reinforces cultural differences in the teaching of history and social studies.

“There is no reification of New Zealand exceptionalism or even of the national flag. Instead, the black flag with silver fern associated with a sports team is the most commonly followed national symbol.

“If anything, there is a downplaying of historically unifying events and forces in favour of cultural difference and diversity, which makes very difficult the construction and promulgation of a common national myth, even if it does recognise that diversity has its own benefits and rewards.”

Ironically, Dr Buchanan says New Zealanders living abroad are often the only ones to exhibit a common sense of identity.

“For some reason – be it homesickness, nostalgia or distance – New Zealanders appear to find their common identity outside of the mother country rather than within it.

“Certainly, other nationalities also cluster and reaffirm their ties to the homeland when travelling or living abroad.

“But the contrast is stark in the case of Kiwis precisely because there is no strong sense of national identity binding them when at home.

“In other words, Kiwis discover their 'national' identity while on OEs.”

Dr Buchanan says it remains to be seen how long Americans will retain their sense of “Americaness”, given the rapid demographic shifts and ideological differences now gripping that nation.

“In New Zealand it does not yet matter that the internal focus on difference rather than commonality remains the dominant trait.

“That’s because the elite system benefits from a culture that sees differences between racial, ethnic and religious groups rather than differences between classes as being the most important to address.

“And that may be the key to New Zealand's stability.

“People prefer to not think in class terms but rather in non-class, cultural or ethnic terms, thereby allowing for the largely unfettered development of capitalism as the primary social construct and market logics as the dominant ideology shared by elite, middle-class and working-class people alike, regardless of ethnic, religious or cultural persuasion.”

So, at long last some encouraging news about where we might be headed as a nation.

And perhaps somewhere along the way we might come to the conclusion that embracing our “New Zealandness”, be it at home or abroad, is no bad thing.


12 · Got a question about this story? Leave it in Comments & Questions below.

This article is tagged with the following keywords. Find out more about MyNBR Tags

Post Comment

12 Comments & Questions

Commenter icon key: Subscriber Verified

If we (NZ) had a decent flag, one that didn't have another countries flag on it we might have a better, bigger since of nationhood. Yes?

  • 0
  • 0


  • 0
  • 0

I recall at school (and I went to several, as my parents moved) we fell in before classes and stood to attention as the ensign was raised, and then sang the national anthem.
And what's wrong with having "another country's flag". Go to Hawaii, where they are proud to fly their State flag, the Union Jack and Stripes. Why, even Australia followed the design of our ensign (check the dates)

  • 0
  • 0

You must have been born outside NZ, maybe a pom Paddy? I don't want to go to Hawaii. I love NZ!

  • 0
  • 0

Mr Vaughan you have written such an essay certainly in length I am sure is from the head and heart. Every paragraph has a point worthy of discussion. I need time to reflect more, but I cant help but wonder at the many kiwis I catch up with while frequently away who are more bold in stating a few things they are glad to leave behind. A common thread are subjects that are rarely openly discussed in unsure company here in NZ when those around the bbq don't know some others. Yet these same folk glad to be gone proudly still wear a kiwi t shirt which at least especially in France tends to ensure you aren't treated like dirt by some pompous type. For myself I have no loyalty anymore. A country and system that fought me on every turn and for the tax I have paid higher than most I have forever felt that I am not welcome. My destiny is elsewhere like those before me and those I have raised. Travelling has opened my eyes to so many wonderful people and places I don't hold NZ in any more regard than some would have me believe and there's the rub, when you are told for all your formative years that you as a kiwi are the centre of the universe, the reality is a bit of a let down.

  • 0
  • 0

Umm-How do you know you have paid more tax than most?? And do you think being a high earner gives you entitlements beyond those of the working class ??

Mainly, your final 2 lines made me wonder about the authenticity of your comments. I never heard that at school-albeit one in a working class area where it remains till this day.

  • 0
  • 0

Then FLICK off.

  • 0
  • 0

Americans have a strong emphasis on personal responsibility and reward, be they Democrat or Republican, whereas we have to a large extent been seduced by the welfare state and a section of our citizens have come to happily rely on the Government rather than being dependent on their own resources.
Some of us believe that the American philosophy of risk and reward is more beneficial to a nation.
We also cling to a greater or lesser degree to the British Monarchy which is unhelpful in terms of building a national identity.
Whether we will mature past this stage must depend on our economic development (which is regrettably flat-lining at present)

  • 0
  • 0

I suggest that people get behind John Ansell's Together New Zealand campaign as a good starting point. Equality under the law and an end to the grievance gravy train would get things moving.

  • 0
  • 0

All comments very relevant.
America are strongly patriotic, ok they have a few loonies and we get to see the best of there daytime tv, Jerry Springer, reality rubbish bla bla. But with a population their size your gonna have a some basket cases.
The hand on the chest to the star spangled banner, the god bless America, can be a little nauseating, but we as kiwis could learn a lot from this.
We don't , I believe, have nearly enough patriotism or pride in our country, securing and looking after our own home grown businesses and economy, loosing the tall poppy syndrome, and having just as much passion for everything that is ours as we do rugby, rather than selling ourselves to the cheapest bidder.
Being married to one, I find yanks show a lot of passion towards family and friends, reflecting selflessness. Pride in the men and women in uniform, but also hard working and dedicated.
We have a long way to go but with a little education and CHANGE! We may get there one day

  • 0
  • 0

A very good article Rod, with many important points and truths to reflect on. Unfortunately, the lack of racial cohesion in New Zealand is being further perpetuated by the lack of willingness of many Asian immigrants to assimilate as "Kiwis" here, and us "Kiwis" general inability to interact with those that do wish to fully assimilate. I also have Kiwi friends and family members - both pakeha and Maori - who have no time for this cointry anynore and choose to live overseas. We do need to ask ourselves WHY this is? This article at least may engender some debate among our nornally apathetic peoples.

  • 0
  • 0

great thought provoking article, one of the best I have read in a while I lived in Wisconsin for 12 months as an exchange student in 1967/68 and have struggled for years since to understand why we seem to struggle for some form of national identity here in NZ. I dont agree with all the points in the article, but it is a good start. I suspect though that by the time NZ might develop any 'US' type identity strength, the whole world will have become a diffrent place, including in the US. and the 'identity' will more develop in the realm of 'individuals' and families than in countries.......ie the significance of countries will in most cases lessen due to , among other things, attrition by pc

  • 0
  • 0

Post New comment or question

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

NZ Market Snapshot


Sym Price Change
USD 0.6964 0.0026 0.37%
AUD 0.8903 0.0014 0.16%
EUR 0.5916 0.0012 0.20%
GBP 0.5278 0.0017 0.32%
HKD 5.4315 0.0185 0.34%
JPY 79.2400 0.0710 0.09%


Commodity Price Change Time
Gold Index 1278.6 -9.430 2017-10-20T00:
Oil Brent 57.8 0.550 2017-10-20T00:
Oil Nymex 51.9 0.580 2017-10-20T00:
Silver Index 17.0 -0.177 2017-10-20T00:


Symbol Open High Last %
NZX 50 8124.1 8142.3 8124.1 0.07%
NASDAQ 6633.4 6640.0 6605.1 0.36%
DAX 13057.8 13063.6 12990.1 0.01%
DJI 23205.2 23328.8 23163.0 0.71%
FTSE 7523.0 7560.0 7523.0 0.00%
HKSE 28557.8 28557.8 28487.2 -0.67%
NI225 21709.3 21712.9 21457.6 1.16%
ASX 5907.0 5925.3 5907.0 -0.03%