As Act peels away, Crown fibre bill hinges on Maori Party support

Act leader Don Brash

The controversial Telecommunications Amendment Bill is back in parliament for its final lap, setting the scene for a Telecom split and the final stages of Crown fibre contract negotiations.

Opponents hoping for major changes during the legislation's select committee phase will be disappointed.

For, as predicted by NBR, the finance and expenditure select committee reported the Telecommunications Amendment Bill returned to the house yesterday with its two most controversial provisions intact (see a PDF here).

National and the Maori Party (forming a majority on the committee) recommended the bill in its current form; Act, Labour and the Greens did not. Labour promised to repeal a key element - the so-called ten-year regulatory holiday - for Crown fibre companies - if elected.

Act: might as well flush $1.35 billion down the toilet
Act voted for the bill's first reading, but with MP Sir Roger Douglas expressing reservations. New leader Don Brash - like Sir Roger and a second Act MP, Heather Roy - has been an outspoken critic of government involvment in broadband. Now, as earlier flagged by NBR, it has become a strong opponent.

Sir Roger sharpened his rhetoric on this morning, telling RNZ that the government might as well "take one thousand five hundred million dollars and flush it down the toilet."

Act's coalition agreement with National requires it to support the government main election promises. However, Communications Minister Steven Joyce evaded the question of whether the telco bill fell under this category, offering only that National and Act are "working through the issues."

Maori Party support shored up
The bill is still set to pass its second and third readings regardless by dint of Maori Party support, recent shored up with the establishment of Nga Pu Waea, a new group that will meet bi-monthly with Telecom and Vodafone to ensure the $300 million rural broadband intiative (RBI) provides connectivity options for marae, addresses land access issues and explores Maori employment opportunities. Communications minister Steven Joyce said Nga Pu Waea could be extended to the $1.35 billion urban ultrafast broadband initiative.

Telecom shares (NZX: TEL) were up 1.35% to $2.335 in late trading on the NZX as the news was announced, contiinuing the company's recent bull run.

Two key elements intact
InternetNZ is not happy.

“The biggest problems with this legislation were the imposition of a regulatory holiday preventing the Commerce Commission from doing its job in the fibre environment and Telecom rather than Government leading the structural separation process,” InternetNZ chief executive Vikram Kumar said this afternoon.

“Neither of these major flaws have been fixed.

"Act, the Greens and Labour MPs on the committee have set these out as key problems they have with the bill, and we agree."

The Greens said the bill delivered Telecom a "legalised monopoly". Labour pledged to repeal elements of the legislation.

TelstraClear, which has been running TV and newspaper campaigns attacking what it calls, confusingly, "The Ultra Fast Broadband Bill" expressed disappointment but not surprise.

Federated Farmers, Consumer, most telcos bar Telecom oppose bill
“Given Minister Joyce’s unwavering faith in his own views and the politics of the whole situation, I am hardly surprised by the outcome,” chief executive Allan Freeth said. “But I am disappointed by the lack of respect shown by the Minister to the industry and consumer groups alike, and the inevitable cost and loss of choice for New Zealanders.” A coalition including Federated Farmers, Consumer, InternetNZ, Tuanz, Vodafone and 2degrees has opposed the bill.

“I had hoped this Government would have learned from recent history which has seen Telecom fined a record $12 million for anti-competitive behaviour, and mobile termination rates forced down only after action by the Commerce Commission," Dr Freeth said.

A few small changes
Mr Kumar acknowledged that the select committee had made minor tweaks.

“We do welcome small changes the Committee has made to the Bill. There are bigger penalties for breaches to LFC undertakings; a requirement for the Minister to consult the Commerce Commission for some decisions, and a useful narrowing of the broad power the minister would have had to spend funds from the Telecommunications Development Levy on almost anything," Mr Kumar said.

“Importantly, the Committee has fixed the definition of Equivalence that will apply to Local Fibre Companies from 2020. It is now clear that an equivalence of inputs standard is required."

Still, “Overall, this Bill favours Telecom’s shareholders over the wider New Zealand public. It seems that the market has made the same assessment, with Telecom’s share price jumping up," Mr Kumar said.

The legislation's impact
Among other measures, the bill sets out the regulatory frame work for the rural and urban broadband projects; allows the government to buy Telecom assets; and a spun-off Telecom network company to invest in local lines and fibre companies without the usual level of M&A scrutiny (crucially, such deals can only be entered into after the initial round of Crown fibre regional contracts are signed).

It also includes provision for a 10-year forbearance period for ultrafast broadband regional contract winners - a measure Mr Joyce has described as a pragmatic move to attract private co-investors. The minister has also argued that pricing is set by contracts with the government over the decade-long "regulator holiday" (it can go down, but not up). Mr Kumar, and others have worried it might not fall as fast as other countries.

Despite the three parties' oppositition, the bill should still pass its second and third readings by dint of Maori Party support, recent shored up with the establishment of Nga Pu Waea, a new group that will meet bi-monthly with Telecom and Vodafone to ensure the $300 million rural broadband intiative (RBI) provides connectivity options for marae, addresses land access issues and explores Maori employment opportunities. Communications minister Steven Joyce said Nga Pu Waea could be extended to the $1.35 billion urban ultrafast broadband initiative.
Telecom shares (NZX: TEL) were up 1.35% to $2.335 in late trading.

11 · Got a question about this story? Leave it in Comments & Questions below.

This article is tagged with the following keywords. Find out more about MyNBR Tags

Post Comment

11 Comments & Questions

Commenter icon key: Subscriber Verified

Speaking as a Telecom employee (hence anonymous) I can assure you most people in Telecom see this as a bill to screw Telecom, not empower it.

Telecom would be forced to take all the economic risk and base the initial price on the '10 year price', effectively passing on the 'regulatory holiday' advantage despite no guarantee it would get that holiday due to politics.

Also the government wants the money back after every connection, you could therefore describe it as an interest free loan rather than a real investment. It reduces takeup risk slightly at the cost of forcing the LFC to invest in technology well ahead of demand

Reply
Share
  • 0
  • 0

So don't bid.

Reply
Share
  • 0
  • 0

Lolecom

Reply
Share
  • 0
  • 0

about time nats have a struggle

Reply
Share
  • 0
  • 0

Is getting this bill passed, blackmail from the Maori party?
I mean, isn't this pork barrelled politics with the government needing to pony up some money for Maori, specifically, at the Maori Party request for support?
Don't you just love MMP?

Reply
Share
  • 0
  • 0

An interest-free loan, for god's sake. I trust the NBR will name-and-shame the clowns on that select committee....poodles for Joyce.
Chris K , you must be apoplectic. This is an unmitigated -- in both senses of the word -- disaster.
Joyce, English and Key (JEK) are so pleased with themselves that they aren't hearing the drums starting to beat. We're sick of the pork-barrelling. Enough.
Watch the Brogue Rogue double his "salary" and delay his NZ-sponsored retirement to the lowlands....just to make us all throw-up. And delay the unwinding of the current monopoly with the overlay of another decade-plus of mediocrity.
Disgraceful.

Reply
Share
  • 0
  • 0

keep taking the pills bertie..... your rants make less and less sense every day....

Reply
Share
  • 0
  • 0

B S Bertie, all you do is BITCH all the time on everything Telecom. why don't you get yourself a good hobby??????

Reply
Share
  • 0
  • 0

B*** S*** Bertie. Talk some sence and do some homework

Reply
Share
  • 0
  • 0

B S Bertie is clearly off his med's! Time for another dose Bertie.

Reply
Share
  • 0
  • 0

Why mention Don Brash, he is not an MP and doesn't get to vote.

We just need to do this

Reply
Share
  • 0
  • 0

Post New comment or question

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

NZ Market Snapshot

Forex

Sym Price Change
USD 0.7030 0.0002 0.03%
AUD 0.9206 0.0000 0.00%
EUR 0.6530 0.0014 0.21%
GBP 0.5627 0.0013 0.23%
HKD 5.4601 0.0019 0.03%
JPY 78.2800 0.2610 0.33%

Commods

Commodity Price Change Time
Gold Index 1243.7 -4.580 2017-03-23T00:
Oil Brent 50.6 -0.100 2017-03-23T00:
Oil Nymex 47.7 -0.360 2017-03-23T00:
Silver Index 17.6 0.010 2017-03-23T00:

Indices

Symbol Open High Last %
NZX 50 7062.6 7079.1 7062.6 0.17%
NASDAQ 5812.3 5842.8 5821.6 -0.07%
DAX 11914.2 12043.7 11904.1 1.14%
DJI 20645.1 20757.9 20661.3 -0.02%
FTSE 7324.7 7346.4 7324.7 0.22%
HKSE 24396.4 24420.8 24327.7 -0.09%
NI225 19066.3 19296.0 19085.3 0.92%
ASX 5708.0 5768.4 5708.0 0.95%