The fall and fall of Richard Worth

The initial press releases from Richard Worth and John Key left many people puzzled. They both stated he had resigned as a minister for personal reasons, but gave no hint of what that meant.

The sad reality for Dr Worth is that there were so many things it could have been. It could have been about his Indian business dealings. It could have been about the high profile defamation case he is a witness in. It could have been about his visit to a crime victim, despite knowing the assailants’ family. It could have been about his Korean business dealings. Or it could have been something to do with a woman.

If you are a minister who is forced to resign, you ideally want everyone to be amazed and surprised, and say how they are stunned and never saw it coming. You don’t want them speculating in a multi-choice fashion as to what the actual reason was.

Richard Worth was seen as a high flier to many when he entered Parliament. He was the chairman of top law firm Simpson Grierson, and had been the National Party’s northern regional policy chairman. He was thought to be able to do as well as classmates Simon Power and Katherine Rich who also entered in 1999.

Worth held off Rodney Hide by 1908 votes in 1999. In 2002 his majority grew to 5619 over Labour’s Di Nash with Hide in third place. And as everyone knows he then lost the seat in 2005 to Hide . To be fair this was mainly the result of strategic voting by National supporters but some felt Worth had not performed strongly enough.

As an Opposition spokesperson, Worth never fulfilled his potential. No major policy work, no scandals broken, no particular vigour. Many pointed out that his attention seemed to be focused on getting his doctorate. So Don Brash told him in 2005 that if National won, he would be Speaker, not a minister.

 Brash didn’t win in 2005 but John Key did in 2008. Lockwood Smith became Speaker – an appointment that ironically at the time was seen as a demotion for Smith. Smith has gone on to enjoy much higher esteem as Speaker than he would have back in cabinet.

Worth ended up not in cabinet, but as a minister outside cabinet. It was never likely he would make cabinet. PM Key used his ministerial spots outside cabinet to place MPs whose seniority was such that they couldn’t be left on the backbench, but who were likely to be a minister for one term only, and be likely to retire at the next election. A sort of halfway house between cabinet and retirement.

Worth is a very bright lawyer. If you talk legal issues with him, he has a first class knowledge and could have contributed a lot in the right portfolios. As well as his PhD, he has an MBA and a master of jurisprudence.

But what he did not have is a very good political antennae. He chose to go camel riding rather than attend a Maori Battalion service in Egypt. A smart political brain would tell you that was risky.

Likewise he happily represented the government of Monaco as its Counsel and sat on the board of the Prada America’s Cup Challenge. Neither of these things are bad or wrong – but they are potentially unwise for an MP. That political survival instinct just was not there.

We see this again with the allegations passed on by Phil Goff about his conversations with a young married Labour Party activist. The allegations are that he made romantic overtures to her, seemingly in exchange for potential board appointments. Now we have yet to hear Worth’s side of the story, but it is another very bad look.

Worth might not be the first MP to try and use his office to big note and impress a potential romantic conquest, if that is what happened. But what is especially naïve or stupid is that she was a Labour Party activist – you don’t have to be a brain surgeon to work out that is a bad person for a National MP to be hitting on (if he was). As one acquaintance quipped to me – “National MPs are meant to be offering jobs and sex to National Party activists, not bloody Labour Party members.” A somewhat bad taste quip, but is it any surprise it ended up with Phil Goff.

Goff to his credit raised the issue privately with Key. This is not an uncommon thing. I know of half a dozen cases myself where cross-party communications have occurred regarding an MP needing some counseling. Key’s chief of staff put the allegations to Worth, who not only denied them, but reportedly offered to swear an affidavit denying them, and that if they were publicized he would sue for defamation. Key relayed that back to Goff and the matter lay there – he denied it but implicitly there would be no further contact anyway. At the time it was probably case closed for both leaders as Worth no doubt stopped texting the woman in question.

Then of course we have the issue which is now a criminal investigation. Even without knowing the facts, there is enough to once again detect the lack of political judgment from Worth. He was under police investigation and he didn’t tell the prime minister. That by itself is sackable.

In the next few days the exact nature of the allegations will probably be made public, and charges may be laid. Even if they are not, PM Key has made it clear that even without criminal offending, the private conduct has been woeful enough to mean he can never return to the ministry.

This is quite a change from past practice. Clark often recycled sacked ministers such as Ruth Dyson and Lianne Dalziel who both returned after being sacked for drunk driving and lying respectively. Key is not only ruling out Worth’s return one day, but has hinted strongly he should resign as an MP.

Until the exact nature of the criminal allegations are known, it is premature to say he will definitely go as an MP. But I have to say it is hard to imagine he will ever attend a National caucus meeting again.


15 · Got a question about this story? Leave it in Comments & Questions below.

This article is tagged with the following keywords. Find out more about MyNBR Tags

Post Comment

15 Comments & Questions

Commenter icon key: Subscriber Verified

He should resign.

Reply
Share
  • 0
  • 0

If Goff was 100% certain he would have gone straight to the debating chamber all right

It is the Labout Party you are dealing with here - any chance of gentlemanly conduct with them is extremely remote.

Wouldn't be the first time a Labour Party member has tried to set up a National MP - just ask Bill English.

Reply
Share
  • 0
  • 0

Lets get it right David the Labour Party aided and abetted with their nefarious actions and the wee man Goff leading the charge are not really interested in Dr Worth ,the whole veiled assault is just a re-run of Labours actions last year with their smear campaign on John Key our elected Prime Minister,once more he is Gutter politics as practised by the Labour Party.

Reply
Share
  • 0
  • 0

I don't think this would be an isolated incident. Guys who behave as worth is alleged to have behaved usually have a long track record of similar behaviour.

That the National Party apparently sheltered this bozo for as long as they did says a lot about the party organisation.

That Worth lasted so long in the party, and was actually selected as the candidate for Remuera, is a pretty poor refelection on National Party management.

Reply
Share
  • 0
  • 0

Its nice to see some decisive action from Key, and no-nonsence stance on the behaviour of his team. A good example of leadership in an "uncomfortable" situation for the National government.

This is far and away better than the dithering of Gordon Brown over unethical MPs like Hazel Blears, or the rotation of favoured supporters under Clark as noted by the article.

Reply
Share
  • 0
  • 0

I'm a National supporter and I think this whole thing is great. I didn't vote for someone this stupid to be in parliament let alone hold a portfolio. If Labour has information on other National MP's that should be gotten rid of then I'm more than happy for them to bring it to light. Their reasons for doing so may be for political ends, but that's fine with me, I voted against all the scandals and deceit of the Helen Clark's government and I won't put up with it from John Key's either.

Reply
Share
  • 0
  • 0

This Worth character, one could tell from his faux paux speech on the India trip, confuses reality with vividly imagined. The poor the broken and the unemployed dont give a monkeys about the deliances This guy wanted to be left to his own devices .. nice credentials .. quality background.. we know best.. in reality he is a twat with low morals. the silly Trout who decided to go to a motel is hardly much better on the moral ladder.. happily married and going to a motel ...Mr Worth you have betrayed your Country when your Country needs good people more than ever.

Reply
Share
  • 0
  • 0

Please may this end quickly so we will not have to endure the PM attempting to get his tongue around tricky words as heard in his interview with Mary Wilson on RNZ last evening. Memo to John - the plural of text is texts - Texas is a rather large piece of land in the southern part of the USA .

Reply
Share
  • 0
  • 0

I can't help but think that John Key has made a big mistake here!

Given Worth's obvious wealth of experience in this area he should not have been dumped from cabinet he should have been moved sideways to become the Minister of 'Foreign Affairs' focusing on further developing closer working relationships with Asian / Indian interests.

Reply
Share
  • 0
  • 0

don't hold your breath. It takes a sense of honour and some morals to actually make that kind of stand. In Sth Korea where honour is a prized trait it's not unusual for a politician to throw themselves off a cliff in shame.

Worth(less) is a weasel of a man who preys on woman for sexual favours by misuse of power. Instead of following Roh Moo-hyuns example, he'll hang around trying to milk the system for all he can before being forced out.

Reply
Share
  • 0
  • 0

given a fair trial before he is hanged.

Reply
Share
  • 0
  • 0

Well, Phil Goff has been getting a free ride in the media as some righteous crusader. He slams John Key for waiting a week to act on the information. Then, we find the Phil Goff had been sitting on the information for over 90 days!! That's right! Over 90 DAYS!!!

Funny though, how the media have hardly mentioned this.

And why haven't they?

Because they were too quick to judge Mr Key for waiting a week. Now Mr Key looks like a saint compared to Mr Goff.

If Phil Goff thought the allegations were so serious etc, why did he not say anything for over 90 Days?

That is the real story that the media should now be pursuing!!

But alas, they won't.

It is time there was BALANCED reporting in the media.

Reply
Share
  • 0
  • 0

Why give the creepy crappy Goff any oxygen for a fantasy yet to be proven other than seeing a drowning politician .literally drown in his own body waste.

Reply
Share
  • 0
  • 0

I am a Nat. supporter usually but do not support Worth staying around. Dump him John. And there is that old woman-Phillis Goff-what a weak spineless little weasel-a pup from Cullen??

Reply
Share
  • 0
  • 0

I am a Nat. supporter usually but do not support Worth staying around. Dump him John. And there is that old woman-Phillis Goff-what a weak spineless little weasel-a pup from Cullen??

Reply
Share
  • 0
  • 0

Post New comment or question

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

NZ Market Snapshot

Forex

Sym Price Change
USD 0.7264 -0.0007 -0.10%
AUD 0.9566 -0.0018 -0.19%
EUR 0.6381 -0.0032 -0.50%
GBP 0.5662 -0.0012 -0.21%
HKD 5.6664 -0.0048 -0.08%
JPY 81.5830 0.0050 0.01%

Commods

Commodity Price Change Time
Gold Index 1246.9 2.870 2017-06-27T00:
Oil Brent 46.7 0.820 2017-06-27T00:
Oil Nymex 44.2 0.870 2017-06-27T00:
Silver Index 16.6 0.020 2017-06-27T00:

Indices

Symbol Open High Last %
NZX 50 7626.4 7629.1 7626.4 -0.02%
NASDAQ 6227.9 6234.3 6247.1 -1.61%
DAX 12586.1 12588.8 12671.0 -0.88%
DJI 21411.2 21440.6 21409.5 -0.46%
FTSE 7434.4 7434.4 7434.4 -0.60%
HKSE 25735.2 25821.4 25840.0 -0.61%
NI225 20149.2 20224.3 20225.1 -0.47%
ASX 5714.2 5757.3 5714.2 0.73%