NZ POLITICS DAILY: Why we need another Nicky Hager book

NZ POLITICS DAILY

Dr Bryce Edwards

Nicky Hager

Nicky Hager is incredibly polarising. There’s a lot of hate for him and his books. That tends to happen when you take on the Establishment and the political right – and they have good reason to regard him as an enemy. However, some of the criticism of Hager also comes from the left, even within the media and universities, where he is sometimes dismissed as a distraction or unreliable. 

Nothing could be further from the truth. Hager’s six existing books, together with an array of important news journalism, show him to be an exceptional investigator and public intellectual. 

The real value of Hager’s work is that it enhances the democratic process. His research is usually on the powerful in society, and helps us understand how that power is used. Of course it’s the nature of the powerful that they seek to wield their influence without raising public awareness. But in a democracy we need to know how society really works, why decisions are made, and how they are influenced. 

This is why in 2015 I contributed an affidavit to the High Court explaining why Hager’s work was in the public interest and needed to be protected from police actions – you can see this here: Bryce Edwards affidavit about Nicky Hager and Dirty Politics

Hager’s focus on media and political communications
It’s the traditional role of the media to investigate and hold the powerful to account. But the question is whether they do that very well. In New Zealand our political discourse is extremely thin and limited. In many ways, our news media do a very good job with the resources they have. But it’s not enough. We need other contributions to political debate and information. Ideally, this should include plenty of think tanks, NGOS, universities, and other parts of civil society. But these institutions are also relatively weak in regard to contributing to the health of democracy and politics.

That’s where Hager comes in. His research has always epitomised the role of the investigative journalist –dealing not with the day-to-day minutiae of politics and current events, but undertaking projects that require lengthy periods of research and analysis. No one else in New Zealand has been able to fulfil such a necessary role. 

The state of New Zealand’s media and political discourse has been a key concern in Hager’s work. Most of his books revolve around issues to do with political communication and information. The role of the media is normally central to his work – with the assertion that the media is either being manipulated by the powerful, or not carrying out its role inadequately.

Secrets and Lies (1999), the Hollow Men (2006), and Dirty Politics (2014) are centrally concerned with how news is manufactured and influenced by the powerful. Hager clearly has a very strong dislike for, and is strongly critical of, the public relations industry. This can be seen in the topic Hager chose for his 2012 annual Bruce Jesson Foundation lecture: Investigative journalism in the age of media meltdown: from National Party Headquarters to Afghanistan. Similarly, his 2007 talk at the Auckland Museum was on Propaganda then and now. And in 2008 he gave a very good lecture to sociologists, titled Imagining a world where the PR people had won. More recently, Hager talked at the University of Otago about problematic role of PR being used in government departments – see John Gibb’s news report, Inclusion, transparency urged

So there’s a very strong chance that his new book could be about media and political communications. After all, Hager has already stated in a late 2015 interview with Toby Manhire that the book he has been working on is “one of the most important projects that I could imagine in my life” – see: ‘A kick back against government intolerance’ – an interview with Nicky Hager

There is certainly a huge public appetite for critiques and criticisms of the media in New Zealand. A survey out last week showed the public’s trust in the media is plummeting. The annual Acumen Edelman New Zealand Trust Barometer measures public trust in the four institutions of government, business, NGOs, and media – and it is media that is the least trusted. Only 29 per cent profess trust in the media, and this is down from 38 per cent last year – see David Brain’s Trust in New Zealand 2017

State surveillance and the military
I’ve been reported as suggesting that the book could be about state surveillance – see Tracy Watkins’ Dirty Politics author Nicky Hager releasing new book. This is because spying is clearly one of Hager’s long-running interests. His first book, from 1996, was the very influential “Secret Power, New Zealand’s role in the international spy network”.

The NBR’s Rob Hosking also argues this is likely: “More likely, much more likely is something spy agency/espionage related. Mr Hager first made his name with the book Secret Power, in 1996, which outlined New Zealand's role in the Five Eyes network involving the US States, Australia, the UK and Canada. It remains his most important work, certainly because of its impact outside New Zealand, and his involvement and interest in spy related matters have remained high. Shot through as it is with the assumption that any spying done by any of those countries is ipso facto bad, it has nevertheless been highly influential” – see: Hager's latest book may be back to spies (paywalled). 

Hosking adds that “such a book would have international import right now, given Donald Trump in the White House and the wispy but discernible tendrils between Mr Trump and the Russian secret services”. 

Of course Hager has written about military themes before – especially with his book Other Peoples Wars (2011). And we live in times of heightened threats of conflict in certain parts of the world. In nine days’ time, Hager is participating in a Wellington panel discussion in conjunction with the New Zealand premier of John Pilger’s latest film about a looming military conflict in Asia and the Pacific between the US and China – see: The Coming War on China

Not about John Key
There is a lot of excitement about the prospect that the new book could be an expose of John Key, perhaps revealing “why he really resigned as prime minister”. As Rob Hosking says, “Mr Key is to give his valedictory speech to Parliament 24 hours after Mr Hager's book launch and there have been so many, mostly scurrilous, stories put around as to the ‘real’ reason Mr Key decided to stand down as prime minister that the announcement of another Hager book has been catnip for the conspiracy theorists” - see: Hager's latest book may be back to spies (paywalled).

This seems unlikely. Although Hager has said very little on what the book is about, these limited statements don’t seem to equate with a Key book. Hager has communicated that the new book is not a sequel to Dirty Politics, and in fact: "It is a completely different book” – see Isaac Davison’s Nicky Hager's new book released this week, 'completely different' to Dirty Politics

Hager has also stated that the book is not related to this year’s election. But certainly the book could have an impact on voting without it being directly about the election. A more wide-ranging expose of how government operates could be devastating for the National Party. And, of course, it’s worth noting that the Fairfax parliamentary press gallery journalists made a prediction at the start of this year, “There will be one more political bombshell in 2017 that will change the course of the election and install Andrew Little as prime minister” – see: The year that might be: Our political predictions for 2017

Labour leader Andrew Little is confident that it won’t be about his party – see Newshub’s New Nicky Hager book won't be about Labour – Little. Little praises Hager’s work: “Mr Little says Mr Hager's past books have contributed to the democratic process, and he's looking forward to seeing what he has in store this time.”

Finally, in a light-hearted Spinoff article, Toby Manhire canvasses possible topics of the new book, and suggests some betting odds – for example, it could be a book about Velcro (based on Hager’s clue that the topic is “gripping and important”), with estimated odds of 100-1; it could be about John Key’s resignation, 50-1; tax, 15-1; New Zealand’s involvement in war, 10-1; and state surveillance, 10-1 – see: Nicky Hager is about to publish a new book. What’s it about? Here are the odds


7 · Got a question about this story? Leave it in Comments & Questions below.

This article is tagged with the following keywords. Find out more about MyNBR Tags

Post Comment

7 Comments & Questions

Commenter icon key: Subscriber Verified

So many words.................

Reply
Share
  • 1
  • 0

Whatever you think of Mr Hager's politics, I think he does play an important role in New Zealand media. As Bryce says, "In New Zealand our political discourse is extremely thin and limited." I would add that there is a low level of real political engagement and willingness to debate issues genuinely. All too often debate becomes personalised, and reverts to a low level of argument about ideologies and so on. If we genuinely value living a in a democratic society, then the media's role must be to question critically, to dig deeper into the use of media by public figures to present accounts of successes, to put forward opinions, to perpetuate or gain public recognition and thereby enlarge the authority of position or opinions, to question, to analyse, to judge, to criticise including to test each other's views, opinions, judgments and findings, and to relativise. In short the role of the media in a healthy democracy should ideally never be to blindly or unquestioningly support a given ideology, political party, or prominent public figure, but rather to promote sensible engagement within the public debate for those who wish to participate. That means that just as Mr Hager raises questions, and points to issues of inconsistency, other parts of the media should be testing and considering the quality of his conclusions and concerns - should they not actually stack up under examination, then the remainder of the media community has been functioning appropriately for a healthy democracy. On the other hand if we simply write his views off to his political beliefs or other factors - ie playing the man not the ball, then that part of the media has taken the easy way out. An active media sector, as described, while essential to a healthy democracy, is, and should be uncomfortable sometimes, and, if there is sufficient competition within the sector, should scrutinise each other to shine the spotlight on the right places.

Reply
Share
  • 0
  • 0

Sorry Bryce.
NZ may need investigative journalism. Nicky Hager does not qualify. Journalists research, conduct interviews and give carefully thought through opinions all the time remembering their obligations to their readers. Hager does not seem to do any of the above...

Reply
Share
  • 0
  • 0

This is nothing but baseless ad hominem. "He doesn't bat for my team, therefore he's useless!"

Reply
Share
  • 1
  • 0

W do need another Hagar book,just not this one.

Reply
Share
  • 0
  • 0

Regardless of the views of Mr Hager, one simple fact remains. He has received, benefited and profited from the use of stolen materials. Further, Mr Hager doesn't bother to talk to those he writes about for their side of the story, and then to put icing on the cake, has the absolute gall to say he's concerned about privacy issues!

Reply
Share
  • 0
  • 0

It's sad when people will focus everything on trying to plug leaks rather than on the conduct that those leaks exposes, seemingly excusing any behaviour from those they side with. Very sad indeed for NZ's society.

Reply
Share
  • 0
  • 0

Post New comment or question

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

NZ Market Snapshot

Forex

Sym Price Change
USD 0.6890 -0.0059 -0.85%
AUD 0.9217 -0.0002 -0.02%
EUR 0.6318 -0.0042 -0.66%
GBP 0.5363 -0.0052 -0.96%
HKD 5.3607 -0.0459 -0.85%
JPY 76.5310 -0.6430 -0.83%

Commods

Commodity Price Change Time
Gold Index 1268.2 4.760 2017-04-26T00:
Oil Brent 51.8 -0.300 2017-04-26T00:
Oil Nymex 49.6 0.030 2017-04-26T00:
Silver Index 17.4 -0.230 2017-04-26T00:

Indices

Symbol Open High Last %
NZX 50 7335.1 7346.3 7335.1 0.11%
NASDAQ 6028.1 6040.9 6025.5 -0.00%
DAX 12466.5 12486.3 12467.0 0.05%
DJI 21010.0 21070.9 20996.1 -0.10%
FTSE 7275.6 7302.6 7275.6 0.18%
HKSE 24563.2 24637.8 24455.9 0.50%
NI225 19205.6 19250.1 19289.4 -0.25%
ASX 5912.0 5915.2 5912.0 -0.04%